Start Another Fire and Watch It Slowly Die: The Aftermath of Regime Change Posted by Eric Martin

Adam Curtis, a documentary filmmaker, traces a loose history of the modern concept of humanitarian intervention in the West and its philosophical underpinnings - punctuated, unsurprisingly, with several compelling documentary film clips.

While historians may quibble with certain aspects of his rendition, there was one passage that stood out: 

The movement had begun back in Biafra because a group of young idealists wanted to escape from the old corrupt power politics. To do this they had simplified the world into a moral struggle between good and evil.

They believed that if they could destroy the evil - by liberating victims from oppression by despots - then what would result would be, automatically, good.

But the problem with this simple view was that it meant they had no critical framework by which to judge the "victims" they were helping. And the Baghdad bombing made it clear that some of the victims were very bad indeed - and that the humanitarians' actions might actually have helped unleash another kind of evil. [emphasis added]

These concerns speak directly to my apprehensions about US military involvement in Libya.  Even a muscular No-Fly-Zone was not likely going to prove sufficient to enable an out-trained and out-gunned rebel force to topple Qaddafi, yet escalating after that fact was made clear by sending in ground forces would be ill-advised to say the least (two wars is likely enough for the moment).  Even arming the rebels (like a No-Fly-Zone, this option has a certain arms-length, antiseptic appeal on the surface) is an extremely risky endeavor, with the potential to destabilize the nation and its environs for decades to come.

More importantly, as I tried to emphasize in my prior piece, we should be careful what we wish for: if the rebels do manage to usurp Qaddafi, what comes next could prove worse in many respects.  It is not fanciful to imagine that a country with no history of democratic rule and weak civil institutions would be fertile ground for violent purges, power struggles, protracted civil wars and/or insurgencies (with forces loyal to Qaddafi attempting to re-claim the power and privilege recently lost - see, ie, the Baathists in Iraq - and rebel forces keen to settle scores - see, ie, the Mahdi Army purges in and around Baghdad).  These armed conflicts would be exacerbated if the rebels receive large amounts of weapons, and the country is awash in arms.

Would the US feel compelled to intervene if such situations were to evolve as a direct result of our armed intervention? Would we commit to policing the population and nation building lest such conflicts run rampant?  Either scenario would be enormously costly and time consuming, both of which are understatements in the extreme. 

But as the Curtis quote illustrates, we can not and should not assume that merely removing an odious regime will inevitably lead to a positive outcome, or that the forces that oppose a given despot must be, ipso facto, righteous.

The essential lessons from Iraq and Afghanistan should not be limited to the notions that wars are almost always far more costly than advertised (in monetary terms), that they unleash myriad unforeseen destructive forces that can have regional implications and that disengaging from them is exceedingly difficult (already, we have been in Afghanistan longer than the Soviets, and our impending deadline to withdraw from Iraq is causing much consternation for US military leaders). 

That list must include the proposition that unseating even a noxious regime is no guarantee that the aftermath will be easily manageable, conflict free or anything short of tragic for the populations that we are ostensibly attempting to help - or that there are not also noxious elements amongst our putative allies in the underlying population.

Comments

[ThePlatoReport]

No one said that Libya needs a defined conclusion. A massive genocide was avoided, and even if the result is an awkward standoff for the next however many years, that's still better than whatever the alternative would have been. After all, state boundaries are malleable and the inception of new states (i.e. the rebel state's new border) happens all the time. In short, Libya may end poorly, but at least it won't end horribly.

Frankly, it appears this blog post may have been fully digested by the administration. We're not using ground forces, and Congress won't be talking about the situation any time soon. We've thrown our hands up and are walking away, a very smart decision.

Sincerely,
ThePlatoReport.com

[Jeffrey C. Goldfarb]

The American policy as explained by the President tries to address the balance between humanitarian aid and regime change, attempting to avoid the problems of interventions past. Success depends on Libyans, America's allies and people of the region. http://www.deliberatelyconsidered.com/2011/03/obama%E2%80%99s-speech-on-libya/

[Eric Martin]

A massive genocide was avoided

Genocide? I don't think you're using that term correctly, and the error is only compounded by your use of "massive" to further embellish.

[replica handbags]

Looking really nice post.

[jordan shoes]

Thank you for this article. That's all I can say. You most definitely have made this blog into something special. You clearly know what you are doing, you've covered so many bases.Thanks!

[Designer Swimwear]

I like your article very much, support you.

[Bikinis 2011]

Thank you. I learned a lot from your article.

[Business Loans]

The official UN policy is to protect civilians, but not intervene for the purposes of Regime change. Given that, if the rebels cannot obtain arms (which is what the piece is obviously hoping for) it would seem that Kadhafi would win by default. Their are three choices: Kadhafi wins, outside forces depose him and install a new government, or armed Libyan rebels defeat Kadhafi. Which one do you support?

[Nike Lebron]

Thank you for this article. That's all I can say. You most definitely have made this blog into something special. You clearly know what you are doing

[Adidas Shoes]

All the information about the Pakistani Conundrum which you have shared all the important information. I read all fantastic things and getting more knowledge. Wonderful information.

[Nike Air Max]

Really appreciate this post. It’s hard to sort the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it!

[Tory Burch]

This is really fantastic work dude..The Way in which You represt this blog is awesome.i really apporicate your work. Keep it up in future..Visit my link as well.

[Lacoste Shoes]

It’s really great article. I would like to appreciate your work and would like to tell to my friends.

[Evisu Jeans]

The spiracles are pretty cool. More on those later

[Jeremy Scott]

I like pics of Chelsea shares of the beauty of running in Madison, Wisconsin.

[MBT Sale]

I want to congratulate the winner for the nomination race.I want to know suggestion from others.

[Air Force 1]

The nomination of the winner depends on the capability and spirit of the personality to finish the race.I like the post

very much as it contain informative in knowledge.

[Nike Shox]

Perhaps this is one of the most interesting article that I have ever seen.

[airjordanseller]

One of the basic Michael jordan shoes for sale details that you need to know Michael Jordan shoes is that you will find that with Air Jordan shoes , ALL of them are manufactured outside of the

United States. There is NO genuine manufacturing plant within the United States and any store that says they are selling genuine USA made air Jordan shoes are in fact selling you a knock off and

if you purchase from a business cheap Jordan shoes that says this they will in fact scamming YOU.

[Authentic Pandora]

Ideas or processes that fail only hihghlight what soesn't/didn't work - just don't do them again, try a different way, idea, or subject.

[louboutin heels]

What a great and amazing thing what you had shared with us thanks for such a nice sharing.

[Ringring]

My brain has gone blank for a long time. I don't know what I should write about this articel.

[MBTシューズ]

Fantastic to hear from you and how are you doing? All the plans on your proposal are totally acceptable. Thank you for you hard work.

[Short Bridesmaid Dresses]

If you intend to study a language entirely at home, then Rosetta stone is the best alternative to sitting in a class room. Another benefit of utilizing this powerful language learning tool is in preparation for a college course.

[pandora bracelets sale]

spreading them out everywhere, only because they make, maybe a tiny mistake. It is too horrible to look at.

[converse new]

This is a very good post. I have read many articles here. All the articles are very excellent. As an English learner, this article is a little difficult for me to understand.

[Mont Blanc Pen]

What is friendship?Mont Blanc PenWhy do we call a person our friend? When do we call someone a very good friend?

[Louboutin Pumps]

Read your article is very happy.Thanks.

[Christian Louboutin Outlet]

Sorry,i don't know how to receive my response, why?

http://www.christianlouboutindiscounts.com/

[Griffey Shoes]

Your article makes me stay in high spirits all the day!

[Office 2010 Product Key]

This is a very good post. I have read many articles here

[Pandora Canada]

This blog is so great.

[Air Yeezy]

You can share some of your article, I'm like you write something, really very good! I will continue to focus on.

[wholesale knockoff handbags]

great! I like it

[Ray Ban Polarized Sunglasses]

thank for share with this blog

[Thomas Sabo]

An extremely good post. This short article sums up for me precisely what this topic depends upon and some of the major benefits that can be resulting from knowing about it as if you. A friend once remarked that you have a totally different frame of mind when you do something for real as opposed to when you’re simply toying with it. In the case of this kind of topic, I believe you adopt, or start to consider, a more professional in addition to thorough approach to what and how you write, which in turn helps you to carry on and get better and help others who don’t know anything about what you have discussed here. Thank you.

[replica panerai]

Thank your for sharing your wonderful article. I very agree with your views from here.

[cheap air jordans]

And they would require protection from the American forces amounting to interposing American mil bodies between The next 3 dangers will be harder to ward off, although a number of the same steps may be helpful for each:

UN bodies and harms way. What would be the advantage of involving the UN again?

[coach bags outlet]

Serving under a far more high-maintenance superior like Hillary Clinton, who with her entourage will likely seek to make her own mark on foreign policy rather than leave it to a subordinate

[replica handbags]

i agree with your opinion....

[replica watches]

Thanks for sharing it with us.May you have a wonderful day!

[prom dresses on sale]

The first part of what the President said is sort of boilerplate: we won't impose democracy or our system of government on another country, yada-yada, even when we do.

[backpack]

I really agree with you!!!

[Nike Air Max]

The man with a new idea is a crank until the idea succeeds .

[Cheap Bikinis]

If you doubt yourself , then indeed you stand on shaky11 ground .

[Air Jordan 7]

Thanks for the introduction! I am always reading your blog and only today I have spotted the post with introduction! I am one hundred percent sure that Jodi is cool as other members are. Good luck in your future work

[Ken Griffey Jr Shoes]

That will really help us all. And this might bring some good repute to you.

[Ken Griffey Jr Shoes]

That will really help us all. And this might bring some good repute to you.

[Air Yeezy]

I want to congratdfulate the winner for the nomination race.I want to know suggestion from others.

[Air Jordan]

i come here first time. You can share some of your article, I'm like you write something, really very good! I will continue to focus on

[Lacoste Trainers]

Only an injunction)0f the lessening Can avoid that problem． Defendant： 1)Our name accurately reflected the first BaFfle of the owner of the store．andwe used the word“secret”as a kind of inside ioke because we wanted to keep the new business a secret from a former boss at a competing store．

[Cheap Bikinis]

The nomination of the winner depends on the capability and spirit of the personality to finish the race.I like the post very much as it contain informative in knowledge.I like pics of Chelsea shares of the beauty of running in Madison, Wisconsin.I want to congratulate the winner for the nomination race.I want to know suggestion from others.

[Griffey Shoes]

Interesting read!!! Your website is fantastic with informative content which i like to add to my favourites.

[Asics Onitsuka Tiger]

Expericence is a hard teacher because she gives the test first, the lesson afterwards.

[cheap tiffany]

I ordered this bracelet because i fell in love with it online. I thought that it was a good deal for what the description said.. when it arrived, i took it out of the box and was completely dissapointed! It's extremely small,and very light weight. i wouldnt recommend this for an adult. this is a childs bracelet. wish i could get my money back.tiffany jewelry

[mercurial soccer cleats]

The first part of what the President said is sort of boilerplate: we won't impose democracy or our system of government on another country, yada-yada, even when we do.

[Cheap Sandals]

Trick and treachery are the practice if fools；they have not wit enough to be honest.

[Christian Louboutins]

Sloth turneth the edge of wit.
s

[jinlala]

Always good to see, this was a brilliant post. In theory I would like to write like this too. You need time to creat that interesting and additionally real effort to make such a good article

[Nike Air Max]

i agree with your views from here.

[Air Jordan]

Thank you so much ,i am feeling so nice after reading your article!

[Air Max Shoes]

Time waits for no man.
s

[Asics Tiger]

Don’t put the cart before the horse.
2

[nikedunkheels]

Thank you, it's been very interestingly.

[coach bags outlet]

HHH Serving under a far more high-maintenance superior like Hillary Clinton, who with her entourage will likely seek to make her own mark on foreign policy rather than leave it to a subordinate

[Cash loans]

What a great and amazing thing what you had shared with us thanks for such a nice sharing.

[Slava Ivanov]

if you purchase from a business cheap cash advance loans Jordan shoes that says this they will in fact scamming you.

[Chinaproducts]

As the Obama administration steps up its support for regime change in Syria, the Arab Spring is moving into what could be its hottest phase.

[fashion furnishings]

Lets Not Forget: Bush Planned Iraq 'Regime Change' Before Becoming President. By Neil Mackay. 15 September 2002.

[chaussures puma]

We always have time enough , if we will but use it aright.

[Polo Outlet]

I was in low spirits before,but now i read your writting,i feel a little better!

[drebeats]

Thank you so much ,i am feeling so nice after reading your article!

[OG Air Jordans]

I have to state, you chose your words well. The ideas you wrote on your encounters are well placed. This is an incredible blog!

[xiao]

The best kind of friend is the kind you can sit on a porch swing with，never say a word，and then walk away feeling like it was the best conversation you've ever had.

[oakley sunglasses]

Took me awhile to read all the comments, but I really love the article. It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!

[OG Air Jordans]

Such a good writing, or by I saw for the first time. I'm quite happy, you are a good writer!

[beats dre studio]

Looks great feeling.

[dr dre solo]

Great article.

[live support chat software]

Really appreciate this post. It’s hard to sort the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it!

[NFL]

it’s hard to sort the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it!

[Oakley Sunglasses]

realized exactly how many bad things had happened in Iraq, in Washington, and around the world in the last three you months. You don’t get the full scope

[Coogi Clothing]

Really nice work guys!! Your studio seems to be an amazing workplace. I would not fail to advertise you.

[cheap Coogi Clothing]

Thats an newsworthy displace. It was worth visiting your blog. Desire to communicate again.

[Cheap Bridesmaid Dresses]

Amazing and useful list. I am just trying to find the Mortgage Brokers related blogs and forums and finally i got it.

[casino]

A pirate must live by the code.

[chaussures femmes]

We have gotten many great comments from our customers and earn a good reputation in foreign makerts, more than 90% customers are satisfied with our products and service, till now our online members are beyond 80,000. As of right now, we Replica Handbags currently serve customers from over 18 countries, and we are still growing. We really hope to expand our business through cooperation with individuals and companies from around the world.

[easy profitbot review]

I consider myself a blessed person for the reason that I am some of those that came to know concerning your blog. This site delivers really special data that help individuals and I wish I may attempt to share the message of this blog.

[cheap louis vuitton handbags]

your opinion is right! I support you!

[clip in hair extensions]

Congratulations to you and to Oren. Sounds like an ideal match; cant' wait to see what comes of it!

[Instant payday loans]

Really appreciate this post. It’s hard to sort the good from the bad sometimes

[xixihaha]

It is time to buy a homecoming dress for youself.Do you want to be the homecoming queen?If your answer is 'YES'.You'd better search for your homecoming dress as soon as possible.Bright colors are so in this year.Remember, this isn't a prom or graduation ceremony. Homecoming is about fun! Dresses can still look formal, but this year you should be jazzing up your look with bright or even neon colors. Hot pink, electric blue; show your wild side and don't forget to color-match your makeup and accessories.Short skirts are a must. . If you're going to be dancing away the night then you don't want a long skirt tripping you up at every turn! Homecoming is a great chance to be a bit less formal, so ditch the long gown and go short!A-Line or ball gown style is ideal. Every year girls are wondering what the best style is for some serious partying at homecoming! Well in 2011 we're saying that you need to choose A-Line or ball gown style gowns as these are going to be really comfortable for dancing as well as being flattering for almost ANY body shape!Choose iridescent taffeta. 2011 is the year of iridescent taffeta. Here comes the best part though, following 2011's trends and still getting the dresses cheaply!

And now let me tell you where can buy these dressses:

Dress store/This is one site which belong to our company..we are provide a lot of new style homecoming dresses. And we will update the products every month.

Gsdresses/It is belong to our company,too.we will update the products every month and send you conpon non-periodical.

Mldress/We not only provide customize homcoming dresses but also send the new product list to you. If you are lucky,you may get the conpon non-periodical.

Don't be shillyshally,To get your new homecoming dresses as soon as possible.

[sending Christmas gifts Southafrica]

Really your post is really very good and I appreciate it. It’s hard to sort the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it. You write very well which is amazing. I really impressed by your post.

[Boston Market Coupons]

"More importantly, as I tried to emphasize in my prior piece, we should be careful what we wish for: if the rebels do manage to usurp Qaddafi, what comes next could prove worse in many respects."

We're there in a coalition to protect civilians under the UN mandate, under the leadership of NATO. Our success needs to be measured on those terms, not as regime changers.

[replica wallets]

Obama also pointedly accused Iran of being "hypocritical" in its reaction to the Arab Spring and predicted that other Middle Eastern countries will eventually punish Iranian leader Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

[knockoff handbags]

I would really like to give thanks a lot for the work you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same perfect job from you in the future too.

[Wholesale baseball jerseys]

Great idea! Love seeing a creative mind work and gain success!!!!!! Hope it continues to grow!

[Karen Millen 2011]

sweet spring,Karen Millen Sale full of sweet days and roses,a box where sweets compacted lie,my music shows ye have your closes,Karen Millen 2011 and all must die.

[Auto Glass Repair Austin TX]

You guys are bringing really good topics and writing the great article. This one is really great! Thanks again.

[knock off handbags]

I would really like to give thanks a lot for the work you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same perfect job from you in the future too.

[replica louis vuitton handbags]

After read the article.I have just one word to say,you are so brilliant.I like all of your article.Well done.