Democracy Arsenal

« The Trouble With Petraeus | Main | Global War on Terror RIP »

April 29, 2011

The Trouble with Petraeus Pt. 2
Posted by Michael Cohen

So I hadn't quite realized how unpopular David Petraeus was in Pakistan until I read this piece in the New York Times today:

The appointment of Gen. David H. Petraeus as director of the Central Intelligence Agency puts him more squarely than ever in conflict with Pakistan, whose military leadership does not regard him as a friend and where he will now have direct control over the armed drone campaign that the Pakistani military says it wants stopped.

Pakistani and American officials said that General Petraeus’s selection could further inflame relations between the two nations, which are already at one of their lowest points, with recriminations over myriad issues aired publicly like never before.

The usually secretive leader of the Pakistani Army, Gen.Ashfaq Parvez Kayani, has made little secret of his distaste for General Petraeus, calling him a political general.

Now it almost goes without saying that the CIA's relationship with Pakistan is the most important US agency relationship to any other country in the world. And on a good day, that relationship stinks (a situation only further inflamed by the Davis incident and Pakistan's general disinclination to do anything helpful for the United States in regard to the war Afghanistan and fighting al Qaeda). But it does beg the question, will the Petraeus selection make that relationship better or worse?

Now in a sense perhaps we shouldn't dwell on the issue. After all, the US relationship with Pakistan is in terrible shape and I genuinely don't think there is a good way to improve upon it unless we dramatically shift US strategy in Afghanistan. But if Petraeus is being picked in part because of his knowledge of the operational arts; if those operational arts are most relevant when it comes to the US relationship with Pakistan and in particular the fight against al Qaeda; and if Petraeus is mistrusted by the Pakistanis . . . well then what exactly is the value added of putting Petraeus in the DCI job? I'm not asking the question in jest; behind some fuzzy notion of "leadership" I'm at a loss in understanding why Petraeus is the best person for the job, especially since there seem to be a number of indicators that would point to him being the wrong man (not to mention the fact that it's impossible to believe that anyone at the White House actually trusts him).

Aha, but perhaps I've missed David Petraeus's most obvious attribute - over to you Mr. President:

I'm also very pleased that Leon's work at the CIA will be carried on by one of our leading strategic thinkers and one of the finest military officers of our time, General David Petraeus. 

Petraeus is one of our leading strategic thinkers? Interesting. Now clearly generals occasionally show some level of strategic enlightenment. Eisenhower comes to mind; so to does George Marshall, even Colin Powell for a brief moment - but field commanders? Isn't Petraeus's greatest skill on the tactical level? Where has he shown great strategic thinking? As a person who thought (among others) that the US not only could, but should conduct armed social work and nation building in Afghanistan, well I'm not sure that "great strategic thinker" is the description that comes to mind.

So aside from the obvious political advantage of keeping Petraeus inside the tent I'm just having hard time seeing why Petraues got picked . . . unless of course the political advantage is the reason why. But who would ever accuse the Obama Administration of putting the politics of foreign policy ahead of actual foreign policy decision-making?


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Trouble with Petraeus Pt. 2:


Nice information, many thanks to the author. Keep blogging an I like to share this information with all my friends.

These all are one of the political strategy which is looking really very interesting which it comes with certain level that can be desired in so many ways which is great.

thanks for you sharing. Keep blogging an I like to share this information with all my friends.

A "great strategic thinker" would have chosen CT, not COIN.

I don't think Petraeus is one of our leading strategic thinkers.

this website information and news are very nice, will visit this website everyday! thanks for you share!!

During the Cold War, the C.I.A. established itself as key, if clandestine, element in America's foreign policy apparatus, promoting coups in countries like Iran, Guatemala and others seen as sliding toward the embrace of the Soviet Union. Its biggest debacle in that era was the 1961 Bay of Pigs invasion, in which a C.I.A.-trained band of Cuban exiles were cut down on the beaches after President John F. Kennedy refused air support for a military operation that was generally regarded afterward as poorly planned and unrealistic. But the next year it was the C.I.A. that provided the intelligence that tipped American officials off to the Soviet effort to install missiles in Cuba missiles that were removed after President Kennedy stared down Nikita Krushchev in the Cuban Missile Crisis.


aches after President John F. Kennedy refused air support for

Youth is not a time of life, it is a state of mind.Spend life with who makes you happy, not who you have to impress.

I came to your article from another article and am really interested in this learning about this, I feel strongly about information and love learning more on this. If possible, as you gain expertise, It is extremely helpful for me.

America have done very good Work for Killing the Osama.

I agree with Mike New year is to make things ready for every one.

Response to Beats By Dr.Dre Beatbox Review.

Response to Beats By Dr.Dre Beatbox Review

Nice to read these all things.Its all about the Relationship of US Agency with any other country.

These all things are really informative. Its fantastic and great information. It all information contain relationship of Us agency with Pakistan.

As much as I want to believe its true that they made some serious mistakes you have to understand what they were up against gorilla warfare is never pretty and there is no winners as you are trying to root out rebels and terrorist the winners are not traditional like Maternity scrubs are untraditional for a nurse at child birth.

he beaches after President John F. Kennedy refused air support

I really glad to read all the things and i can get some extra knowledge after read to it.

Response to Beats By Dr.Dre Beatbox Review

Very good comment. The other day I used to be educated about this website and wanted to let you realize that I have been pleased, through his messages. I'll be signing up to feed blog and is expected next post.

Yeah, looking at all the wonderful contributions to modern life that have come from Arabs in the past millenium or so, it's clear they're about as smart as a box of rocks. Easily led, particularly easy to brainwash, can't control their animalistic urges (although the livestock don't seem to mind), prone to violence at the drop of a rag, they value death over life, what a great culture!

Very good comment.

Never done in the article comments, this is my first network comments, appreciate you sharing. Very good article

Good ! very good!

Never give up on anybody. Miracles happen every day.

I really liked it. conducted a serious analysis of the measure is added irony. interesting to read. impressive.

Thank you for this article. That's all I can say. You most definitely have made this blog into something special. You clearly know what you are doing, you've covered so many bases.Thanks!

this is my first time to visit this bog and i really like it and i find it very help full and very informative hope that you will keep it !

Very good comment. The other day I used to be educated about this website and wanted to let you realize that I have been pleased, through his messages. I'll be signing up to feed blog and is expected next post.

Weiner-crafted robots aren't funny? Since when? You and Castle can take your elitist 'humor' and sacrifice it to Satan on an altar.

Thank you for this article. That's all I can say. You most definitely have made this blog into something special. You clearly know what you are doing

All the information about the Pakistani Conundrum which you have shared all the important information. I read all fantastic things and getting more knowledge. Wonderful information.

If Gucci handbags Fall 2011 is any indication of what we’ll see from the rest of Milan Fashion Week, then I think my credit card is going to be begging for mercy when fall pre-orders start. The ready-to-wear had an easy, colorful, jet-set hippie feel to it with lavishly draped chiffon and vibrant furs, and the Replica Gucci Handbags Shop were just as luxurious. Exotics outnumbered regular leathers and some models carried multiple Fake Gucci HandBags, indicating Gucci’s emphasis on accessories for the season to come.

What was perhaps even more interesting than the colors or materials were the shapes that they took. Gucci is the latest brand to embrace the so-called “ lady scale” bag, and most of the runway options were sized for essentials only. If you’re a woman who needs to carry her whole life in her handbag, though, fret not; Knock off Gucci showed several larger New Replica Gucci bags as well.

Thanks so much for sharing this post. pellet millI like it very much.

After read the article.I have just one word to say,you are so brilliant.I like all of your article.Well done.

Thank you for your articles which let me think about my life and find out what to do. Your blog is like a mirror.

they are have an army?? o_O LOL, never think that it's possible. funny

Fun to see crochet and knit together, so few people are interested in both, it seems!

Nike has withdrawn a range of trainers called Dunk SB Low Men Purple Air Stab from its London store following the recent spate of knife deaths in the UK.

In the last couple of Fashion Air Shox NZ Women White/Pink days, the company said it removed the shoes from its Nike Town store in Oxford Circus, "given the current climate".
A total of 15 teenagers Nike Air Max 2011 Women Grey/Pink have been stabbed to death in the city this year.
A spokesman for Nike said the name for the running shoes came from stability, and had nothing to do with knives.
He said the retro range, which was only sold in the central London store, was "an unfortunate Cheap Nike Air Shox R3 Women Black/Pink coincidence timing-wise".
One style in the limited edition range, re-launched two years ago, carried the logo Runnin' 'n' Gunnin' on the inner lining and heel.
'Astonishing naivety'
"The shoe was first launched in 1988 as a stability Nike Air Max 24-7 Men Black/Red running shoe, hence the name Air Stab," the Nike spokesman said.
"It has nothing to do with Dunk SB Low Women White/Yellow/Blue knives or knife crime.
"While it may be an unfortunate coincidence timing-wise given current problems regarding knives, we completely reject the idea that we are in any way condoning or encouraging the issue of knife usage.
"Given the current Dunk SB High Shoes Men Allred ?climate, however, we have taken the step of withdrawing the shoe from our Nike Town store."
Charity Crime stoppers said it was "astonished that a major retailer such as Nike could be this naive and act so irresponsibly with Nike Air Shox R3 Men Cheap Black/Blue its marketing".
"With the current gun and knife epidemic that is sweeping our Dunk SB High Shoes Men White/Blue/Grey/Purple country we would expect retailers to be taking a more sensitive approach to promoting products to a young and impressionable market," they said.

So much interesting contents here! You can go to see promotional gifts ,just have a look,right now.

i am not interested in politics, but this one i can understand. So thank you very much.

Your article makes me stay in high spirits all the day!

Thank your for sharing your wonderful article. I very agree with your views from here.

i agree with your opinion....

Wonderful articles, let me have to this admiration

The first part of what the President said is sort of boilerplate: we won't impose democracy or our system of government on another country, yada-yada, even when we do.

I have tried inserts in my vibram shoes but it only makes it worse. Would these vibram 靴 five finger shoes work for me. Can they be used in aerobics classes. Can I get them in New Zealand. Any pain at all. I’m 6’6″ formerly heavily D1 recruited lineman when I was knocked out of vibram シューズ
sport with incurrably flat and maleformed feet – or so said vibram best doctors in Texas (I went to Drew Brees’s guy for example) They told me to take up a new sport.


Fanstatic insight, in particular for a politics novice / enthusiasts like myself!

TO be honest its bewildering Petraeus got picked up at all

True Religion Jeans gehören zu den trendigsten Jeans weltweit. Stars aller Branchen schwören auf True Religion. Möchten Sie eine dieser coolen Jeansmarke besitzen? Dann kaufen Sie die Jeans in True Religion Outlet. Unser True Religion Onlineshop bietet umfangreichste True Religion Herrenjeans mit Schnäppchenpreisen.

Hast du schon Ray Ban Sonnenbrillen, die wichtig für dein eigene Befinden ist und Ihr gesellschaftliches Ansehen bewahen können? Was? Noch nicht? Hier findest du sensationelle Lösungen - wir sind der ideale Partner für ihre perfekte Sonnenbrille. Hier können Sie coole und modische Ray Ban Wayfarer, Ray Ban Aviator u.a. bekannte Sonnenbrille von Ray Ban mit günstigem Preis online bestellen! Billige

Thomas Sabo ist einer der bekanntesten Marken von Schmuck und bietet heutzutage Anhänger, Armbänder, Chamrs, Ketten, Charmträger, Ketten, Bänder und so weiter. An Thomas Sabo Charms kann man verschiedene Ahänger hängen. Das reichhaltige und inspirierende Universum der Thomas Sabo Charms können Sie einfach

Veuillez trouver sur peinture huile, peinture portrait, art peinture ,et même peinture impressionismebg

including long-sleeve polos, short-sleeve polos, mostly including polos from the famous brand Ralph Lauren at the cheaper price and of good quality and design! What are you waiting for then? Here is your best

There were a few factors that had an impact on the United States. One is the fact that it's involved in three wars around the world.

China, while it is certainly less democratic than the U.S. and respects human rights much less, has not been involved in international war.

The only thing you will hear from Afghani or Pakistani Taliban will be "God! Please! Stop!"

Took me awhile to read all the comments, but I really love the article. It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!

The best kind of friend is the kind you can sit on a porch swing with,never say a word,and then walk away feeling like it was the best conversation you've ever had.

A very good article. I think I should tell more people to come and read this.

If you are willing to get great information, I think this blog is really awesome to have some good information.

Awesome article, will be recommending this to my politics class to take a look at.

Looks great feeling.

Great article.

I am really lucky that I came to know about this awesome blog.

i think you posted the great article :)

After read the article.I have just one word to say,you are so brilliant.I like all of your article.Well done.

We have gotten many great comments from our customers and earn a good reputation in foreign makerts, more than 90% customers are satisfied with our products and service, till now our online members are beyond 80,000. As of right now, we Replica Handbags currently serve customers from over 18 countries, and we are still growing. We really hope to expand our business through cooperation with individuals and companies from around the world.

wishing to be aware of more details on this subject ? then I prefer that you need to have a look at blogs relating to this particular issue for more clearing your thinking.

I came to know concerning your blog by google. I'm quite lucky that I discovered this site because it has some very nice details which will help myself and is particularly extremely helpful for several functions.

your opinion is right! I support you!

The article in your blog reminds me some old memory .That is good .It gives me happy .I think we will have a harmonious talk.Do you agree?

t is good .It gives me happ

As to our supposedly itchy cruise missile trigger finger, well op. cit. Ken Roth. But let me sketch a larger picture and resist the idea, speaking at least for one liberal, that the worldview focuses on social justice at the expense of other concerns.

discovered this site because it has some very nice

A real lot of useful info here!These are all great comments here. Very cool article.

moon cakes!

Ein weiterer Grund Ugg Boots Sale Australia hohe Umsätze mit Schuhen gesehen hat, ist, weil
Ugg Boots Günstig liefert ", einem luxuriösen Komfort,Ugg Boots
Ugg Boots Sale dass Käufer ein Geschenk für jedermann Ugg Boots wenn sich Größen erworben Ugg Boots sale werden abgerundet.

Canada Goose Expedition dunjakke og gjess strøk. Rabatt Canada Goose Jakker
Canada Goose Salg og Outle, Quality Warranty.Shop på vår butikk og kjøpe en favoritt en nå
Canada Goose Jakke dette site har de fleste af de modeller, 50% rabat salg, kan du spare 50% af Canada Goose Parka udgifterne.

I would really like to give thanks a lot for the work you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same perfect job from you in the future too.

Among those posts I've seen, this is the most particular one, and I think the blogger must have spent lots of time on it, thank you so much!

Hello, Thanks for this fine blog. I think it is really a great topic to write about on my blog. Also here is some nice information:

Easily led, particularly easy to brainwash, can't control their animalistic urges (although the livestock don't seem to mind), .

Information like what you described here is going to be quite useful to me. I will post a link to this post on my site.

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the author has approved them.

This weblog only allows comments from registered users. To comment, please Sign In.

Emeritus Contributors
Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Powered by TypePad


The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use