Democracy Arsenal

« Back to the Top of the Slide | Main | Credit Where Credit Is Due, Obama Played This Beautifully »

February 11, 2011

Don't Believe the Hype: The Surge as a Sequel
Posted by Eric Martin

While myth-making and propagandizing can be useful tools in political contests, such embellishments can pervert policy if taken literally. As a general rule, it is best not to believe the hype - even your own. One recent example of this credulity is the conventional wisdom that has coalesced around the "Surge" in Iraq and the supposed benefits that resulted from that policy.

According to the myth, the brilliant visionary General David Petraeus shifted US forces in Iraq to a counterinsurgency (COIN) footing based on the COIN manual he wrote and that switch, together with an influx of 30,000 additional troops, led to victory in Iraq.

In reality, hundreds of Iraqis are still dying each month in political violence, though that tragic figure is far lower than the thousands per month that preceded the Surge. Serious obstacles still remain on the political front as well, with potential for violence to erupt in the future along several existing fault lines. Further, Petraeus didn't write the COIN manual, in either the literal or figurative sense. More importantly, though, it was not the influx of additional soldiers, or implementation of COIN doctrine, that played the most important part in leading to a reduction of the violence in Iraq.

Rather, the causal factors were indigenously conceived: First and foremost, the bulk of the Sunni insurgency made the decision to adandon insurgent activities, pursue political avenues and cooperate with coalition forces in targeting al-Qaeda elements (with such a turnabout commencing prior to the Surge, or Petraeus' arrival on the scene). In addition, Moqtada al-Sadr, putatitive leader of the largest Shiite insurgent faction, also changed course, ordering his loosely organized militia to stand down.

In essence, the main combatants comprising the insurgency opted to pursue their interests primarly via the political apparatus, and abandoned attacks on coalition and Iraqi government targets (in addition to the fact that the population transfers reduced sectarian tensions, and general exhaustion from fighting pervaded).

To Petraeus' credit, he was quick to seize on the outreach from insurgent groups and the extra soldiers likely enhanced our capacity to take the fight to al-Qaeda with our new Sunni allies. He deftly took advantage of the opportunities presented by both the Sunni detente and Sadr's stand down.

What the Surge taught us, then (or rather, reminded us of), is that insurgencies can be wound down when the vast majority of the combatants join the political process and abandon violence, and that we should seek to encourage and facilitate such developments when doing so is consistent with our overarching interests.

Unfortunately, the Obama administration seems to have bought in to the mythologized version of the Surge, and has attempted to recreate in Afghanistan the successes realized in Iraq by simply adding additional soldiers, and shifting to a COIN-infused approach.

Predictably, the fighting continues: insurgent attacks are occurring at an accelerated pace, with estimates of Taliban numbers remaining constant during the recent escalation. Despite a coordinated effort by military leaders to put recent events in Afghanistan in a positive light, tangible gains using any observable metric remain elusive.

Perhaps, then, it is time to pay closer attention to the reality of the Surge, and test available opportunities to wind down the conflict through the political inclusion of the main group comprising the insurgency: the Taliban.

As Michael Cohen noted, a recent report by Alex Strick Van Linschoten and Felix Kuehn explores the possibility that the Taliban and al-Qaeda could be separated as part of a negotiated political settlement with the current Afghan government, and US/NATO forces. Although admittedly optimistic, the report even includes this tantalizing prospect for military cooperation akin to that enjoyed by US forces working in tandem with Sunni groups in Iraq:

One such vision – recently suggested in private by a senior Taliban political strategist – is that Taliban forces could conduct counterterrorism operations, including joint operations together with U.S. Special Forces, against al-Qaeda and possibly its affiliates along the Afghanistan-Pakistan border.

That level of cooperation may never materialize, but something short of that could still be invaluable. Given that our primary strategic objective in Afghanistan should be to disrupt al-Qaeda and deny that group a base of operations, we should pursue negotiations with the Taliban to test the feasability of at least a separation of the two groups.

Such a settlement might involve including groups whose human rights record we might find noxious, but it is important to note that there are current factions within Karzai's government with equivalent records. We must engage the players in Afghanistan, regardless of what our ideal outcome would look like.

Unfortunately, our current strategy might be forcing the Taliban to rely more and more on al-Qaeda, sowing mistrust and giving rise to a younger, more radical crop of Taliban leaders who are taking the place of senior commanders killed or captured. Pursuit of negotiations would require a more consistent approach, without various tactics working at cross-purposes and proving counterproductive to what should be the strategic imperative.

While there is no guarantee that a negotiated settlement with the Taliban would be possible within parameters that satisfy our interests, or that enough Taliban elements would be willing to abandon al-Qaeda at an acceptable price, it is essential that we explore the possibilities further. What the Surge taught us is that the quickest way to wind down an insurgency is to turn the insurgents into allies and political participants, not rely on superstar generals or over-hyped tactical approaches.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Don't Believe the Hype: The Surge as a Sequel:


Petraeus was McChrystal­'s boss and as you noted, he signed off on the plan and the date. We need to hold him and the President to that commitment­. They seem to think a shift in personnel allows them to move the goal post again. It doesn't.


Rather, the causal factors were indigenously conceived: First and foremost, the bulk of the Sunni insurgency made the decision to adandon insurgent activities, pursue political avenues and cooperate with coalition forces in targeting al-Qaeda elements (with such a turnabout commencing prior to the Surge, or Petraeus' arrival on the scene). In addition, Moqtada al-Sadr, putatitive leader of the largest Shiite insurgent faction, also changed course,

You are a very intelligent individual!

I love you, noise cancelling headphones.

Timberland boots - almost Timberland Shoes everyone knows it. As famous boots, Timberland with its high quality and warm feeling become the most popular one among the crowd. For the long development of boots, Timberland company introduce Timberland sale activity to attractive customers.Timberland has the most excellent type of casual and working boots. In its over 25 years of existence, Timberland Company has initiated a wide number of state of the art technologies in shoes to provide only the best quality. Timberland was the one of the first companies to create the first ever guaranteed waterproof leather boots. After coming up with this, Timberland has since earned the reputation for making first-rate, rugged footwear. Timberland boots are perhaps the toughest shoes to date. Each boot has been carefully crafted and beautifully designed for daily wear by hardworking professionals who deserve only the durability, comfort and floor protection that they need on the job.Nowadays, Timberland sale has a clothing line of quality outdoor is bought by people who want to look good and also to those who need strong clothing for hiking. The range is impressive. They have coats, raincoats and tents. Everything a person could want.There outdoors is no doubt that Doc Martins are the world's number one casual boot.Timberland boots that seem to offer intelligent and strong, with any type of clothing, mens timberland boots, while at the same time, not only does provide.Timberland affordable.And boots also have shoes that can be used on formal occasions . The different styles are the shoes of Montgomery Bay, Madison and Summit Carsbad Shavaro shoes. big shoes to impress your boss, whether new or girlfriend. All designed for use by men.Timberland high top boots Classic Boots Sale Online Shop is very popular in Japan, the joint United States and Japan, the original brand of old undefeated street level with the launch of joint brand shoes WTAPS, this set a style Timberland Classic Timberland Boots sale 3-eyelet Timberland Boots shoes Lug, the finger of a grain car grid line pattern, the shoes with a hair and nail design of three main brands of the standard. This sale will be the undefeated Timberland Boots stores sale.New Caliburn Japan Series (men) Timberland Caliburn series produced footwear for the foot to provide continuous 360 degree comfort all year round.Timberland work boots are different from other brands because they only come in brown and black, but in a variety of colors that style over the years and for almost every occasion. Mens Melbourne Timberland boots are durable enough to be used as work or hiking boots, but looks are stylish and comfortable enough to use Cheap Timberland boots anytime. Whether you are in market for good quality, durable pair of boots that will last you season after season in hiking boots Timberland mountain road is the direction you should always say go.Many lovers Timberland, Timberland boots itself is a advantage.Timberland boots are available in all department stores and shoe shops worldwide. They are also available through online shops for those who prefer to enjoy seamless purchases online. However, if you would like a great deal, Timberland boots are available. With the feeling of comfortable, it is worth for you to own Timberland boots as you best lovers.

I also like this policy and also it is much interesting and also attractive and beneficial. Obama is a very great person for everything.

hanks for blogging this, it was quite helpful and showed me tons

it is good

I have recently started using the and I having some problems here? in your blog you stated that we need to enable write permissions on

i can get some info form your article,,thanks.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Powered by TypePad


The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use