That Wacky, Wacky Kristol Posted by Michael Cohen

It has almost reached a point where it is simply too painful to continue reading the weekly musings of Bill Kristol that pollute the Monday morning New York Times. But alas, I am a masochist.

In today's piece de resistance, Kristol argues that Democrats are not serious about governing, because a) they opposed the surge and argue that it is not working (it isn't) and b) they opposed retroactive immunity for telecom companies. Of course, Democrats have not taken the latter position on any sort of substantive grounds, such as believing the rule of law is important. Instead, "for the House Democrats, sticking it to the phone companies — and to the Bush administration — seemed to outweigh erring on the side of safety in defending the country."

So when President Bush made the statement below he was acting in the responsible manner that we've come to expect from our 43rd President.

There is a big part of the Democrat (sic) Party that is against giving our intelligence officers the tools necessary to protect America.

Thank god, responsible truth-tellers like George Bush are running this country.

There really is something precious about watching a man who has so breathlessly defended the Bush Administration preach about "responsibility" in government. After all this is the same Administration that brought us the bungled response to Hurricane Katrina and of course the Iraq War, which is now running into its fifth year of ever so competent and responsible management.

But thanks to Jonathan Chait over at TNR's Plank we have an even more resonant example of Bill Kristol's mendacity.

Does Kristol not remember his role in defeating health care reform in 1994, in which he told Republicans:

"At bottom this debate is now a political one," he wrote in a strategy memo on July 26. "Sight unseen, Republicans should oppose [the new Democratic bills]."

and in which he warned that successful passage of reform would "revive the reputation of the party that spends and regulates, the Democrats, as the generous protector of middle-class interests"? Please, Mr. Kristol, tell us more about how liberals should make highbrow intellectual arguments and take responsibility for responsible governance in opposition.

It's bad enough that the Times gave a weekly column to a partisan operator and thoroughly mediocre writer instead of the many competent conservative writers who would have jumped at the role. But does this hack also have to lecture the rest of us on our responsibilities as intellectuals? Were no members of the Gambino family available to write the ethics column?

Yup, that pretty much sums it up.

Comments

[Dave]

Your summary of his oped, which certainly does not even begin to cover what he wrote, just proves his point.

Can Democrats govern? Of course not.

Every major city has had a Democrat council since WW2. Point to one - just one - that is better off.

Every major city school district has, since WW2, had a Democrat Board. Point to one - just one - that is better.

Everyone knows Democrats can't govern. It's like gravity - your belief (or not) in the fact is irrelevant.

[Walid]

From Kristol's well written editorial : "The director of the Central Intelligence Agency, Gen. Michael Hayden, the director of national intelligence, the retired Vice Admiral Mike McConnell, and the attorney general, the former federal judge Michael Mukasey, are highly respected and nonpolitical officials with little in the way of partisanship or ideology in their backgrounds. They have all testified, under oath, that in their judgments, certain legal arrangements regarding surveillance abilities are important to our national security.""

In other words "Just trust us" which the Bush Administration has been saying for years while it proceeds to make the Judicial Branch an arm of the Republican Party, operate as far as possible from judicial review, operate in secrecy even in regard to trivial matters, all the while meeting opposition with constant and repetitive appeals to fear or "this is going to make it easier for terrorists to attack us". If a trusted president wants this immunity fine but if an imperial one wants it for his own personal aggrandizement having already collected other exceptions to the rule of law, then the answer's no.

[Steve Nesich]

Yes, once again the absolutely brilliant Billy Kristol (as opposed to the funny one who pronounces his name the same way) comes up with a complete gem!

You're right, Billy---it's easy for "outsiders" to criticize those who attacked and now occupy Iraq. It's also a breeze for the critics to speak out against Bush's violations of constitutional rights and civil liberties. The critics don't have to bear the heavy weight of responsibility, like we "adults" do.

Just like those pesky 19th Century abolitionists. It was so easy for them to criticize slavery. Meanwhile the clear-headed "adult" slaveholders and their defenders had to bear the gruesome weight of this awesome responsibility. So easy then for those extremist elements to say "Just end it."

I'm so glad that "adults" like Bush---and his enablers like Kristol---have demonstrated such responsibility, skill, judgment and leadership with their power. How easy for all of us to think that other choices might have been better for our country.

[masmanz]

If you really believe in the 'White Man's Burden' and the myth that the lesser races are 'half devil and half child' then of course you will agree with Bill Kristol. But, if you are a decent human being you will have to listen to others, treat them as equals, and stop dropping bombs to 'shock and awe' them into submission. A better governance does not mean using brute force.

[Bruce Schaper]

Bill Kristol claiming Dems can't govern? Did IQ's just get thrown out the window. Until two years ago, Republicans controlled the House and Senate and the Presidency. Under their governing. This nations finances are in the red, at war, and the middle class is shrinking. This is success?

[Walid]

From Kristol's well written editorial : "The director of the Central Intelligence Agency, Gen. Michael Hayden, the director of national intelligence, the retired Vice Admiral Mike McConnell, and the attorney general, the former federal judge Michael Mukasey, are highly respected and nonpolitical officials with little in the way of partisanship or ideology in their backgrounds. They have all testified, under oath, that in their judgments, certain legal arrangements regarding surveillance abilities are important to our national security.""

In other words "Just trust us" which the Bush Administration has been saying for years while it proceeds to make the Judicial Branch an arm of the Republican Party, operate as far as possible from judicial review, operate in secrecy even in regard to trivial matters, all the while meeting opposition with constant and repetitive appeals to fear or "this is going to make it easier for terrorists to attack us". If a trusted president wants this immunity fine but if an imperial one wants it for his own personal aggrandizement having already collected other exceptions to the rule of law, then the answer's no.

[cheap Perfect World Gold]

I spent much Perfect World Gold on the gift.
Buy Perfect World Gold for me as present.
Perfect World Silver
Perfect World money make me happy.

[aoc money]

When you have aoc gold, you will become strong. With conan gold, you can upgrade and admire by others. You can use age of conan gold to start the journey of the world. So, do not hesitate, let us move to buy cheap aoc gold

[cheap wow gold]

I am so glad to receive some wow gold and the World of Warcraft Gold is the gift as my birthday. Some of the warcraft gold is very attractive for me that I will buy wow gold to enter into the game because the gold is the key to the net game.

[dd]

I hope i can get Sho Online Mun in low price,
Yesterday i bought Sho Mun for my friend.

[rappelz money]

Many friends told me that in here can get rappelz money, and here you can also relax yourself. so i hope more and more players come here to buy the cheap rappelz rupees.

[luxury watches]

I am so with you,rolex watch
luxury watch

[Nicole Thompsen]

Om du funderare, att en kopia silver earrings inte är det högra primat för dig, då kanske dig bör betrakta denna. Och ta det extra försök eller gå inte ens att den extra milen som får någon fodder och information för att göra ett mer informed och mer bättre beslut, så att det inte finns några ånger som någonsin fästas till silver sterling silver earrings. Men om vi tar en kartlägga av de bäst, silver earrings SA ska bly- den. Alltid försök att ha en föreställa av en äkta silver earrings klocka, när du köpslår över internet. Också när du undviker kopian silver earringss som tillverkas i asiatiska länder, kan undvika ett raddaslagsmål. Ett nummer av klockor för kopiasilver earringsdatejusts är tillgängliga i marknadsföra, och några av dem har varit eftersökta för jumbon många år. Som klockalooksna gillar Daytona, som är endast tillgänglig på att vänta, begäran för dessa ledar- klockor för kopiasilver earringsyachten är fortlöpande ökande. En av de mest härliga silver earrings kopiaPatek Philippe klockorna ut du ska där som fynd, är Calatravaen. Hans fader var bestämd som väl den Avalon som precis igen lades på utkanten av gränserna, men därefter, gränserna var enorma och seemingly gränser-mindre, där verkade inte för att vara any synligt avslutar till världen att de kallade gränserna, var handelsresandear och affärsmän kom att möta och barter för saker, som de önskade eller behövde, som var fallet med kaffemanen och kopiasilver earringsklockan som var främre av honom. Om du får din silver earrings från någonstans annars, du behöver att vara medveten av den unika teckninggåvan i modellera som du är köpandet. Klockan för kopian för den silver earrings pärlan den ledar- kan vara ett unikt ting som ska has för kvinnor. För mest av kvinnorna som den jämna tillfredsställelsen överskrider, jämför till prissätta av klockan för kopian för den silver earrings pärlan den ledar-. En man, som föredrar att vara special till hans fru eller flickvän, klockan för kopian för den silver earrings pärlan den ledar- kan vara ett unikt långt. Klocka för silver earrings GMT-kopia. Bemanna vem förälskelse att leda ett glamoröst och trendigt livförsök att få den bäst saker. Dessa saker gör dem frånsett annat folk. Föregående endast överklassfolket kan leda sådan liv.

[cheap coach handbags]

Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!

[iedge]

Yeah! Each of us can emphasize that the columnist most like Kristol in his background as a political operative, William Safire, was obviously very different in his attentiveness to the means of expression...