On Precedents and Double Standards in Libya and the Wider Region Posted by Eric Martin

A few days back, Shadi Hamid made an interesting argument in favor of intervening militarily in Libya that I would like to revisit:

One of the main sources of Arab antipathy toward America is our long, tragic history of supporting repressive dictatorships in the region. This five-decade-long bi-partisan policy gave us the self-destructing Arab world that we have now (and also contributed to the rise of Arab terrorism as Steven Brooke and I argue here). The "stability paradigm," - which is just about as "realist" as you can get - has proven a failure.

Let's grant Shadi's premise for the sake of argument: US support for brutal autocratic regimes in the region has fostered resentment and, at times, a virulent strain of anti-Americanism that has produced violent manifestations. 

But if that's the diagnosis, how exactly would launching military attacks on Libya provide the cure?  After all, Qaddafi's is most definitely not one of the autocratic regimes that the US has funded, armed and otherwise helped to maintain power. Quite the opposite. 

A similar argument was made in anticipation of the invasion of Iraq, with a similar logical disconnect separating premise and conclusion. Again, Iraq's was not a regime supported by the United States (at least, not since the 1980s, after which the US fought a war and maintained a no-fly-zone and other punitive measures), so how would its ouster convince denizens of the Middle East that the United States was not conspiring with autocracies when it suited US interests?

If anything, it reinforced this notion by stressing the disparate treatment certain regimes received (Iraq) under the putative justification of spreading freedom and democracy, while US client-states remained in good favor despite their blatant disregard for human rights and democratic norms (not even so much as a reduction in aid or other forceful ultimatum requiring reforms).

Similarly, our muscular action in Libya, while we turn a blind eye to Saudi Arabia's activities in Bahrain (at the Bahrain regime's request and with its assistance), and events in Yemen, will drive home the point that "friendly" dictators will continue to receive US support, even if less accommodating regimes will be targeted in furtherance of our highly malleable and selective (though universal?) support of "freedom and democracy."

As the New York Times notes (via Matt Yglesias), the intervention itself might be serving to further entrench those autocrats that we find strategically appealing:

With his brutal military assault on civilians, and his rantings about spiked Nescafé, Col. Muammar el-Qaddafi handed many leaders across the Arab world what had otherwise eluded them: A chance to side with the people while deflecting attention from their own citizens’ call for democracy, political analysts around the region said. And they really do not like him. Even Arab leaders most critical of the United States’ intervention in the Middle East have reluctantly united behind the military intervention in Libya. That has given a boost to Arab leaders in places like Saudi Arabia who are at the same moment working to silence political opposition in their backyards. [emphasis added]

Interestingly, Zalmay Khalilzad fully endorses the implementation of this type of double standard.  Here is Khalilzad's description of the underlying dynamic:

...[T]he dysfunction of the Middle East today generates the most threatening challenges to the international community. The largely peaceful, youth-oriented, democratic revolutions across the region present an opportunity to catalyze a fundamental transformation.

Yet he argues that the US should only take vague steps to apply some undefined "pressure" on "friendly authoritarian" regimes, but, on the other hand, utilize military assets (in one form or another) to oust those regimes hostile to US interests (Libya, Syria, Iran). He argues that if we fail to act in Libya:

Other dictatorships would then be emboldened to squelch their democratic opponents and resist liberalization.

But he fails to mention what lessons will be drawn from Bahrain and Yemen.  In that sense, Khalilzad is not so much endorsing a regional transition in support of broad-reaching democratic revolutions, as he is recommending using the spread of freedom and democracy as a pretense to help unseat US adversaries (sound familiar?), while engaging in the same toothless goading of the "friendly authoritarian" regimes. 

There may be sound strategic reasons to follow the advice of Khalilzad or Hamid, but disabusing the Arab public of the notion that the US supports friendly autocratic regimes despite their brutality and anti-democratic tendencies should not be one of them.

Comments

[baltimore ravens jerseys]

These all things are very informative and knowledgeable and i can get so many ideas form it.I like your sharing too much.You have done such a nice job.

[Beats By Dr. Dre]

Response to Beats By Dr.Dre Beatbox Review.

[Business Loans]

In 2004, Colonel Qaddafi was accused of being directly involved in a plot to assassinate King Abdullah, who was then the crown prince. Then in 2009, Colonel Qaddafi embarrassed the emir of Qatar, Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa al-Thani, and infuriated King Abdullah, during an Arab summit meeting in Doha, Qatar.

[replica handbags]

It very beautiful how detailed issue on erudition topic has been well enlarge here within this site.

[jordan shoes]

Thank you for this article. That's all I can say. You most definitely have made this blog into something special. You clearly know what you are doing, you've covered so many bases.Thanks!

[Ringring]

This is a such wonderful article that I just can't understand why there are so fewer comments.

[Wei Wei]

Thank you for this article. That's all I can say. You organize the article very well and your writing ability is really wonderful. I hope one day I could write such good articles. I hope my English is better and better.

[wholesale knockoff handbags]

great! I like it

[replica panerai]

Thank your for sharing your wonderful article. I very agree with your views from here.

[replica handbags]

thanks for your sharing article, i like that.

[replica watches]

Wonderful articles, let me have to this admiration

[Sino-Italy Trade]

If Qaddafi wins, Libya will look to the east for support...maybe Shadi Hamid is right.

[pharmacy chemical]

But first, Libya, and we begin in Qatar with Shadi Hamid. He directs the Brookings Institution's Doha Center, and Shadi. and Libya could very well prove to be the Obama administration's defining moment in the Middle East.

[generic viagra]

I have been keeping a tab on your article and love the way you come up with new and different health piece. Please keep it coming. I look forward to your work and ensure that a lot of my friend read them too.

[CXHond]

Don't bury your head in the sand.

[oakley sunglasses]

Good post. I am also going to write a blog post about this...I enjoyed reading your post and I like your take on the issue. Thanks.

[Curly Human Hair Wigs]

Nice post, keep on working to be better.

[football shirts]

england football shirts
Then one day it rained and I thought for sure she'd be up at the bus stop, but no. Garrett said
he saw her trucking along on her bike in a bright
yellow poncho, and in math I noticed that her pants were still soaked from the knees down.

[beats dre studio]

Looks great feeling.

[omni dual saw]

I heard that in Libya ,the people suffered from the war,and the turmoil...

[dr dre solo]

Great article.

[haare selber schneiden]

This is the nice one keep up the good work

[bubble trouble]

thank you for nice information.. I am going to bookmark this page. we will meet soon.

[medicare supplements]

my luck is very good because i found your post. In future ready to hear more from you

[cheap adidas]

“Not really,” she said. “He works too much, but that’s about it.” In her tone I heard a hint of sadness, one that I didn’t quite understand. As I considered it, I saw a young couple with their arms around each other, hugging as if they hadn’t seen each other in years.

[In Stock Full Lace Wig]

I am happy to find information useful to many here in the office, we have a more technical work in this direction, thanks for sharing.

[cialis kaufen]

hi to all nice and very interesting post i am going to bookmark this we will meet soon.

[disc jockeys djs]

nice post and very decent also thank you a lot for share

[Tyre Labels]

hello all i m writing this because i want to say thank you for a very nice & impressive post sharing with us . thank you & keep writing :-)

[diablo 2 items]

A very attractive and eye catching post you are great dude keep up the good work

[melanotan II]

hey this is the post i was searching but by luck found it now i am going to bookmark this

[trade on forex]

hey this is the post i was searching but by luck found it now i am going to bookmark this

[Remy hair extensions]

hey buddy this is awesome and really impres with your views superb

[Watch Mayweather vs Ortiz Online]

hey this is the post i was searching but by luck found it now i am going to bookmark this

[chaussures femmes]

We have gotten many great comments from our customers and earn a good reputation in foreign makerts, more than 90% customers are satisfied with our products and service, till now our online members are beyond 80,000. As of right now, we Replica Handbags currently serve customers from over 18 countries, and we are still growing. We really hope to expand our business through cooperation with individuals and companies from around the world.

[easy profitbot review]

wishing to find out a little more about this subject matter ? then I prefer that you ought to look at websites regarding this specific issue for even more clarifying your ideas.

[Fire Sprinklers]

At least the Libya conflict is coming to a conclusion! or at least the conflict with Gadaffi! Lets hope, along with Egypt they strive for democracy from now on! Fire Sprinkler Systems

[Dwarka Delhi]

appreciated work perhaps you did very hard work for this

[beats by dre]

iated work perhaps you did v

[tool steel]

This is an affecting point of view on this topic. I am happy you shared your ideas and I find myself agreeing.

[belstaff uk]

The fat, lazy funny patter cat, was created by Jim Davis in 1978. Within four years, Garfield’s comic strip was appearing in a thousand newspapers around the world. He also has computer animated and cartoon movies under his belt.

[melanotan]

hello guys really i am impress with this sites and i am going to bookmarks this site.

[replica wallets]

Let's grant Shadi's premise for the sake of argument: US support for brutal autocratic regimes in the region has fostered resentment and, at times, a virulent strain of anti-Americanism that has produced violent manifestations.

[CL outlet]

Need a new heating and air conditioning system, but are unsure where to turn? The article below will walk you through the process.

[Background Check]

This is such a great thing to know "If anything, it reinforced this notion by stressing the disparate treatment certain regimes received (Iraq) under the putative justification of spreading freedom and democracy, while US client-states remained in good favor despite their blatant disregard for human rights and democratic norms (not even so much as a reduction in aid or other forceful ultimatum requiring reforms" more power....

[replica louis vuitton handbags]

After read the article.I have just one word to say,you are so brilliant.I like all of your article.Well done.

[transcription services]

Excellent article.I am definitely going to put this into use one of these days.
I will be sure to let you know if I do.Great work!

[moncler down jackets]

A real lot of useful info here!These are all great comments here. Very cool article.

[best skin care]

We have gotten many great comments from our customers and earn a good reputation in foreign makerts.i think you can do it.

[Røykeslutt]

i think As of right now, we Replica Handbags currently serve customers from over 18 countries, and we are still growing. We really hope to expand our business through cooperation with individuals and companies from around the world.

[ไพ่ออนไลน์]

Amazing website, especially the illustration. Nice flow and visually appealing. Although, some may say shameless self promotion. Kidding. http://www.spd1120.com

[Nike Air Max]

Superhero were amazing at Soul Survivor, the whole of my youth group really enjoyed them!

[apple peel]

I have enjoyed.Wonderful articles, let me have to Sharing it.Thanks

[forex affiliate]

Both Khalilzad or Hamid gave sound strategic advice. Thank you for sharing this news.

[top position in google]

great article about the situation in libya. this is really a great resource. will bookmark your post and will comeback later.

[Air Max UK]

A man can fail many times, but he isn't a failure until he begins to blame somebody else.