Democracy Arsenal

« Getting Obama Foreign Policy Wrong - Part II | Main | Saving The Responsibility To Protect From Future Libya Wars »

October 19, 2011

What's The Matter With Leon Panetta?
Posted by Michael Cohen

Leon_panettaThis past Friday, President Obama announced that he would be sending 100 combat equipped soldiers to Central Africa to help the governments of the region combat the Lord's Resistance Army, which is a particularly nasty and nihilistic terrorist organization that operates along the Ugandan border. It's a pretty straightforward intervention and one that is even codified in US law.

Yet here is what Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta had to say about it in an interview with CBS News:

 Pelley: Did you have reason to believe that this part of Central Africa was becoming a haven for terrorism?

Panetta: There are elements there that either have ties to al Qaeda or that represent the forces of terrorism on their own. And that's what's dangerous.

Why Leon, why?

The United States is not sending troops to Central Africa to combat al Qaeda (at the very least that's not what the President of the United States told Congress about why he was sending troops to Central Africa). The al Qaeda presence in the region is at best, infinitesimal.  Going after the LRA with 100 non-combat US troops should be defensible on its merits without some silly Al Qaeda angle thrown into the mix. So why would Panetta make a comment like this?  It all has the odor of a transparent effort bolster the domestic case for military intervention by linking it somehow to terrorism and al Qaeda. 

In isolation this gaffe would not be a huge deal, but it fits a disturbing pattern of misstatements and overblown rhetoric from Panetta. Back in July in his first trip overseas as Secretary of Defense he said that the US was in Iraq because of al Qaeda and 9/11; he also pledged to keep 70,000 US troops in Afghanistan until the end of 2014. The latter is in contradiction of US policy that was announced by President Obama only a month before and the former is in contradiction of the truth.

On the issue of keeping US troops in Iraq beyond the December 31, 2011 departure date Panetta has taken the odd approach of publicly negotiating with the Iraqi government in public - a surefire way to prevent any deal from actually occurring.

But it's on defense spending where Panetta has really gone off the deep end -- taking on maximalist, almost apocalyptic, positions including calling potential cuts "catastrophic," "draconian" "doomsday"-inducing and akin to America "shooting itself in the head."  This tracks with he said in August, when he wrote only days after the hard fought debt limit deal was signed that automatic cuts to the DoD budget "would undermine the military’s ability to protect America and its vital interests around the globe" and that such a move would "do real damage to our security." This is bizarre hyperbole, particularly sincePanetta hasn't identified a single way in which these cuts will "hollow" out the US military.

In fact, as Ben Armbruster pointed out recently when pushed to identify what risks would come from these reductions in current military spending (a fiscal outlay that far surpasses US spending during the Cold War) the best example that Panetta could point to was that the US presence in Latin America and Africa would have to be reduced. And why? Because according to Panetta the US would need to maintain a presence in the Middle East and the Far East.

It's funny that sounds a bit like "prioritizing" - no wonder it was so confusing to the head of the Defense Department.

In a speech last week at the Woodrow Wilson center Panetta offered a litany of "threats" that continue to face the United States, "terrorism, nuclear proliferation, rogue states,cyber attacks; revolutions in the Middle East, economic crisis in Europe, the rise of new powers like China and India."  It reads a bit like the Pentagon's current greatest hits.

According to Panetta, "all of these changes represent security, geopolitical, economic and demographic shifts in the international order that make the world more unpredictable, more volatile and, yes, more dangerous." That these words are practically identical to the ones spoken by Mitt Romney at the VFW convention in August are disturbing enough; that by any appreciable measure the world today is far less dangerous than any point in recent history only compounds the strategic incoherence of Panetta's statement.

I asked Bill Hartung, who is a Senior Fellow at the Center for International Policy and a defense budget expert how he would rate the absurdity of these comments on a scale of 1 to 10 . . . his response was 12.  And Hartung should know - he served on the Sustainable Defense Task Force which outlined about one trillion dollars in defense cuts over ten years that would NOT turn the military into a hollow force.

If one wants to argue that defense cuts will be bad for US military preparedness and national security that's obviously an appropriate argument (even if it is, in my view, wrong). But Panetta has gone far beyond that, employing scare tactics, fear-mongering and apocalyptic warnings to make his argument. Worst of all by suggesting that its not defense spending that should be cut, but rather entitlement spending like Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security he's basically siding with Republican lawmakers on Capitol Hill and undercutting the President and Democrats in Congress who are currently negotiating with Republicans about additional cuts to the budget. 

It's not enough that Panetta is using inflammatory rhetoric to make his case for preserving the Pentagon's bloated budget; he's also feeding Republicans the attack lines they can use against Democrats if defense cuts do actually occur.

All of this seems at pace with a Sec Def who seems preternaturally focused on making sure everyone at the Pentagon likes him. Whatever one thinks of Robert Gates tenure at DoD he at least occasionally demonstrated the ability to speak some difficult truths to the military. Panetta, on the other hand, seems more inclined to offer chest thumping and flag-waving. 

As Spencer Ackerman devastatingly pointed out last week his recent speech to the AUSA convention was a pander-ific performance that glossed over the reality of austerity politics and pledged that significant cuts in the DoD budget will "not happen on my watch.”

And then there was this, "This nation needs an Army that can deter any potential aggressor — an expeditionary Army able to deploy to distant battlefields and, upon arrival, decisively overwhelm any enemy land force,” Panetta said. “And if an enemy does challenge us in a conventional land war, we need an Army that can, as General George Patton used to say, ‘Hold the [enemy] by the nose and kick them in the ass.’” To listen to Panetta talk about the the threats facing the United States, the importance of a big ass-kicking Army and the need "to make sure that rising powers understand that the United States still has a strong defense" you'd think that either Panetta has been asleep for the past ten years or Max Boot is now writing his speeches.

It is almost as if Panetta is so desirous of approval from the military brass that he is going out of his way to sound as tough as he possibly can. Indeed, when he was in Iraq over the summer even the Washington Post remarked on his "salty" language and occasionally martial tone with the troops.

I understand that a new Secretary of Defense wants to be respected in the building, but Panetta is taking this way too far - and trying way too hard.  

Of course there's another explanation for Panetta's obsequiousness - he is deeply inculcated by the notion that Dems are vulnerable on national security and they must do a good job of seeming "tough" enough to run the military. After all, who can forget this priceless Panetta quote captured in Bob Woodward's "Obama's Wars" about Obama'sfall 2009 review of Afghanistan policy:

He told other principals, "No Democratic President can go against military advice, especially if he asked for it." His own recommendation would be, "So just do it. Do what they say." He repeated to other key White House officials his belief that the matter should have been decided in a week.  

If one didn't know better (and there really is not much reason to suspect otherwise) Panetta is another in a long list of Democrats whose inclination is to approach national security issues through the narrow prism of domestic politics. His public statements sound like those of a Democrat too insecure to talk sensibly about the future of the US military and national security policy.

Panetta is the first Democrat to be Secretary of Defense in more than 14 years he should start behaving like it, rather than a caricature of how Democrats are supposed to act on foreign policy and national security. 

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c04d69e20162fbc3a87f970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What's The Matter With Leon Panetta?:

Comments

Remember this will be Secretary Panetta's last government job. By doing and saying the right things, he can earn millions upon retiremet.

I think one of the major national security threats the squatting of the Congress and its inability to confront the problems that we face, "said Panetta near the end of a three-hour hearing by the House Armed Services Committee.

It is very important to choose a better Laptop Batteriesfor your laptop .

I like this blog. It is a rich content topic. It helps me solve a lot of problems. It updates at a very fast rate, and provides for me many opportunities. I think it can help me to solve many problems, thank you.

The military and political at present very confusion, lead to so many things.

Why would the sec of defense go against something his president said? For those who would propose defense cuts I think the real issue here is how do the US maintain a powerful force and assure national security despite the budget cut? I think a lot of people are really willing to cut some budget to get things going.

Matt,

I came over from Greg Sargent's link. I'm sorry, but you blew it with your analysis of the troops being sent to Africa. From the interview:

Pelley: Did you have reason to believe that this part of Central Africa was becoming a haven for terrorism?

Panetta: There are elements there that either have ties to al Qaeda or that represent the forces of terrorism on their own. And that's what's dangerous.

---

You commented that "The al Qaeda presence in the region is at best, infinitesimal." This is deliberately obtuse or betrays a poor grasp of geography. The LRA is active in S. Sudan and Uganda. Care to guess the neighboring country? Ding ding ding! Kenya. You know, the site of the embassy bombings in the late 90s. Care to guess another neighbor of Kenya? If you guessed Somalia, you get a gold star and a cupcake. Yeah, clearly an infinitesimal presence of radical Islamists there!

Leaving aside the basic issues of human rights (kidnapping of children and turning them into abusers), there is significant danger for forming safe havens for terrorists. When the basic facts laid out to build your case are so wrong-headed, it's difficult to take the remainder of the analysis seriously.

BB

I understand that a new Secretary of Defense wants to be respected in the building, but Panetta is taking this way too far - and trying way too hard.

It's a mistake green lieutenants often make. You want to be loved by your troops but instead you loose their respect. Disciplined breaks down because everyone knows they can walk all over you. Most new lieutenants eventually figure it out with a little help/ butt kicking from their superiors. But if they don't they remain ineffectual and are sifted to some backwater staff position until they can be eased out. Paneetta is way too old to be making these kind of rookie mistakes. With the budget storm brewing and a need for the military to make hard choices he is sending the wrong message. He needs to be replaced ASAP.

Here's the issue: If the supercongress does not identify a solution, the defense budget will be decimated (as well much of the new deal programs). All Panetta is doing is keeping this dynamic up front so that the supercongress negotiators and the U.S. public see the implications of not doing a deal. I'm sure this is a tactical move that is coodinated within an overarching Obama strategy to get a deal done. We're watching a chess game here, and the rook is making it's position known.

It's quite admirable that Obama believes a deal is in the best interest of the country and is trying to hurd the cats in the right direction.

If the supercongress does not identify a solution, the defense budget will be decimated

Your real dedication to getting the message all through was really beneficial and have really permitted most people just like me to realize their goals.

I love this website is great aswell.

http://www.wholesaleprojersey.com/

アジア杯の上の惨敗は私達を中国のサッバスケットシューズカーの立ち後れることがはっきり見えさせて、日本のサッカーはすでにみごとに世界に向かいました。アジア杯の(以)後で、pumaは日の本文で霊感の2足のサッカーシューズに変わることを出しました――PWR-C1.10 TokyoとV1.10 Kanji。PWR-C1.アウトドアシューズ10 Tokyoは東京街頭の文化を霊感にして、下手な字を書く方法は日本語の“東京”の印を白色の靴の表面の上にあります。V1.10 Kanjiの中Kanjiは日本語の“漢字”の意味です。設計者は漢字の“高速”の印を靴の表面の上で、際立っているV1.10のスナイキ ジョーダンピードは思います。哀れみを誘うのは中国の文化の代表の漢字にするのが意外にも日本の文化の元素にして今回の付けてはいけない設計の霊感の出所になったのなのです。見たサッカースパイクところサッカーシューズの領域にもっと多い発言権を持ちたくて、中国のサッカーの後れているレベルは最大の妨害です。

thank you for share it will help me a lot :)

Welcome to the second installment of DA’s exploration of where Mitt Romney stands on the foreign policy issues of the day. With Senate passage earlier this week of a bill to pressure China to appreciate its currency and the three long-awaited free trade agreements passing last night, trade is the issue d’jour.

It is nice to know this. Thanks for the time and effort. It is well appreciated. More to come.Good share,you article very great, very usefull for us…thank you

I was very fantastic why i not see your blog before i will come back.

This girl is really good looking but nasty. However, she has some talents. That’s why people still love her.

The good news is that there is a plethora of great books out there targeted to hungry leaders who want to do better this year than last. If you belong to a networking group or other professional club

I recently decided to make a short video about this, I would be appreciative if you would maybe take a second to watch it and perhaps leave a message about what you think, I left the video url in the “website” field, hopefully you can access it, thank you a lot.

バーバリーマフラーはリーズナブルな価格で、裁縫や原料などの品質も上質の仕上がりとなっています。バーバリーハンドバッグはファッションの象徴、デザインがユニーク。バーバリー アウトレット
商品は品質がいい、価格が高くない。バーバリーマフラーはおしゃれのみならず、実用性が高いです。バーバリー財布のスタイルもまちまちです。チェック柄のは一番人気と思います。バーバリー アウトレットは最高。

日本にエルメスを買うことは安くないよ。エルメスバッグは全国レディースの最愛です。持っている人は、もっと気質があると思います。エルメス財布の販売はレットファッションの表現です。人々の需要
を満足させます。ウールエルメスバーキンは1匹当たりいくらですか?インタネットで、エルメスバーキンの価格は高くないと思います。エルメススカーフ通販店は東京、大阪、名古屋などの地方もあるで
しょうか?

Rudolph Dassler and Adolf Dassler were brothers with big dreams in a war ravaged Germany. Wanting to do their part for the fatherland, both brothers served their time in the army and found a small shoe factory in the back of their house in their mother's laundry. In the 1936 Olympic Games

Hi, nice post thanks , great site !

The nomination of the winner depends on the capability and spirit of the personality to finish the race.I like the post very much as it contain informative in knowledge.I like pics of Chelsea shares of the beauty of running in Madison, Wisconsin.I want to congratulate the winner for the nomination race.I want to know suggestion from others.

Ladies classic pirate costumes can be used in several places. The main parts of costumes are for birthdays, anniversaries and special events. Why not tell it fun or scary, with Pirate Party Costumes and laugh at all or on the edge of the seat is the choice is yours.

Excuse me, you of the blog address??? What???

Hello!I am glad to here, Good Site! Thanks you!

very well,thanks

fantasy news ,thank you

Nike har kommet opp med et nytt produkt linje, kalt Nike Air Force One. Nike har alltid vært forbundet med idrett. Nesten alle produktene er ment spesielt for billige nike sko
visse sportslige aktivitet. Dermed forbrukerne er litt overrasket over å finne denne nye linjen av nike sko norge
sko å være helt annerledes. De er ikke joggesko, spor sko, eller sykkelsko. I stedet blir de bare Air Force One sko

adiPUREとadiZERO最初に考えたのを持って来るために、ミズノ サッカー過去に確かにadidasのサッカーシューズの2つです、そして2011年から2つの用語はもはや排他的なサッカーのシリーズはありません。 サッカー アディダスadiPUREとadiZEROのバスケットボールシューズの出現をされているとして、アディダスのテニスの製品ラインもadiPURE PROとadiZEROフェザーは、2つの新しいテニスシューズをオープンしました。Adidas サッカースパイクカテゴリーは違いますが、家族の特性が接続されていますが、adiPURE PROは、外観の古典的なシンプルさと性能の全体的なバランスをもたらす、とadiZEROフェザー好調ファミリは、スピード感を持って最も鮮やかに反映さadiZEROなります。Nike サッカースパイク靴のファンの可用性の認識の考え方の概念を作成し、唯一の私たちが待って見ることができるようにフルラインの製品ラインを持つこのサッカーシューズなど

i wonder, if hundred solder will be enough for these kinds of mission. why the US send more solder to get control about this place.


I am going to bookmark this for my future needed and also i will tell my friends to check this post. Thanks a lot for sharing.

Great job! Keep working! useful post, thank you

If you have been issued with a winding up petition for your company because the company owes money. You can pay the money owed before the court date and get the case droped or fight it if you believe it to be worth defending.

a huge deal, but it fits a disturbing pattern of misstatements and overblown rhetoric from Panetta. Back in July in his first trip overseas as Secretary of Defense he said that the US was in Iraq because of al Qaeda and 9/11; he also pledged to keep 70,000 US troops in Afghanistan until the end of 2014. The latter is in contradiction of US policy that was announced by President Obama only a month before and the former is in contradiction of the truth.

On the issue of keeping US troops in Iraq beyond the December 31, 2011 departure date Panetta has taken the odd approach of publicly negotiating with the Iraqi government in public - a s
Full software


Good stuff as per usual, thanks. I do hope this kind of thing gets more exposure.

Superior quality with low price! Free shipping with fast delivery.Cheapest beats by dre headphones sale With FREE SHIPPING,sound wonderful high performance headphones,buy now!

Obama, since his first day in office - has been actively trying to restore US engagement and influence in Asia, especially in Southeast Asia


This is all very new to me and this article really opened my eyes.Thanks for sharing with us your wisdom

I have no desire to talk on a network with a bunch of strangers.

More information from Leoch International, a manufacturer of lead acid battery, supply ups battery, gel battery, vrla battery, and so on. http://www.leoch.com


nice post , i like it , thanks for sharing it . have a nice day.

Great job! Keep working! useful post, thank you

【my-lady.jp】のアグ ブーツはキッズも、レディースも、メンズもよくぴったり新作はいよい よ入荷中...UGG ムートンブーツ,UGG ブーツは通販激安ing…phoenixzon.com

rakanet.comモンクレール 新作 2011 登場,当サイトMonclers.jpが激安な価格で男女共に人気のジャケットなどを販売しておりますジャケット通販激安,それに品質もよい、ご来店をお待ちしております

モンクレール通販の専門店モンクレール販売店です。品質が完璧、値段が激安、いろんなサイズが揃って、最も多様な選択空間を提供いたしており、お客様に気楽なショッピングを享受させるだけでなく、より美しく暖かい冬を過ごせます。Monclermaya.jp

楽しめる!Monclerxx.comは最新UGG、クリスチャンルブタン、モンクレール等を通販専門サイトです.豊富な品揃え格安価格で販売しています.

モンクレール 新作 2011 登場,当サイトMonclerss.netが激安な価格で男女共に人気のジャケットなどを販売しておりますジャケット通販激安,それに品質もよい、ご来店をお待ちしております

モンクレール ダウン 新作 2012 登場,当サイトFashionsmonclers.comが激安な価格で男女共に 人気の ジャケットなどを販売しておりますジャケット通販激安,それに品質もよい、ご 来店を お待ちしております.モンクレール人気激安通販専門サイト!

Moncler専門店モンクレール販売店です。moncler(モンクレール)品質が 完璧、値段が激安で提供いたします、より美しく暖かい冬を過ごせます。Moncler-s.com

ugg(アグ)ブーツ専門店UGGブーツ販売店です。ugg、UGGブーツ、アグブーツ品質が 完璧、値段が激安で提供いたします、より美しく暖かい冬を過ごせます。Shineugg.com

Majestueux sujet, merci de nous le faire découvrir. Également, votre site a-t-il un flux RSS disponible ? Pouvez-vous me l envoyer via email svp ? Merci

chiffre résultat loto lotomillions loto en ligne euromillions en ligne

--
camilla euromillion

great information you write it very clean. I am very lucky to get this tips from you.

I look for such article along time,today i find it finally.this postgive me lots of advise it is very useful for me .i will pay more attention to you ,i hope you can go on posting more such post, i will support you all the time.

yes its really nice article.

good arctile , thanks for sharing it and please keep doing this good job .


Reduce the health club membership and stick to individuals classic exercises

It makes me feel so surprise.I never know there is such a wonderful place that I can find what I need

nice post, thanks for share!

Nice one! Never thought of it. I used to add on delicious, but your idea is more better.

this is such a very intriguing article. I specially love this part 'In a speech last week at the Woodrow Wilson center Panetta offered a litany of "threats" that continue to face the United States, "terrorism, nuclear proliferation, rogue states,cyber attacks; revolutions in the Middle East, economic crisis in Europe, the rise of new powers like China and India." It reads a bit like the Pentagon's current greatest hits."..more developments will be coming

This is the face of a guilty man!

No, this is a man who's really trying too hard.
Bad comedian.

Have you ever felt that Microsoft Office a game needed or lacked a certain element to it?

I am so happy to read your post , I like it and thanks for sharing it .

All Panetta is doing is keeping this dynamic up front so that the supercongress negotiators and the U.S. public see the implications of not doing a deal..

I am so happy to read your post , I like it and thanks for sharing it

Good stuff as per usual, thanks. I do hope this kind of thing gets more exposure.

good arctile , thanks for sharing it and please keep doing this good job

A man can fail many times, but he isn't a failure until he begins to blame somebody else.


It is a good post , I like it and please keep writing .

Air Jordan is produced by Nike.new jordans It is known as Jordans and a famouse brand of shoes at the same time. Air Jordan Fusion shoes has been accepted better than many people though.cheap Air Jordan Fusion Shoes.The Air Jordan Fusion Shoes is a part of the 23 years celebration,combining Air Jordan and Air Force basketball sneakers Wholesale Nike Free Run Shoes into one new designer shoes. Selected material and soft sole promise the comfrtable and breathable wearing. This kind of Air Jordan Shoes wholesale brings you self-confident as well as comfortable. Take an example. The Air Jordan 6 is released in late 1990/early 1991,which is the most popular in NBA court.The Air Jordan 6 has beautiful outside. A lot of fans of NBA also love this Air Jordan 6 shoes.wholesale Air Jordan 1 is also one of the classical and also popular style people like as well as cheap Air Jordan 26.

 


Whether it is summer or winter, bag is the forever core for you, not mention those stars. Today's topic is about bags. Do you know accurately how to choose the most suitable bag for yourself?cheap designer handbags What's the popular colour and style nowaday? Let's learn something toghter.Forever classical black wholesale designer handbags and brown is classical and never be out of the date, such as the China wholesale LV bags. Red and lovely pink attract others' eyeballs.Big bags huge sapce. Elegant one is necessary just as brand Gucci handbags. Cool and fashion style is also the must. Luxury materials creat luxury bags, just like China cheap Juicy handBags. On the top of these, Prada also cann't be forgotten. Not all of Prada Fall 2011 is furry. designer Prada HandBags. You will find a lot of latest styles that there is must one you like.

In the year-plus NFL Hatssince commissioner Roger Goodell Dallas Cowboys et al began cracking down, the game, however,Oakland Raiders Detroit Lions hasn’t descended into flag football as some doomsday predictions claimed. Pittsburgh Steelers It looks about the same,just hopefully with less brain damage. That said, Harrison,New Orleans Saints even with his history of similar actions,Miami Dolphins faasfa01 is making a split-second decision in the heat of a wild football game Atlanta Falcons. McCoy was out of the pocket,Buffalo Billswith the option of running down field in a tight game with playoff implications.New York Giants Harrison has to answer for his poor tackling form – perhaps by sitting during next's Monday's New York Jets showdown at San Francisco. It doesn’t mean the league should absolve itself for the situation,Dallas Cowboys Boston Celtics Hats though.Houston Texans
San Francisco 49ers Indianapolis Colts Chicago Bears
Denver Broncos Minnesota Vikings Kansas City Chiefs Green Bay Packers Baltimore Ravens St.Louis Rams Cincinnati Bengals Seattle Seahawks San Diego Chargers Arizona Cardinals New England Patriots Tampa Bay Buccaneers Cleveland Browns Washington Redskins Jacksonville Jaguars Philadelphia Eagles Tennessee Titans Carolina Panthers

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.

This weblog only allows comments from registered users. To comment, please Sign In.

Emeritus Contributors
Subscribe
Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Email: 
Powered by TypePad

Disclaimer

The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use