Democracy Arsenal

« Who Are You Calling "Pollyana"? | Main | What the United Nations Should, and Shouldn't, Worry About »

September 10, 2010

Muslims, Quran Burnings, and the Problem of Freedom of Speech
Posted by Shadi Hamid

It’s good that Pastor Terry Jones is considering backing down from his plan to burn 200 Qurans. Obama and Petraeus, correctly, anticipated that such an act would have dire repercussions and provoke anti-American activity throughout the world (it already has). We saw what happened with the Danish cartoon controversy and drawing a bunch of cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad is considerably more mild than burning the book that Muslims consider the literal, exact word of God.

But herein lies a problem. I remember getting into a conversation with a relative – an American citizen – about the Danish cartoons. He suggested that there should be some sort of international ban, enforced by the UN (I’m not sure how), on offensive depictions of religious figures. When I heard this, I thought to myself, “you’re sort of missing the point here.” Meanwhile, Muqtedar Khan, a professor of Islamic studies at the University of Delaware, is regarded as one of the more progressive – I’ve imposed a moratorium on using the word “moderate” without quotation marks – American Muslim voices. But he has written a bizarre and, quite frankly, frightening article about the Quran burnings (via Isaac Chotiner). For example:

The act will scorch Muslim hearts everywhere. The searing pain will never be forgotten...Believe me, there is nothing more precious to Muslims than the Quran, and watching people toss it into fire, will be horrifying. I would rather burn in fire myself, than watch a Quran burn.

I have to admit – the first time I heard about Pastor Jones’s Quran burning scheme, it disturbed me a bit, but in the same way that a Sarah Palin speech disturbs me – it bothers me, makes me fear for my country, but, after 10 minutes, you sort of shrug it off. In contrast, when I first heard about the Danish cartoons a couple years back, I literally didn’t care and had trouble understanding how people could get so worked up about it.

While Obama was right to condemn Pastor Jones’s actions, we probably should be clear about first principles. The burning of Qurans, as offensive as it is to common decency, is – and must be – protected speech. The right not to be offended, as many conservatives in the wake of the Park51 issue seem to have forgotten, is not a protected right. For me, as a Muslim, it is troubling that a good chunk of co-religionists around the world support of freedom of speech in abstract terms, but do not think that freedom should extend to religious expression. The Muslim Brotherhood, for instance, is calling for the expulsion of US ambassadors. This is absurd. Mohamed Morsi, the Brotherhood spokesman who conveyed this position, knows better, or at least I hope he does. He lived in the US a while back and did his PhD in California (USC if I recall).

It’s like when certain individuals and organizations in the Arab world called for a "ban" on Denmark over the Danish cartoons. The notion that the Danish government doesn’t have any control over media organizations – and, more importantly, shouldn’t – appeared to have been lost on many. 

People often ask me how Muslims can get so worked up about symbolic acts but have trouble summoning the same anger over the killing of innocent civilians. It is understandable, if somewhat loaded, question. It is also difficult to explain. This is a civilization under siege and so its reactions and preferences become distorted. The slow, difficult work of understanding how this distortion occurred - and what we can do about it - is more critical than ever.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Muslims, Quran Burnings, and the Problem of Freedom of Speech :


I would rather burn in fire myself, than watch a Quran burn. I am amazed at how millions of Americans who are decent and honorable can watch this happen.

Mr. Hamid, it is nice to learn that you are not like all other Muslims. By the way I notice that what you don't cite from Dr. Khan's rather eloquent and candid opinion on Koran burning contradicts the conclusions you want us to draw from what you quote. In the interest of honesty I am reproducing what I consider as his recommendations, which you neglected to refer.

Start Quote

Yes, Muslims attach unimaginable value to it, but the Quran belongs to all people, it is part of the human treasury and the Quran attests that it was sent, not to Muslims, but to the entire humanity: "It is nothing less than a message to all nations" (Quran 68:52). It belongs as much to Terry Jones as it does to Muslims. The only difference being, some have built great civilizations on its basis others may burn their own values along with it.

When images of Quran burning will be flashed around the globe, it will excite Muslim anger. I want Muslim leaders everywhere to council their communities. Recognize this provocation for what it is and ignore it. And remember do not let this become a source for anger and hatred towards Christians. Remind your congregations what the Quran tells Muslims about Christians:

"...Forgive them and overlook their misdeeds, for Allah loves those who are kind (Quran 5:13).

If Muslims react with anger and indiscriminate violence then one of Terry Jones' goals will be fulfilled. He would have shown the world that some Muslims are more barbaric than even he is. Be patient, encourage everyone to be patient, let Terry Jones enjoy the monopoly on barbarity for a while.

"True believers are those who show patience, firmness and self-control (Quran 3:17) and indeed God is with those who are patient (Quran 2:153)."
End Quote

nice article commerce, update stuff nice writing, thank you

your write is very good,I like you write.and I am a girl,I like ndscard,it is a game card.ndscard is very good,and ndscard is very interesting.

Few things are powerful enough to fuse far-left and far-right together into what appears to be unity, but on closer analysis is groupthink.

Let them build their Islamic Cultural Center, let them burn the Koran, let them burn the Bible, let them burn the flag, but everyone stand strong.

Then let the offended grow strong enough not to freak out about it because that is what fuels a lot of the attention seekers.

We can be bigger than all the hatespeak.

The only way to end the strife between these religions is for someone to finally deliver verifiable scientific proof that they are all blatant lies that were designed to hide something absolutely vital to the future of humanity.

Here is Wisdom...

Good blog, where it taught me a lot! Thank you! The hope of improving the content!

thanks for you share ,i like so much,It is so lucky to read your blog,it is full of useful message

The afflicted batteries covering those actuate in HP and Compaq laptops (or purchased separately) amidst August of 2007 and July of 2008. A anniversary of the afflicted computer models and adjustment bar codes can be actuate on the US Chump Product Affirmation Commission (CPSC) Web site.

This is a sort of blog we can have loads of information i would like to appreciate the intelligence of this blog's owner

The comments to this entry are closed.

Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Powered by TypePad


The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use