Democracy Arsenal

« The Politics of Apologies | Main | The Chosen People? »

December 13, 2011

Richard Clarke: Presidents, Not 'Commanders on the Ground,' Decide
Posted by Jacob Stokes

493px-Richard_clarkeFormer White House counterterrorism czar Richard Clarke has a piece in the New York Times today that explains why it’s a core part of the president’s job to exert control over the military. Clarke explains how this imperative is by design: the president is in charge of grand strategy and the intersection of foreign and domestic affairs – and the military understands this:

There’s no doubt that the United States has the most professional military officer corps in the world, and certainly the one with the most combat experience. Part of their training and professionalism is, however, a deep-seated understanding of the American tradition of “civilian control of the military.” They know that Article II of the Constitution says that the elected civilian president is the commander in chief of the armed forces.

But civilian control isn’t just a matter of law; it’s also a matter of effectiveness. Being on the ground may provide for an understanding of local circumstances, but it does not necessarily offer insight into what is best in the long run for our nation. We want our president to think about that larger context, and to make decisions that take as much as possible into account. 

Clarke goes on to explain how this concept should inform our choice about who becomes president:

Of course, we choose our presidents in part because of how we think they will handle crises, how they will see the bigger picture, the greater good, the historic moment. We expect them to exercise their own judgment after listening to military and civilian advisers, not just to do what the “commanders on the ground” want. 

In countries like Pakistan the president cannot tell the military what to do. Not so in America. But by offering to cede automatically to the will of military commanders, some presidential candidates are telling voters in advance that there is an important part of the president’s job that they are unwilling to perform. 

The whole thing is worth reading. You can find it here.

Photo: Wikipedia

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c04d69e201675eb33cac970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Richard Clarke: Presidents, Not 'Commanders on the Ground,' Decide:

Comments

If you are looking at purchasing on your own bags that are the perfect example for luxurious, modernity and trend then you definitely should check out the latest assortment of mulberry bags. http://www.mulberryoutletsb.co.uk/

Sorrow is hushed into peace in my heart like the evening among the silent trees.
Achievement provides the only real pleasure in life .

Sorrow is hushed into peace in my heart like the evening among the silent trees.

"It's the fellows who go to West Point and are trained to think they're gods in uniform that I plan to take apart".--Harry S Truman

his was a really informative post, Ive been searching for the last frew pieces for a report. The search is over!

Your article swept me away with its vast information and great writing. Thank you for sharing your views with such passion. I like your views.~~

This step taken by the President so there must be some strong reason behind his decision.

Your article swept me away with its vast information and great writing.

There’s no doubt that the United States has the most professional military officer corps in the world, and certainly the one with the most combat experience. Part of their

そこに、NIEの銭湯が目開いて、いくつかの甲高い音声Ruanmianは、叫んだのか、理解しなければならない:"アンノウンプレジャーズを、あなたは私たちがハンサムではないと言う!"張の花は、モンクレール ダウン レディースを聞いて足を保つ、浮体はえたいの知れないものだ、言った:"ミスNIEのは、あなたが私を不当な扱いをしている、私は言うことができない。"

小さなオレンジ色の隣にある奇妙なことです:"漣Gongzaiは時言った?" ストンプ銭柳ニエユエン:"都市ちょうど私達がいじめを軽蔑したわけではないということを理解していないものを使用してこの女の子、ですか?" "ああ?プレジャーズ..."少しオレンジがどのようなナンセンス、モンクレール女性のダウンジャケット女の子の顔が最も大切である、漣Gongzaiない瞬間と呼ばれるには、人々はあなたが不安に言うことができないと言う?

The comments to this entry are closed.

Emeritus Contributors
Subscribe
Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Email: 
Powered by TypePad

Disclaimer

The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use