Democracy Arsenal

« Looking on the bright side of an Iraqi Civil War | Main | Great Power Politics: India's ying and Russia's yang »

February 25, 2006

Iraq off the rails: should we stay or should we go?
Posted by Suzanne Nossel

For the last few months, since the Iraqi election in December, we've all lived with the sense that something bleak and horrible would happen to prove that the Iraq war effort truly was doomed.  The fear was driven by brooding conviction that despite the bright pronouncements of the Bush Administration about Iraq's standing up for itself, the country's weak security forces, unreliable leaders, ethnic fragmentation, militant clerics, and uncontrollable militias made the path to stability a bridge too far.

Now is time to dispense with the fear and start dealing with reality.  I've been talking for a long-time about the adverse consequences of Iraq's spiraling into a failed state.   I am convinced that all of these risks I listed out last August are still staring us in the face.    But what's becoming more questionable by the day are whether the 130,000 US forces in Iraq are any longer the finger in the dike they have been for the last 3 years.

Over the last few days, the principle concern in Iraq has not been violent and determined insurgents, but rather ordinary Iraqis - Sunni and Shiite - who have gotten caught in a escalating spiral of violence triggered by Wednesday's bombing of the Shiite Golden Mosque in Samarra.  Experts agree that American soldiers cannot interpose themselves between battling Sunnis and Shiites.

That's why, over the last few days, rather than trying to restore calm American commanders have largely kept their troops away from the hot-zones, knowing that a US presence would only further stoke tensions.  The Iraqi security forces, even if they possessed the skill and firepower to intervene, are so thoroughly riddled with partisan militiamen that they too may prove close to useless.   Some fear that if the conflict continues to boil, the Iraqi army may split apart.

Another major concern is the impact of these sectarian skirmishes on the formation of a new Iraqi government, a process that has already taken nearly three months  and has been setback significantly by the outbreak during the last few days.  Sunnis have formally pulled out of talks on how to allocate government ministries, and even if they return it seems unlikely that the Shiite victors will now readily turn over enough key ministries to allow for true power-sharing.

Some deep voices of Iraqi leaders have called for restraint, and its possible they'll manage to tamp down tensions.  This time.   But because they'll reassure ordinary citizens with the promise of protection from sectarian private armies, the crisis this week seems destined to repeat itself.

So where does this leave all our teeth-gnashing about whether the US should stay or go?  I have for the last six months or so argued that if an increasingly implausible set of conditions could suddenly arise, it would render our presence in Iraq a worthwhile bulwark against civil war.  I've proposed benchmarks for staying in, none of which appear to have been met.  Kevin Drum reports that we're now down from one fully combat-ready standalone Iraqi battallion in December to zero today.

At this point, on the one hand its starting to look like the US presence in Iraq isn't doing much good:  we're paralyzed in the face of the worst military crisis the country has confronted, our troops holed up in barracks for fear that getting involved would only make things worse.  On the other hand, were we to leave now in significant numbers, its hard to escape the sense that we'd be pulling out just as Iraq collapses.  Even the White House doesn't seem to have arrived at a way to spin this.

The hope is, of course, that Iraqi political leaders and clerics will succeed in their call for calm, securing a hiatus in widescale sectarian bloodshed.   If that happens, we need to look seriously at whether there's any justification for continuing to put American troops at risk.  The Administration's "strategy" - after dozens of reformulations and refinements - is failing.  Its possible that the tactics being used now could have worked if adopted earlier, but they aren't equal to righting Iraq in its present condition.  With a failing strategy, we will not succeed.

The only thing worse than Iraq as a failed state is Iraq as a failed state with 130,000 Americans living there.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c04d69e200d8345be26a69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Iraq off the rails: should we stay or should we go?:

» Evening Roundup from Political Animal
EVENING ROUNDUP....A few links to get you through the night: Did Germany provide the U.S. with copies of Saddam Hussein's planned defense of Baghdad? They say no, but the New York Times says yes. Suzanne Nossel: "The only thing worse... [Read More]

» Evening Roundup from Political Animal
EVENING ROUNDUP....A few links to get you through the night: Did Germany provide the U.S. with copies of Saddam Hussein's planned defense of Baghdad? They say no, but the New York Times says yes. Suzanne Nossel: "The only thing worse... [Read More]

Comments

The only thing worse than Iraq as a failed state is Iraq as a failed state with 130,000 Americans living there.

Perhaps not. How about an Iranian intervention in that same failed Iraq to assist Shiite allies in defending themselves against Sunni incursions into southern Iraq? That might be worse.

How about an Iranian occupied southern Iraq along with a Shiite revolt in eastern Saudi Arabia, ultimately bringing Iran and Saudi Arabia into direct conflict? That might be worse.

How about a Turkish invasion of northern Iraq to put down a Kurdish independence move, while the Kurds are at the same time attacked from the south by Sunni Arabs?

How about a successful Salafist-Islamist assault on the Hashemite monarchy in Jordan, as the militants flow freely back and forth from Jordan and the most radicalized sectors of Iraq? That might be worse. Imagine radical Islamists take power, with the assistance of allies within the military, revoke Jordan's peace agreement with Israel, and begin sending weapons and fighters into Palestine. That might be worse too.

How about streams of refugees pouring over Iraq's border, and the humanitarian nightmare that might create as the neighboring states resist accepting them? How about decades of Iraqi refugee camps, just like they have in Palestime? That might be worse.

How about massive sabotage of Iraq's oil infrastructure, oil wells burning as during the Gulf War, and a complete breakdown of shipping in the Arabian/Persian Gulf as conflict intensifies, all bringing skyrocketing global oil prices? That might be worse.

How about worldwide instability in global hotspots, as the world community's attention is diverted by the chaos in the heart of the Middle East? How about renewed strife in Kashmir, and military confrontation between nuclear-armed Pakistan and nuclear-armed India? That might be worse.

The main function of the US presence in Iraq now is to deter intervention by other states in the region, and to help secure Iraq's borders.

We can always imagine something worse, Dan. The question is, are our troops accomplishing anything long-term, or are we just breaking our army so we can pull out at a later date during a similar situation? As Suzanne says, it's hard to see much evidence of improvement so far. (No independent Iraqi battalions after almost 3 years of training!?)

If all we're doing is deterring neighboring states from intervening, we could probably accomplish that with half the force, maybe less.

If all we're doing is deterring neighboring states from intervening, we could probably accomplish that with half the force, maybe less.

Yes that's probably true Cal. And to be fair, Suzanne did mention that the problem might be 130,000 troops. I just want to raise the possibility that we may have to start thinking in terms of keeping a very bad situation from getting much worse, even if we give up hope of improving things.

Preventing a broad regional

Sorry, I didn't complete my last comment. The concluding fragment should read:

Preventing a broad regional war would be an important accomplishment at this stage, especially since we are the ones who set the cycle of escalation in motion through our intervention.

I've argued for the past several months the only reason to have any troops in Iraq is to supress a civil war.

I've thought that the US should deploy to protect the Sunnis from the Shiites, since they are the minority and don't have either the militias (either in or out of the Iraqi security services) to stop massive ethnic cleansing os Sunni areas. Ethnic cleansing is already being practiced on a more modest scale by Shiites.

But if US is going to order its troops to withdraw to its camps (as it did last week) while the Sunnis and Shiites fight each other, what good are they doing?

Continuing the occupation to deter a possible incursion from Iran isn't realistic because Iran already controls by one means or another the Shiite south and much of the Iraqi security services. The US would be fighting both the Iranian and Iraqi Army, and doesn't have nearly enough troops for that possibility.

How about an Iranian intervention in that same failed Iraq to assist Shiite allies in defending themselves against Sunni incursions into southern Iraq? That might be worse.

OK, how about that happening while 130,000 americans are living there? That might be worse still.

How about an Iranian occupied southern Iraq along with a Shiite revolt in eastern Saudi Arabia, ultimately bringing Iran and Saudi Arabia into direct conflict? That might be worse.

Yes, how about all that happening while 130,000 americans are living there? That might be worse still.

Etc.

Kind of like looking at various wishful thinking ideas and adding "and a pony", but in reverse.

I've thought that the US should deploy to protect the Sunnis from the Shiites, since they are the minority and don't have either the militias (either in or out of the Iraqi security services) to stop massive ethnic cleansing os Sunni areas.

Chuck, I think it doesn't make sense for US forces to try to protect sunnis from shias. Ever since the truce with the Sadrists, they've been fighting sunnis. Every sunni is a potential insurgent. We've bombed sunnis, strafed them, hit them with white phosphorus and the modern equivalent of napalm, we've occupied their cities, kidnapped civilians we thought looked suspicious, you name it.

Pretty much every time the US military has taken initiative in iraq since November 2004, it's been initiative against sunnis. And now we're supposed to protect them from our friendly shias? And we're suppose to trust them at our backs, assume that they'll let us protect them?

If we tried it -- our supply lines run through shia land. Our air supply routes go over shia land. If we're going to do things that annoy shias, well, look at the trouble we had convoying on those routes when it was sunnis doing IEDs, what should we expect when it's the bulk of the population against us?

We've been backing shias to the hilt for quite awhile. Maybe if we had some really smooth-talking diplomats we could get away with switching sides now. What do you think?

I'll have to remember this blog. Looks good.

Dan, I've been arguing to pull the troops our early before it was cool. Your argument about regional strife is not a bad one. In fact, it's the best argument I've seen yet for a US presence. However, Jack Murtha's Spec Ops/Kuwait plan does the job equally well to cover this scenario.

We're not likely to get any credit for the Iraq situation anytime soon in the Arab world, but sooner or later something really nasty is going to happen, and we're going to take the blame. Meanwhile, our leverage is only going to decrease.

(no independent iraqi battalions after three years of training!?)

For what it's worth, I don't think that there was enough focus on training to begin with because they didn't expect the local population to go along with the insurgency. They expected executions not ambivilance. I don't know how many battalions in the world are independent, but most of them are U.S.

My stupid prediction: The civil-war is a media thing, Iraqi's start to pull together (they still look forward to waving goodbye to the coalition) and end up joining NATO in one of the weirdest alliances ever.

Mike, the original idea was the iraqi troops would do the fighting and we'd supply them (and of course command them).

The problem we were trying to solve was that we were losing too many casualties, and also we needed more troops. The solution was to get iraqi troops and let them take the casualties. There was no interest in an iraqi army that could fight without our supplies, or for that matter without our artillery, armor, and air support. I doubt the concern came up explicitly that if they could fight independently they could fight against us, it was more that we simply never thought about planning for the distant day that we might pull out.

So now the problem isn't that they need battalions that are completely independent. The problem is that they don't have a battalion that can fight without our supply. And if we aren't there to give it, then the iraqi army just sort of evaporates even if the men are dedicated.

I've seen the claim that it takes *longer* to train the supply people. And we have a later start, supposing we've started that training by now. And of course it takes longer to train higher officers. Iraq has some guys with that training (probably not nearly as good as ours) but they're mostly sunnis and Ba'athists and not considered reliable.

Some people were saying we had to stay in iraq until the iraqi army was trained. But we never intended to leave and never intended the iraqi army to operate without our close supervision.

the american people will not much longer stand for the drain on our resources

not to mention that our army is tied down and cannot effectively respond to or do anything else; and given the resource drain, our military is effectively tied down

the latter situation is worse, unless you believe that there are really no other threats than the middle east

we cannnot persue this policy without a draft at the least


...hi

i believe that the united states should stay in this war, without this the world would end

There are certain things in life related to smoking that simply cannot :)
parça kontör
parça kontör bayiliği
parça kontör bayilik

My friends and I like to buy kal geons , because the kal gold is very useful to upgrade equipment. Only your equipment becomes better, then you can win this game. In kal online geons , you can buy everything you want in this game. Yesterday is my birthday, so my friends bought me some kal online gold as gifts. I am so happy.

It is the silkroad gold which make me very happy these days, my brother says sro gold is his favorite games gold he likes, he usually buy some silkroad online gold to start his game and most of the time he will win the silk road gold back.

Once I played 12sky, I did not know how to get strong, someone told me that you must have twelve sky Gold. He gave me some 12sky gold.

she like quiet and twelvesky Gold. she always read books in the library 12Sky Silver Coins.

or you can not go on this game without cheap requiem lant. If you get requiem online gold, you can continue this game.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

or you can not go on this game without cheap requiem lant

or you can not go on this game without cheap requiem lant

Newspaper by China printing is very good quality and good prices.
Plastic products made by plastic injection molding services with low costs and supeior quality
Shoring scaffolding for construction is a very useful tool.

ghd IV salon styler,ghd purple roll bag.


product features:


Auto sleep mode(A built in safety feature that gives you peace of mind by turning off if the ghd IV styler is left unallended for 30 minutes.)


Universal voltage(So that you can use your styler in any country without an adaptor.)


Advanced ceramic heaters(The ultimate heating technology for the ultimate shine and style creation.)

All our products are cheap,if you want to find cheap ghd,come here and that is right.


If you want to find GHD hair products,you can write GHD straightener,GHD hair straighteners,GHD straightners,GHD hair,straighteners GHD in google browse.

Chanel Handbags are woman’s dream come true.

Chanel, a fashion name that has become synonymous with femininity since 100 years, is on the must-have list of every fashion-conscious woman.? And we bring these must-have Chanel Handbags at never before discounts, just for you.

It is only when you come across an Chanel New Arrivals, do you realize the power of her words.? Chanel handbags are crafted not just to be trendy, but trend-setting.? Hardly has lived a celebrity who has not been seen carrying a Chanel handbag under her arm; such has the influence of Chanel handbags as a fashion statement.

Chanel handbags have been so popular in the elite classes of the society, that their pricing is usually prohibitive for everyone else.? Discount Chanel handbags are really difficult to come across, but today should be your lucky day.? We bring you a superb unbeatable range of Chanel Flap bags, all at fantastic discounts.? With us, you have an incredible chance to buy your favorite Chanel handbags at rock bottom prices!

Chanel Handbags have always been at the forefront of luxury and style.? The Chanel classic quilted leather handbags and its reinventions have ruled fashion since forever.? Chanel handbags have remained extremely popular as they continue to merge evolving modern trends with the class and simplicity of its original avatar.

An Chanel 2008 Collection and Chanel 2009 Collection single handedly enhances the look you are carrying.? The reason you would buy a Chanel handbag is own a bag that mingles with your charm and intensifies it with its inherent simplicity.? If you have owned an authentic Chanel handbag before, you know what we are talking about.? If you are one of the unlucky people who haven’t yet gotten a chance to own an Chanel Cambon, now is your chance to shop for an authentic Chanel handbag and discover its ability to transform your look completely.

Buy Chanel handbags with us, and get fabulous discounts which you will never get at your favorite store.? We offer cheap authentic Chanel handbags and they are all up for grabs!

Both sides of the symmetrical lines, wantonly flaunt a perfect Louis Vuitton handbagsline, in the right case, the border, from 9 o'clock to 12 o'clock position to develop a unique design to show the whole concept of asymmetry, resulting in visual surprise, crown, located in the the right to beautiful, 4 o'clock position of the bright red jujube board. Black dial with white silkLouis Vuitton handbags screen printing, second hand with red paint, resulting in the formation of brand image is more out of color.

Of couse we should go.Do you think so ?

bighaber strategy of confrontation and steam-rollering" which started when Bush went to the UN in September 2002 and is further demonstrated by his administration's strategy on issues such Cote

http://www.bighaber.com

thanks for sharing Sohbet many people are pay more attention to one's swearing than before, especially a watch.Muhabbet.
Perhaps when you went to some place far away Sohbet you must borrow it from friends you can get everything you want in this game Chat money to invest in other industry which will return you good profit. Sohbet when you look at Chat
the surface of the watches viaload great any cool Exsohbet from the city you live in and thought you knew nobody there Egitim Fourth, there were various signs of political conflict among shia. If they split 3 ways or 4 ways, the sunnis and the kurds could often be the Sohbet swing votes in the politics. If they felt they had political clout out of proportion to their numbers, they could settle in Sohbet and do politics and not feel oppressed.

Iraqi election in December, we've all lived with the sense that something bleak and horrible would happen to prove that the Iraq war effort truly was doomed. The fear was driven by brooding conviction that despite the bright pronouncements of the Bush Administration about Iraq's standing up for itself, the country's weak security forces, unreliable leaders, ethnic fragmentation, militant clerics, and uncontrollable militias made the path to stability a bridge too far.

I must confess your clarity broadened my sentiments and I will right away snatch your rss feed to stay up to date on any upcoming articles you might write. You deserve thanks for a job well done!

Will there be a conference in 2011 as well? It sounds very interesting to me and I would like to visit.

Will there be a conference in 2011 as well? It sounds very interesting to me and I would like to visit. online information technology degree

I trust that others will review other cases and the legal background of this question of stripping citizenship in times of war -- and weigh in.

Another major concern is the impact of these sectarian skirmishes on the formation of a new Iraqi government, a process that has already taken nearly three months and has been setback significantly by the outbreak during the last few days.

I trust that others will review other cases and the legal background of this question of stripping citizenship in times of war -- and weigh in

We are now possibly looking at having to have pleurodesis on the left and not sure what will happen or what is next if the fluid goes to the belly. Looking for insight from others who may have had same experience. Masters in education online

I think it's important that today there are still people who are responsible for disseminating messages and information as interesting as this, I am very grateful to have had the delicacy to share with me I served too! thanks ...

You helped me a lot indeed and reading this your article I have found many new and useful information about this subject.

There are lot of decision which cannot be taken in a while. Things need to be viewed more delicately.

paylaşım için teşekkürler

I am just now working on, and i am sure this will help me a lot..and I have been looking for such information since from few days....thanx!!!!!

yazılarınız ilgi çekici teşekkür ederiz admin...

I am just now working on, and i am sure this will help me a lot..and I have been looking for such information since from few days....thanx!!!!!

I am just now working on, and i am sure this will help me a lot..and I have been looking for such information since from few days....thanx!!!!!

Very good points you wrote here..Great stuff...I think you've made some truly interesting points.Keep up the good work.

Thanks for one's marvelous posting! I quite enjoyed reading it, you are a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and will come back down the road. I want to encourage you continue your great posts, have a nice weekend.

Very good points you wrote here..Great stuff...I think you've made some truly interesting points.Keep up the good work.

Congress might well encourage the Iraqis to hold such a vote on their own initiative. After all, last week, the majority of the Iraqi parliament, 144 out of 275 members, signed a petition calling for a withdrawal timeline.

We need to get out of Iraq as soon as possible. Nothing good will come from staying there.
canopies
mosquito magnet
caravan canopy
EZ Up Canopy
tents

its a nice article . we should go from iraq its necessary for us.

Every decision need to be taken with lot of precaution so that it does not affect the population.

first is the good news for Democrats is that they have some Presidential candidates who are probably aware of this lesson second is the bad

Only the Jews are constantly put on trial for wanting a Jewish State - though no other people has required a state of its own more than the Jews.

There are lot of decision which cannot be taken in a while. Things need to be viewed more delicately.

Where shall we go?

My website is in the exact same niche as yours and my users would genuinely benefit from some of the information you provide here. Please let me know if this ok with you.

I think you are correct and I am with you and of your same opinion. might be correct once you declare this particular

We supported the Haitian military and dictators for two hundred years, and then in 1990 Aristide came along and we got rid of him.

Shame on Google for no longer positioning this put up upper! Come on over and discuss with my website .

Thanks. I like this Blog and it is certainly the best post and this blog makes a lot of sense to other readers.

I can say. You organize the article very well and your writing ability is really wonderful.As an English learner, this post is a little too difficult for me to understand. I hope one day I could write such good articles

This is your great post.i liked your brilliant information.

The countries need to have lot of support to be able to solve all the problems.

A keen regard not only for the dignity of the oppressed but for those who will no doubt be made to suffer in the sullied name of redemption. Joe Klein, to his credit, keeps on talking about the chokehold political consultants

A keen regard not only for the dignity of the oppressed but for those who will no doubt be made to suffer in the sullied name of redemption. Joe Klein, to his credit, keeps on talking about the chokehold political consultants

A very good post indeed. It's a shame about some of the responses. A very good post and an excellent blog. I am now a follower. Thanks, Steve
Dissertations | Essays

Thank you so much for sharing a lot of this good info! Looking forward to checking out more posts.

Great Site, your plugins are very useful and save me a tonne of time.bhetgber

Thank you for nice information.. I am going to bookmark this page. Thanks again it was very helpful for me.

. I am going to bookmark this page. Thanks again it was very helpful for me. A very good post indeed. It's a shame about some of the responses. A very good post and an excellent blog. I am now a follower. Thanks, Steve

Thanks for your sharing,and you will enjoy the sunshine service

This is my Good luck that I found your post which is according to my search and topic, I think you are a great blogger, thanks for helping me outta my problem..

very good for me see it first time.i like it very much and and help me at least.

d but for those who will no doubt be made to suffer in the sullied name of redemption. Joe Klein, to his credit, keeps on talking about the chokehold political consultants

This is a wonderful site! I’ve been looking for something like this for a while now! Thank you!

I'm tipped heavily toward yours. And no matter, that's what is so great about modernized democracy and the marketplace of thoughts on-line.

I think they got the right person for the job. I definitely want this person running the show here. This is definitely an easy choice...

This is a very good news for the locals for the ones who are unemployed. I will make certain to bookmark this post.

This is my Good luck that I found your post which is according to my search and topic, I think you are a great blogger, thanks for helping me outta my problem..

I think they got the right person for the job. I definitely want this person running the show here. This is definitely an easy choice...

A very good post and an excellent blog. I am now a follower. Thanks, Steve

but for those who will no doubt be made to suffer in the sullied name of redemption. Joe Klein, to his credit, keeps on talking about the chokehold political consultants

It's really hard if the tension gets hot. I mean they are just facing each other.

But, we have to let them continue to keep their culture because we have to be open minded. Wolf whistles are cultural expression. So is martyrdom and getting 79 virgins upon death. Damn, female circumsision is also cultural expression so we have to allow that, too.

Are you one of those people who think we should seal off the borders (an imaginary line), if so you should look into the history of the great wall of china. Ill get you started, it was built at least three times, everytime resulted in it failing and ultimately led to the country being concured and ruled by its enemies. Nice precedent.

This is absolutely a commendable post indeed. You share splendid piece of information here. Thank you for attributing this informative post..!

Life outside is very difficult, especially now that prices such high, would like to out to dinner should be make good consider the following, alas, cups. .

Traces a long time ago there was a little girl, she lives comfortably, then it, like she hit a person, she rebelling against her family, now a man living outside.

Now life is not the same as before, and now a lot more constraints, is not not talk to their parents home a baby, is not married daughter spilled water, I do not think so.

I really enjoyed the way you wrote about this. It is not very often that I encounter such writing and I really just wanted to say that. That's all.

wow yes in wedding ceremony we get alot of gifts. and gift is the thing we make the relation stronger and
removes the distance among the heart not just on wedding occasion but also any time.

Thanks for sharing.You wouldn't say how some websites are helpful source of information like this one.Thanks

Actually I do not quite understand about this,but I know a lot after reading this article.

Agreed. Online commenting has the potential to be a powerful way to get quick feedback from those who agree and disagree from a variety of sources. Positive or not, it should be sincere and at the least thoughtful. So often it becomes a popularity contest.

Really all your information is good and specially the obsessions are brilliant!

Yes, the main aim is for webmasters to submit their sites to gain links and hopefully higher ranking on the search engines. Hope this answers your question, I am kind of new on the forums and still trying to gain knowledge.

our article was really interesting! I find that the new health care bill is very interesting and you really explained it well. I am a fan of this website and I will come back again. Thanks for taking your time to write suc a great article and inform all of us.

I completely agree with you. I have no point to raise in against of what you have said I think you explain the whole situation very well

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.

This weblog only allows comments from registered users. To comment, please Sign In.

Emeritus Contributors
Subscribe
Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Email: 
Powered by TypePad

Disclaimer

The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use