Democracy Arsenal

« A Bit More on that Afghanistan Study Group Report | Main | Stephen Walt Drags Me Back In - More on ASG »

September 14, 2010

The Military and Succession in Egypt
Posted by Michael Wahid Hanna

Thanassis Cambanis had a very interesting story over the weekend in the New York Times (in which I am quoted) on the Egyptian military and the looming issue of presidential succession (yes, I know, it has been looming for some time now). The story describes the stakes for the military in the succession process and discusses how the military might fit into various post-Hosni Mubarak succession scenarios.

In the piece, Issandr el-Amrani, a sharp observer of Egyptian politics, states that “[t]he military is seen as the only institution that is able to block succession in Egypt.” But gaming out what the military would and, as importantly, could actually do is difficult. It is not at all clear that they could in fact block a succession scenario, specifically, a scenario that involved the ascension of Gamal Mubarak. In the story I argue that “[i]t’s an open question how much power the military has, and they might not even know themselves.”

The role of the military in Egyptian society has changed dramatically since the days of the Free Officers movement and Gamal ‘Abd al-Nasser. The thing to remember is that Egypt’s military has not been involved directly in political affairs in years. The last high profile military man, Field Marshall ‘Abd al-Halim Abu Ghazaleh, was removed from his post as Defense Minister in 1989, in a move that was seen as a preemptive action against a potential political rival.

Furthermore, the military role in governance is diminished. In 1966, Sid’qi Suleiman led a government filled with active-duty military officers. These serving military men held key portfolios and occupied half the cabinet-level positions. As such, in 1968, the leftist historian Anouar Abdel-Malek could confidently describe Nasser’s Egypt as a military society. The current cabinet of 33 formal ministers includes only one active-duty military officer, Field Marshall Mohammed Hussein Tantawi, the minister of defense (Lt. Gen. ‘Omar Suleiman, often seen as a potential presidential successor, is a minister without portfolio).

It is hard to pinpoint the parameters of the military’s power within Egyptian society at this juncture. Yes, it is the most respected and coherent organization in the country, but Egypt does not fight wars anymore and the military is not involved in the day-to-day of politics. And, it has not been overtly involved in a presidential succession since 1952. While Anwar al-Sadat and Hosni Mubarak were both military men, they were hand-picked as vice-presidents by the president. There was no real process for the military to be involved beyond the sort of informal vetting that might have taken place internally prior to the their appointments. And it is also worth remembering that both al-Sadat and Mubarak were seen as weak figures with no broad popular legitimacy at the time they assumed the presidency, and, yet, the military regime did not attempt to block the ascension of either man to the post.

Along with its distance from politics, the military has also been co-opted by the regime through patronage and perks; the story portrays a military establishment perhaps placated through lucrative business deals and interests, in contrast to the all-pervasive role of the military in earlier eras:

The beneficiary of nearly $40 billion in American aid over the last 30 years, the Egyptian military has turned into a behemoth that controls not only security and a burgeoning defense industry, but has also branched into civilian businesses like road and housing construction, consumer goods and resort management.

In short, this is not Pakistan, or even Turkey, where overt military interference has brought down civilian governments through pressure and coups and replaced them with military dictatorships. While there are no civilian institutions or traditions to guide the succession process, there is, similarly, no institutional memory of political meddling by the Egyptian military. Egyptians hardly remember President Anwar al-Sadat decked out in his military finest – such trappings are no longer part of the state’s choreography - let alone an intrusive gatekeeper role for the military.

In Egypt, power has become increasingly centralized and concentrated in a system of one-man rule. With this backdrop in mind, it is worth asking whether the military really conceives of itself as a failsafe and the ultimate safeguard of national interests. I suspect that assurances that the military would maintain its privileged position and business interests will be enough to guarantee that the military establishment does not make a bid to dictate the country’s political future.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Military and Succession in Egypt:


I'm sorry, but it's not good enough to say "do over." The pundits' second thoughts should carry the cargo of their previous assumptions, heady projections and salient selling points.I'm a businessman, but also about this air max .

As for craftsmanship, however, Christian Louboutin would not budge an inch. When asked if there are any strategic changes in running the business that has been in the family for five generations, or pressure to up the profits, the first nonfamily member CEO first underlines that a board of 11 family members holds control of the company. He answers that there simply is no compromising the spirit of the brand for business.

"Spirit of the company, of the signature, comes first. And business next. Yes, we're a public company so we cannot completely ignore profits or growth of the company, but what is always at the top of our mind is retaining our top creators," said Thomas.

The third floor of Maison Christian Louboutin shoes  Dosan Park is an atelier wholly devoted to art exhibitions. As "art is the source for our craftsmanship and key to attract clients into the world of Louboutin shoes ," said Thomas.

The Hyperdunk is the base product of lots of other basketball sneakers from Nike. One of the is the Nike Air Max Hyperfly, which is set to make its debut this month. The Air Max Hyperfly is an entirely new model that was inspired after the Hyperdunk. The simple look is a must have on the Hyperfly, because they will used mostly on the basketball court. The sneaker feature Flywire equipped side panels with eye-catching black patent leather seen throughout the shoe. The use of black is also seen on the Nike Swoosh and

Among Afghan analysts the sense of gloom is even more pervasive. This sense that the mission has gone off the rails is also reflected in US public opinion polling.

this is not Pakistan, or even Turkey, area apparent aggressive arrest has brought down noncombatant governments through burden and coups and replaced them with aggressive dictatorships. While there are no noncombatant institutions or traditions to adviser the assumption process, there is, similarly, no institutional anamnesis of political meddling by the Egyptian military. Fast and easy to find cheap designer clothes Men and Women in this exciting new online shopping destination providing the best prices, selection, and overall experience you’ll find online.

In this era of blog ,we easily get nice & updated information for research purposes... I'd definitely appreciate the work of the said blog owner... Thanks!

You mentioned in paragraph 2 of the view is very interesting,Thank you for sharing.

Use Slendertone electronic muscle exercise products, skin redness, this Slendertone System Arms is normal?Minor redness is normal. As muscles, the speed of blood flow to the skin, Slendertone Flex Belt leading to redness. Usually 2-3 hours will be dispersed. To exercise the parts should be coated to avoid any leap Lotion or perfume, so as Slendertone Flex Max not to stimulate skin. if not dispersed across several hours, please stop using, to the doctor.

With the white and metallic silver pair, you get quintessential summer style with Nike Air Max 180, and there's also a pair with teal and purple accents to celebrate Bron's Summit Lake Hornets rec league roots. Both pairs of Nike air max are coming in at retailers across the country, kobe bryant shoes and while the Hornets are out of stock,classic and popular Nike running shoes, NikeStore has the whites right now. More from

Subsequently, after spending many hours on the internet at last We\'ve uncovered an individual that definitely does know what they are discussing many thanks a great deal wonderful post.

For this matter, once I discussed with one of my friends, not only about the content you talked about, but also to how to improve and develop, but no results. So I am deeply moved by what you said today.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Powered by TypePad


The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use