Options for Gaddafi Posted by James Lamond

With the world sitting in anticipation for the news of Gaddafi's arrest it is worth taking a look at his options going forward. In June the International Criminal Court accused Gaddafi of inciting his troops to commit mass rape, and indicted him, his son Saif al-Islam and his intelligence chief Abdullah Sanussi with charges of crimes against humanity including the murder of hundreds of civilians, torture and the persecution of innocent people. Gaddafi could also face the consequences of his 41 year of authoritarian rule, his system of bribery, enriching himself and his family with the country's oil money and support for international terrorism. So what are the options going forward?

The exile option - a favorite for dictators - seems unlikely. Early on there were reports that South Africa might provide him with asylum. That has since been proven not to be the case. South Africa, as signatory to the ICC, would be required to arrest and extradite him. With 116 signatories to the ICC, there are few hiding places for the ousted Libyan leader. Zimbawe and Angola seem to be the most likely options, neither is a signatory. 

If Gaddafi does not make it out of the country and is in fact taken alive, he will have to face a trial. The big questions is whether this is tribunal from the ICC or if he will face a local Libyan court. Ideally it would be up to the Libyan people who would deliver justice to the man who persecuted his own people. This would provide closure, help with stability, and help provide legitimacy to both the legal process and the new government. The main problem, however is that the Libyan judicial system is essentially nonexistent after four decades of autocratic rule. 

Stewart Patrick makes a strong argument for ICC jurisdiction: 

“The problem, of course, is that a country must have a competent judicial system to undertake such trials in an unbiased and professional manner. The Rome Statute of the ICC accepts this logic, by embracing the principle of complementarity. That is, the Court can claim jurisdiction on one of only two conditions: when the country lacks a functioning judicial system, or when state authorities have manifestly failed to carry out a credible investigation into alleged atrocity crimes.

"If there were ever a strong case for ICC jurisdiction, it is Libya—a country with no functioning judicial system after four decades of arbitrary, dictatorial rule. Given the monumental governance challenges confronting the TNC, it could take years of international assistance before the Libyan state is capable of conducting a credible trial of Qaddafi and his henchmen. And yet there will be enormous pressure, given the understandable thirst for retribution, for the TNC (or its immediate successor) to fast-track Qaddafi to trial in a judicial proceeding that could become a farce.”

Meanwhile, U.S. policy is that the Libyan people will have to decide whether to try Gaddafi themselves for crimes against his people, or surrender him to the ICC. My thoughts are that the Libyan people have continued to step up to the plate beyond many people’s expectations and they may very well do so here. Column Lynch points out however that this is turning into a bit of a turf battle.

There are very serious concerns about a trial becoming a tool for revenge rather than reconciliation and justice. As Michelle Bowers warns regarding Mubarak's trial in Egypt: 

"The drive for retribution and punishment must not eclipse the need for truth telling, accounting, and transparency... While punishing the old regime for its crimes is necessary and important, the prosecution of deposed officials will ultimately prove an empty victory if the process does not help consolidate a new and meaningful democratic order that ends impunity, reconstructs state-citizen relations, and institutionalizes accountability and rule of law."

Stewart also lays out a series of options and hybrids, two of which I think are especially worth highlighting: 

"Under a fourth scenario, the UNSC could weigh in not on the side of the Court but the TNC, invoking Article 16 of the Rome Statute, which permits a one-year deferral of any ICC prosecution, to suspend ICC proceedings. This could allow the new Libyan authorities time to put into place new institutions and mount their own trials. The downside of this option, as suggested above, is that one year is an awfully short time horizon for getting this done.

"A final scenario would be for the UN Security Council to create a hybrid trial, along the lines of the Special Court for Sierra Leone, which was set up jointly between that country and the United Nations. This option would essentially split the difference: allowing the trial(s) to occur in Libya itself, while providing sufficient external judicial expertise, as well as financial and other resources, to ensure a credible, professional proceeding."

I think these options provide a nice balance. But ultimately it should be up to the Libyan people and the new government, this is their revolution. The new government will face a range of major tests, from creating a system of government where the various groups that make up the TNC feel they all have a stake in the new system to creating order and stability to performing basic functions like trash collection. These tests will allow a new government to develop its legitimacy among the people. The Gaddafi trial is just one of these tests. He was such a looming figure for so long, that if the new government feels they have the “capacity + ability to administer impartial justice”, as Michael Hanna put it, it should.

Comments

[randy moss jersey]

I find errors in this blog a bit, but it caught my attention, after I thought I would let you know, I really like it. I like this post, and will subsribing to your RSS feed.

[Vestidos de Noche]

Vestidosnow es una tiendas de vestidos de fiesta. Tenemos experiencia de muchos a?o en las Vestidos de Coctel. Les ofrecemos variedades de vestidos formales, Vestidos de Noche. Tenemos experiencia de muchos a?os en las vestidos de fiesta online, vestidos para graduación, vestidos de baile, así como vestidos de fiesta cortos. Todos son de precios económicos pero de alta calidad.

[sbobet]

I find errors in this blog a bit, but it caught my attention, after I thought I would let you know, I really like it. I like this post, and
sbobet 7m Livescore แทงบอล ผลบอล คาสิโน คาสิโนออนไลน์ sbobet

[jerseys]

I visit your article every sector is very clear and great information

[Canada Goose Jackets]

Many thanks for the article. I will have a link back to this information from our fresh blog.

http://www.cheapcanadagooses.com

http://www.cheapcanadagooses.com

http://www.cheapcanadagooses.com

[cheap nfl jerseys]

Hello,your post are very helpful.

[yiwu market]

Dream what you want to yiwu dream；go where you want to go；be what you want to yiwu china be，because you have only one life and one chance to yiwu agent do all the things you want to do.

[cheap nfl jerseys]

Cool,I like this post.Thanks!

[Rift Gold]

Tenemos experiencia de muchos a?os en las vestidos de fiesta online, vestidos para graduación, vestidos de baile, así como vestidos de fiesta cortos. Todos son de precios económicos pero de alta calidad.

[Cheap Coach Purses]

Vestidosnow es una tiendas de vestidos de fiesta. Tenemos experiencia de muchos a?o en las Vestidos de Coctel. Les ofrecemos variedades de vestidos formales, Vestidos de Noche. Tenemos experiencia de muchos a?os en las vestidos de fiesta online, vestidos para graduación, vestidos de baile, así como vestidos de fiesta cortos. Todos son de precios económicos pero de alta calidad.

[r4 card]

Thanks for the insight. You are absolutely right.

[abercrombie and fitch]

The only way to differentiate yourself from the competition is through service.

[Nike Dunk Shoes]

Everyone’s familiar with the ebay.com, a popular b2c website, which plays a very important role on online business. In the same way, we strive to provide a better place to all our customers: not only satisfying your needs and expectations, but exceeding them.

[New Jersey Devils Jerseys]

Hello, I like this. It is really helpful to me. If you are looking for others Ican try to help mine the link. Please test my hyperlinks, you will be able to create a things you like. Thank you.

[rolex watches]

An earthquake measuring 6.1 on the Richter scale jolted off the south Pacific islands of Vanuatu on Monday morning (21:44:21 GMT on Sunday), the U.S. Geological Survey said.The epicenter, with a depth of 59.40 km, was initially determined to be at 19.1556 degrees south latitude and 168.6960 degrees east longitude.A powerful earthquake measuring 7.0 on the Richter scale struck off the island nation of Vanuatu on Sunday morning (2255 GMT Saturday).

[yemek tarifleri]

I’ve just lately started a personal site, the data you posted on this site has helped me tremendously. I want to thank you for your entire time and work.

[Green Bay Packers Jersey]

I accept your article, you made all the concepts. They are very convincing, certain work. Nevertheless, the positions for beginners are too short. You may only extend them from the next bit? After thanking.

[Merchant Cash Advance]

Hi,
Thanks for sharing this post with us. It's really an amazing post. Keep posting the good work in future too.

[replica louis vuitton handbags]

Great job! Keep working! useful post, thank you

[best watches replica]

Wheat yesterday traded with the negative node and settled -0.21% down at 1138.6 and prices are expected to remain steady as prices have touched bottom and are trading below government-set prices and a further correction is unlikely. Higher stock position with the government due to a record harvest in 2010/11 season is hurting the sentiment and is preventing prices from going up. On July 1, India's wheat stocks in government warehouses were 37.1 million tonnes, well over its target of 17.1 million. India's wheat output for 2010/11 season is estimated to hit a record high of 84.27 million tonnes.

[women jordan heels]

Great job! I'm looking for this information a long time, I found it here.I am a lucky man, to be honest, 'really important to me. Thank you forsharing with us its kind.Very good indeed.

[links of london]

They could be created after the buttocks, penis,links of London breasts, and vagina. These not only remind your special someone about your great sex life, but it can also make your man or woman proud. Individuals that wear this kind of links of London uk jewelry are the ones who can't stop thinking about their sex life because it's too great to forget.If you're searching for a longer and much more gratifying sexual relationship with that unique someone, sexual jewelery is certainly the best method to achieve that. links of london sale Do not let your hesitation get the best of you. Try it out and encounter the magic it brings first hand. Sex experts have been suggestions to thousands of couple worldwide. links of london charms Porn stars wear them to enhance their sexual encounter and advertise their sexual prowess to their fans. There is no better way to spice up that old campfire sex life. links of london bracelet Go ahead and pour a gallon of gasoline over your relationships sexual flame and become your partner's ultimate sexual pleasure.

[chaussures femmes]

We have gotten many great comments from our customers and earn a good reputation in foreign makerts, more than 90% customers are satisfied with our products and service, till now our online members are beyond 80,000. As of right now, we Replica Handbags currently serve customers from over 18 countries, and we are still growing. We really hope to expand our business through cooperation with individuals and companies from around the world.

[lidia]

Los vestidos de fiesta son tan hermosas, espero poder comprar un vestidos de fiesta baratos hermosa y barata para el día de mi boda o en otras ocasiones. Gracias por tu parte.

[ugg retro cargo]

Very useful article for me, there is more information I have is very important. Thank you! I'm glad you could get out of it to share with us.http://www.bootstrade.ca

[oms shoes]

Very informative post. Looking more to something similar to this new designer sunglasses.

[best watches replica]

Chelsea boss Andre Villas-Boas has warned misfiring striker Fernando Torres that he has two more matches to improve his game or face being dropped.

Villas-Boas has insisted that he will not jeopardise his team’s ambitions for the sake of an individual.

The Daily Mail quoted the Portuguese, as saying: “I have no problem dropping players. You have to persist, but it can never compromise the objectives of your team and the things you want to achieve.”

[ac adapter]

Villas-Boas has insisted that he will not jeopardise

[luxury handbags]

your opinion is right! I support you! I will let my friends to read!

[Cheap nfl jerseys]

Your post is always helpful for me.

[film izle]

thankss

[Discount UGG Boots sale]

The article in your blog reminds me some old memory .That is good .It gives me happy .I think we will have a harmonious talk.Do you agree?

[coal crusher]

I found it here.I am a lucky man, to be honest, 'really important to me. Thank you forsharing with us

[Handbags]

The nice thing about standards is, there are so many to choose from.

[best replica watches]

I was actually looking for this resource a few weeks back. Thanks for sharing with us your wisdom.This will absolutely going to help me in my projects.

[Kalbim Seni Seçti]

kalbim seni seçti dizisini sitemizde izleyebilirsiniz

Kalbim seni seçti
http://www.kalbimsenisecti.biz

Kalbim seni seçti dizi müziği
http://www.kalbimsenisecti.biz/kalbim-seni-secti-dizi-muzigi

Kalbim seni seçti oyuncuları
http://www.kalbimsenisecti.biz/kalbim-seni-secti-oyunculari-2

Melisin Sevgilisi berk yani alihan arıcı
http://www.kalbimsenisecti.biz/kalbim-seni-secti-alihan-araci-berk

[mynet sohbet]

sana cok yalvarmıştım kapın da aglamıstım bır tek sana yanmıştım senın papucun dama

[louis vuitton handbags on sale]

your opinion is right! I support you! I will let my friends to read!

[replica wallets]

I like your article so that I read all of your articles in a day.Please continue and keep on writing excellent posts.

[CL outlet]

Handyman services are available to help you with large or small jobs around your home and office.

[CL outlet]

Handyman services are available to help you with large or small jobs around your home and office.

[knockoff handbags]

comfy and warm - These shoes are just what I wanted. They are warm.

[dr dre beats headphones]

Obama, since his first day in office - has been actively trying to restore US engagement and influence in Asia, especially in Southeast Asia