Democracy in Iraq, through the Looking Glass Posted by Michael Signer

On the Sy Hersh piece in The New Yorker about the Bush Administration's manipulation of Iraq's emerging quasi-democracy, I was trying to think of a metaphor or allegory for the neocons' continuing obliviousness to the failure of their theories to create the right reality, and was failing.  Maybe it's the heat.  The index in Richmond is 110 right now, and it's almost impossible to walk outside -- all the more reason to empathize with our soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan.

So, to recap.  Hersh's piece is here.  Eric Alterman's angry synopsis and expansion is here.  Laura Rozen's coup de grace is here. 

Hersh's piece exposes that while the Administration was, like Socrates in Aristophanes' The Clouds, producing gaseous clouds of rhetoric about Democracy, it was simultaneously engaging in old-style ward politics that would make Richard Daley blush.

The Administration, Hersh reveals, was hosting a small civil war between weirdly hypocritical neocons who were willing to produce a counterfeit of democracy at any cost, and those who thought America should allow transparent elections to go forward, and let the chips fall where they may. 

On the one hand was a clutch of insiders who wanted to rig the elections against pro-Iranian Shiites -- with the goal of reducing Iraq's formal connections to this member of the Axis of Evil. 

On the other hand was a number of pro-democracy NGO's, as well as the more sensible duo of Richard Armitage and Colin Powell -- who argued that democratization would suffer both substantively and image-wise if it was so overtly manipulated, if transparency, well, disappeared. 

Here's Hersh's summary of the debate:

The main advocate for channelling aid to preferred parties was Thomas Warrick, a senior adviser on Iraq for the State Department’s Bureau of Near Eastern Affairs, who was backed, in this debate, by his superiors and by the National Security Council. Warrick’s plan involved using forty million dollars that had been appropriated for the election to covertly provide cell phones, vehicles, radios, security, administrative help, and cash to the parties the Administration favored. The State Department’s Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor resisted this plan, and turned to three American non-governmental organizations that have for decades helped to organize and monitor elections around the world: the National Democratic Institute (N.D.I.), the International Republican Institute (I.R.I.), and the National Endowment for Democracy (N.E.D.).

“It was a huge debate,” a participant in the discussions told me. “Warrick said he had gotten the Administration principals”—senior officials of the State Department, the Pentagon, and the National Security Council—“to agree.” The N.G.O.s “were fighting a rearguard action to get this election straight,” and emphasized at meetings that “the idea of picking favorites never works,” he said.

“There was a worry that a lot of money was being put aside in walking-around money for Allawi,” the participant in the discussions told me. “The N.G.O.s said, ‘We don’t do this—and, in any case, it’s crazy, because if anyone gets word of this manipulation it’ll ruin what could be a good thing. It’s the wrong way to do it.’ The N.G.O.s tried to drive a stake into the heart of it.”

Wouldn't you know, but the neocons won in the short-term, producing an election riddled with fraud, producing the marionette of Ayad Allawi.  The Independent Electoral Commission of Iraq later estimated that 10% of ballots had been stuffed. 

And then when the actual government was formed in Iraq, the enterprise spun a little more out of control.  Ibrahim al-Jafaari became Prime Minister and, in early July, "stunned Washington" (in Hersh's words) by announcing a multi-billion dollar aid package with Iran.  The whole point was to separate the Iraqi government from Iran -- not connect them.

There are, thankfully, signs of progress for a stabilizing Iraq, if Sunnis have more of a hand in the government (as it looks like they might) and if the constitution-drafting proceeds apace -- but this is despite Washington, not because of it.

So where does this all get us?  A ripe example of the ideology of this Administration.  Marx defined "ideology" as "Sie wissen das nicht, aber sie tun es," which means, "They do not know it, but they are doing it."  Here's how the political theorist Slavoj Zizek summarizes it:

The very concept of ideology implies a kind of basic, constitutive naïveté: the misrecognition of its own presuppositions, of its own effective conditions, a distance, a divergence between so-called social reality and our distorted representation, our false consciousness of it.

This is ideology, in the classic sense:  the fusion of home-schooling, faith-based reasoning, and salvationist, millenarian politics (which culminates in the emergence of the "rapture index" as something politically-engaged rightists actually care about) leads neocons to become so absorbed in the rhetoric of democratization that they think the worst kind of realpolitik is justified to produce the image (rather than reality) of Democracy. 

Where there's smoke, there's no fire -- or something like that:

I want so much to know whether they've a fire in the winter: you never can tell, you know, unless our fire smokes, and then smoke comes up in that room too -- but that may be only pretence, just to make it look as if they had a fire.

This is from Alice in Wonderland, but it kind of seems appropriate today.

Through the looking-glass, indeed.

Comments

[Brad Plumer]

Good post, but if Hersh is right and the Bush administration did manipulate the election, and if that did lead to a better-than-expected showing for Allawi's Iraqi List, then in retrospect that might have been a good thing, no? Would Sistani's UIA have been so ready and willing to compromise -- they're still not very flexible, but more flexible than many thought they would be -- if they had won 60 percent or more of seats in the National Assembly, as was, apparently, expected?

This is still very sordid no matter what, but it's not impossible that manipulating the election "worked" in some small degree, or was better than the alternative. Or that manipulating elections is always a bad idea from a practical standpoint.

[David Noon]

Among the many other things this article underscores, it should remind us of the Bush administration's apparent preference for elections as the primary symbol and instrument of what it describes as "democracy." We're constantly hearing about the seemingly alchemic consequences of "elections" in formerly authoritarian and failed states, as if elections must somehow precede the creation of an active public sphere capable of supporting them. I'm still waiting for an explanation from the Bushies — and the "democratic globalists" on whose rhetoric they've drawn — as to why this must be so. I suppose the cynical (and maybe proper) response is that they can only imagine democracy as a collage of images, to be managed and milked for maximum sentimentality and minimal effect.

[Laura]

Hersh's article is about the elections in Iraq, but it is also about whether the Bush administration is evading Congressional oversight and reporting requirements in such foreign policy matters. In that regard, I am perplexed why it has not generated more public frenzy (the pre-publication NYT reaction and the WaPo follow up notwithstanding). Thoughts?

[rosignol]

Dunno about this. It's a disturbing story, but Sy Hersh is known to be fairly partisan.... I would very much prefer to have multiple sources on this.

Is there other coverage of the issue?

[paperwight]

"Sy Hersh is known to be fairly partisan"

par-ti-san
adj.
Known to report or repeat actual facts which Republicans don't like.

Ah yes, the belief that one is entitled to one's own facts concerning the world, not just one's own opinions. The Republican Party is like a cult anymore. It's sad.

[rosignol]

Speaking of partisans... it's interesting how you define something unpleasant in such a way that only people you don't like can commit it.

I think there's a word for that... 'bigot'.

[rosignol]

Re-reading my comment, it is clear that I was a little hasty in my phrasing.

Please consider the comment withdrawn.

[Vincent25086]

http://www.goodsite.com/25086/hlink It's a bad link

[vilatik]

Hi
I found very cheap viagra, cialis and e.t.c.

[Vincent19065]

http://www.goodsite.com/19065/hlink It's a bad link

[Vincent19065]

http://www.goodsite.com/19065/hlink It's a bad link

[Vincent190651a]

http://www.goodsite.com/19065/hlink It's a bad link

[Vincent190651au]

http://www.goodsite.com/19065/hlink It's a bad link

[WhiteLedi]

Please, can you help me? I need to find where I can buy this complect of oil colors www.elpaste.ee/index.php?productID=390 in the internet.
My mum has a birthday soon so I wanted to make her a very good present.

Thanks:)

[maxgood5]

Designing of the stand and firm style for exhibition stands, development of drawings and development. Designing of standard and individual stands, mobile exhibition stands

News about exhibition business

[teenpussys]

It is interest.
http://wetpussy.12w.net
http://teenpussy.12w.net

[smallboobs]

It is Boobs.
small boobs
http://babygotboob.12w.net
http://bouncingboobs.12w.net

[perfect boobs]

It is Boobs.
perfect boobs
http://nakedboobs.12w.net
http://niceboobs.12w.net

[stareika]

hello. good site.
vip
[url= http://nedd.lineseo.com ]vip[/url]
http://nedd.lineseo.com - vip

[Dobrogil]

Design of apartments A-Kwadrat
Have bought a new apartment or have decided to repair old? If wish to save time and money address to us.
Design

[oniitm55]

Складское оборудование

[Mister]

hi nice site!!!

[tre gole]

Good job. I loved youre site, keep it up.

[madrus mpeg cum animl]

Good job. I loved youre site, keep it up.

[buy levitra]

cheap@levitra.com

[buy levitra]

cheap@levitra.com

[cheap levitra]

cheap@levitra.com

[cheap levitra]

cheap@levitra.com

[generic levitra]

cheap@levitra.com

[generic levitra]

cheap@levitra.com

[Fordghjk]

Welcome to a site about Ford


[url=http://fordinfo.net/]history of the company ford[/url]

[polyfoniyyaw]

Own melody - the simple way to be allocated from crowd and to not shudder each time, when in a premise a mobile phone. And it is especially pleasant, when this melody polyphonic. If your phone possesses polyphony to begin to rock in it a melody it is possible in three ways. A variant the first and the most simple: to order it having sent SMS on corresponding number. Other way to take advantage of services WAP or GPRS. The third way - connection to a personal computer. The connecting channel can become a special cable. However, to connect devices it is possible by air - with the help of infra-red port or Bluetooth. Also you will need the program.
It in can [url=http: // polyfoniya.info/]on our site[/url]
[url=http: // polyfoniya.info/]mmf melodies[/url]

[elpagesengl]

Site about the city of Electrostal. It is a lot of helpful information.
[url=http: // elpages.ru]electrosteel furniture[/url]

[elpagesengl]

Site about the city of Electrostal. It is a lot of helpful information.
[url=http: // elpages.ru]telephone electrosteel[/url]

[mmfmidieng]

Own melody - the simple way to be allocated from crowd and to not shudder each time, when in a premise a mobile phone. And it is especially pleasant, when this melody polyphonic. If your phone possesses polyphony to begin to rock in him(it) a melody it is possible in three ways. A variant the first and the most simple: to order it having sent SMS on corresponding number. Other way to take advantage of services WAP or GPRS. The third way - connection to a personal computer. The connecting channel can become a special cable. However, to connect devices it is possible by air - with the help of infra-red port or Bluetooth.
It in can find [url=http: // mmf-midi.info] n our site[/url]
Site with free-of-charge midi melodies, the big base
[url=http: // mmf-midi.info/]melodies midi[/url]

[Fhantomasto]

Недавно наткнулся на веб студию, скажу сразу что опыт работы в этой сфере у меня есть, не раз обжегался об красивые обещания, невыполненные сроки, непрофессиональную работу и невыполненные же вскоре обещания. Но эти ребята меня приятно удивили. Заказывал у них сайт и раскрутку его же, в срок уложились, сделали все качественно и профессионально. Вобщем рекомендую!
Вот ссылка:
Recently has come across a web studio, I shall tell at once that the operational experience in this sphere at me is, not time обжегался about beautiful promises, outstanding terms, nonprofessional work and outstanding soon promises. But these guys of me have pleasantly surprised. Ordered in them a site and promotion of it(him), in time have kept within, have made all qualitatively and professionally.
Here the reference:

[url=http://e-masters.org/]создание красивых сайтов[/url] [url=http: // e-masters.org/]creation of beautiful sites[/url]

[hxgqi]

Google

[dgtar]

The excellent site!!! Want you good luck!!! With best wishes Stuart!!!

[brad anelka]

simply the best attorney.zayvision.com

[mtv]

hellow everybody....cool stuff here

[Nikki Cash]

Your site is the best one!

==
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Nikki-Cash/45019743393

[book]

Hello it a very nice site!
books and and cool stuff
http://www.bookonly.org

[Tattoos]

{Hi|Hello|Hi all!} the best gallery i ever seen
get an angel tattoos,
{get the best designlfind your best angel|you live only one}



http://angel-tattoo.org/gallery/
{Bye|G'night}

[dedikus]

Всем привет! Классный у вас форум :) Как только попал на него, так и торчу тут. Давно тут уже сижу, да не писал ничего до сих пор. Но вот не удержался! Очень уж форум ваш хорош! Жаль, что наши <a href=http://forumnn.ru>форумы нижнего новгорода</a> не такие интересные, <a href=http://forumnn.ru>forumnn.ru</a> - ваще шило какое-то.... Ну да ладно, не будем о грустном ;) Расскажи, как вас-то на такой ресурс судьба занесла?

[Gerbion]

Здравствуйте, уважаемые форумчане! Решил поделиться своими мыслями по поводу наших СМИ. Что с ними творится? Неужели все газеты скоро будут электронными? А как же чашечка кофе с утра, сидя на кресле-качалке и свежая утренняя пресса? Неужели всё это исчезнет? Как по мне, так я ни на кой монитор не променяю свою любимую газету. У меня самая любимая - это <a href=http://gazetann.ru>газета Нижний Новгород</a>. Хоть на неё уже и пытаются сделать ин

[Qwadromen]

Решил поделится своими наблюдениями :) И рассказать о своем казусе. Я очень люблю ездить по области , конечно же в этом деле мне помогают<a href=http://gpsnn.ru>gps навигаторы</a>. Однако этот случай мне доказал, что слепо верить спутникам не всегда нужно )) ПСЫ. Лучше всего смотреть обновления на <a href=http://gpsnn.ru>gpsnn.ru</a> Как то еду я по бездорожью. Смотрю - на жпс приемнике дорога есть! Ну и поехал я, не снижая ск

[Geracleagma]

http://www.robsonbightcharters.com http://www.robsonbightcharters.com - whale watching <a href="http://www.robsonbightcharters.com">charters</a>

[Christel Clean upm]

You have a wonderful Site with a lot of great information. It has been a pleasure reading.

Thanks,
Christel Clean Domestic Services
==========================
Christel Clean Domestic Services has been providing quality cleaning services throughout Metro Atlanta area for over 6 years. We have built our reputation on providing an outstanding, reliable cleaning service at a reasonable price. The importance of a clean working or living environment simply can not be overstressed, and we pride ourselves on consistently providing just that to all of our clients. Our services are designed to meet the needs of corporate singles, large families and/or business owners with quality services designed to accommodate all. Our prices are based on the size of the job and square footage of your home or office. NOT by the hour!! Our services are designed to make your place clean and sparkle. We will clean and dust every corner of your house. To help us with your requirements and/ or needs you should prepare a task list. Our goal is to provide you with a quality level of service and support that exceeds your expectations. We can clean your home/office daily, weekly, bi-weekly, once a month or a one-time extensive cleaning.

Please Visit: http://www.christelcleands.com/

[Carla Maria]

Very good place

==
http://www.mscarlamaria.com

[Cassie Rihanna]

Hello there,very nice place

==
http://www.cassiespreadeagle.com
http://www.rihannaleaked.com

[muhtar]

Thank you for your sharing.! seslichat seslisohbet

[cheap coach handbags]

Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!

[nike air max]

0314
The Nike air max Shoe lives up to its name with plush cushioning and a sleek silhouette. It brings you just what you need to style it up wherever you go. you can look at the Air max 2009,air max 90,Air max 95,Air Max 2010
Features:
* Minimalistic construction of leathers and synthetics in the upper
* Nike Shox technology for optimal cushioning
* Rubber outsole for excellent grip

[ghd]

GHD IV mini styler has a safety feature that gives you peace of mind, by turning itself off if it is left unattended for 30 minutes. The unique digital technology of GHD hair straightener means that the temperature is automatically controlled even quicker for even better styling.

Creating tight curls, flicks and waves as well as the perfect straight. The ideal styling tool for urban angels with short hair, men's hair and fringes.

price includes: ghd IV salon styler,ghd purple roll bag.

product features:
Auto sleep mode(A built in safety feature that gives you peace of mind by turning off if the ghd IV styler is left unallended for 30 minutes.)
Universal voltage(So that you can use your styler in any country without an adaptor.)
Advanced ceramic heaters(The ultimate heating technology for the ultimate shine and style creation.)
All our products are cheap,if you want to find cheap ghd,come here and that is right.

If you want to find GHD hair products,you can write GHD straightener,GHD hair straighteners,GHD straightners,GHD hair,straighteners GHD in google browse.

[chanel handbags]

Chanel Handbags are woman’s dream come true.

Chanel, a fashion name that has become synonymous with femininity since 100 years, is on the must-have list of every fashion-conscious woman.? And we bring these must-have Chanel Handbags at never before discounts, just for you.

It is only when you come across an Chanel New Arrivals, do you realize the power of her words.? Chanel handbags are crafted not just to be trendy, but trend-setting.? Hardly has lived a celebrity who has not been seen carrying a Chanel handbag under her arm; such has the influence of Chanel handbags as a fashion statement.

Chanel handbags have been so popular in the elite classes of the society, that their pricing is usually prohibitive for everyone else.? Discount Chanel handbags are really difficult to come across, but today should be your lucky day.? We bring you a superb unbeatable range of Chanel Flap bags, all at fantastic discounts.? With us, you have an incredible chance to buy your favorite Chanel handbags at rock bottom prices!

Chanel Handbags have always been at the forefront of luxury and style.? The Chanel classic quilted leather handbags and its reinventions have ruled fashion since forever.? Chanel handbags have remained extremely popular as they continue to merge evolving modern trends with the class and simplicity of its original avatar.

An Chanel 2008 Collection and Chanel 2009 Collection single handedly enhances the look you are carrying.? The reason you would buy a Chanel handbag is own a bag that mingles with your charm and intensifies it with its inherent simplicity.? If you have owned an authentic Chanel handbag before, you know what we are talking about.? If you are one of the unlucky people who haven’t yet gotten a chance to own an Chanel Cambon, now is your chance to shop for an authentic Chanel handbag and discover its ability to transform your look completely.

Buy Chanel handbags with us, and get fabulous discounts which you will never get at your favorite store.? We offer cheap authentic Chanel handbags and they are all up for grabs!