Democracy Arsenal

« Tell Me Now If You Want Me to Stay; It Don't Matter, 'Cause I'd Stay Here Anyway | Main | The Pakistani Conundrum »

October 26, 2011

Anticipating Herman Cain's Foreign Policy
Posted by James Lamond


There has been great speculation and fun guessing games throughout the 2012 GOP primaries about what a Tea Party foreign policy would look like. Ideological consistency would, of course, lead to an isolationist-leaning approach. A movement claiming to have been founded out of concern over the growing role of the government and deficit issues would naturally oppose excessive defense spending, "global war on terror" policies and an overall less aggressive and expensive foreign policy. But as has been outlined before, with the possible exception of Ron Paul, that has not been the case. 

Josh Rogin's peice today about Herman Cain, the current Tea Party favorite, and his foreign policy team is the latest in the trend. Cain's chief adviser, J.D. Gordon who previously worked on detainee affairs in the Bush administration and later at Frank Gaffney's neoconservative think tank, the Center for National Security, appears to be a defender of the very policies that a libertarian would likely reject. 

Last year he wrote this defense of why Guantanamo Bay prison should remain open: 

Ironically, the "mess" at Guantanamo that Mr. Obama cited was caused to a great extent by the damaging, yet disingenuous, characterizations continuously repeated by those who supported him on the campaign trail. Wildly exaggerated claims of detainee abuse, factual misrepresentations regarding conditions of confinement and interrogations (for instance, waterboarding was never used there) and false portrayals of most detainees as innocent goat herders sold for bounties helped create such an internationally controversial symbol.

As Mr. Cheney recounted in his American Enterprise Institute speech, the immediate aftermath of Sept. 11 was an extraordinarily challenging time in which the George W. Bush administration made tough choices from the bunker that kept the country safe from a repeat attack on American soil.

Some of those tough choices proved difficult to sustain over the years. Such was the case of sending al Qaeda- and Taliban-linked detainees to Guantanamo and holding them under the international-law-of-war context similar to prisoners of war - though technically without the same rights, as they were unlawful enemy combatants, along with a lack of meaningful transparency that undermined public accountability.

I admittedly do not know the details of Mr. Gordon or the rest of the team's intellectual foundations. However this combined with Mitt Romney's getting the PNAC band back together, it appears neocons and hawks are not out for the count, despite the Tea Party rhetoric. I do look forward to Herman Cain's expected foreign policy address, and how much it looks like Mitt Romney's recent speech, which was clearly influenced by the PNAC crowd, verses George W. Bush's "humble" plans for foreign policy in 2000. 



TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Anticipating Herman Cain's Foreign Policy:


Herman Cain, FED lackey and tax cheat. Yeah, the Tea Party is just gonna LOVE this guy. Calls us 'stupid' and 'ignorant' but can't 'remember' to pay his taxes. Riiiiight.. Says people without jobs are to blame while supporting big bank bailouts and FED secret loans. Why, you jes' call 'em right up (in his best Kingfish voice) all the while winking and smiling at us because to him WE are the stupid and ignorant ones. I'd sooner have my hair set on fire than vote for that fool.

Please have Herman Cain go to youtube and put in Milton Friedman (economist) and Phil Donahue, 1979, but still relevant for today. If someone had followed his advice we would not be in the pickle we are in now.

Herman Cain and Newt Gingrich, a terrific combo, in either office.

life is hard for us to make dream.

I like you have framed this particular issue

@Louis Nardozi: Your mother must be so proud of you! You mastered the CTRL-C / CTRL-P commands on that fancy keyboard! I love reading Ron Paul talking points cut and pasted from the daily briefing! What is this, the 3rd or 4th time you made that same comment? While I appreciate your spirit none of you Paulbots sway my support for Herman Cain. You folks can't seem to understand that the more you try to tear down your opponents the worse it makes your candidate look. You guys just look kooky to most of us regular folks. Just sayin.

so.. joesixpack... you like herman cain because he's a smooth talker? That's the only thing I can come up with - he's not an economic genius (he literally said the housing bubble wouldn't lead to recession - also, just for giggles: google enron Herman Cain, you'll enjoy that). It's certainly not his consistency - as he has None. Nor could it be his claim that he's not a washington insider because, last I checked, a lobbyist for the restaurant association, Federal Reserve Branch Chairman, and congressman hopeful (who the people in his own district didn't trust enough to give him the job) are the very definitions of washington insider.

People like you make me laugh - you wear your refusal to look at the facts and research a candidate's past like a badge then elect people like Barack Obama.

Amazing post! I like it.

What is this, the 3rd or 4th time you made that same comment? While I appreciate your spirit none of you Paulbots sway my support for Herman Cain.

This astonishing article, I like it

The comments to this entry are closed.

Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Powered by TypePad


The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use