Democracy Arsenal

« Five Reasons To Take Hamid Karzai's Latest Rant Seriously | Main | Steve Benen skewers Kyl on START »

November 16, 2010

What if Muslims don't want to become "liberals"?
Posted by Shadi Hamid

It's easy to make fun of those who overhype the supposedly impending imposition of sharia law within the United States. The Muslims are not taking over, at least not anytime soon. There’s, um, like, 1 percent of us in the United States. At the same time, though, we shouldn’t pretend that there aren’t tensions or tradeoffs. There are. There was the recent case of Muslim students asking for female-only swim hours at the George Washington swimming pool. Not the end of the world. But my friend Evan Hill raised concerns about the precedent and said so on twitter. What ensued was an interesting foray into the tensions, both real and imagined, between the practice of Islam and the norms of an ostensibly secular society (The tensions between freedom, liberalism, and democracy is a challenging one to have over twitter).

What if there was a Muslim-majority district in the US and Muslims asked that the local beach be closed off for a couple hours every week to allow observant Muslim women to swim? There are other hypotheticals, most of them unlikely, but some perhaps plausible. All other things being equal, Muslims seem somewhat different than Christians and Jews. At this point in time, Muslims, for a complex set of reasons, seem to be somewhat immune to the sort of secularization that so many Western liberals (and, oddly, Christian conservatives) seem to want for them.

In Europe, there will come a time when cities like Berlin become plurality or majority Muslim. Well, then, what if you have a majority in the local council of a German town who want to restrict alcohol licensing for religious reasons? These tensions are more evident in Muslim-majority countries, where we seem unable to consistently support democracy, precisely out of fear that more democracy will bring with it less liberalism (and more opposition to American foreign policy). This might be a trite way of putting it, but what if Muslims don’t want to become “liberals”?

I’ve always felt that this was the best definition of a “democrats” (small-d) – those willing to support democratic elections even, or particularly, when they’re sure people they really, really don’t like will win. At least as far as foreign policy is concerned, this is a test that many – too many – Americans have failed. 


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What if Muslims don't want to become "liberals"? :


In summer, we should wear a skirt that has swinging scene, wearing a small skirt that can expose body, with a variety of silver jewelry, pandora necklace, rings and pandora bracelets. Our youth should be bloom in this season.
Occasionally I pass a Pandora bracelet store, and that beautiful blue robin makes this hot summer more comfortable, and gives people a refreshing cool feeling. We can go the shop to take a look at that beautiful fine pandora jewellery. That beautiful jewelry on there is really very enjoyable. This makes me to think of San Mao. San Mao is a writer who I like most, I often read her book, he has a lot of collection of the treasure, those treasures may not be very valuable things, but each one has its own story.

one word, jordans 2010 christmas free shipping www yessneaker com free shipping

This is a very good blog. I appreciate very much this text, thank you.

"All other things being equal, Muslims seem somewhat different than Christians and Jews." - yeah, no shit

OF COURSE Muslims don't want to become liberals - their religion prohibits it! This is the fundamental conflict between secular Western democracies and conservative Muslim theocracies - secular freedom (to drink, dance, look at females, et cetera) versus religious lifestyle restrictions.

And you can call a theocracy a democracy all you want, but as long as the laws are based on religious mores and texts and the people with influence are mullahs and sheikhs and Majlis, it's a theocracy, regardless of whether elections are technically held.

The idea of starting an content creation and marketing campaign might appear just like a daunting activity, yet if you are taking it one action at a time, it will become much more workable.

Boy oh boy! I can't wait until Berlin becomes a majority muslim city. That will be uber kewl. I'm sure the Germans are very excited about those prospects. Stockholm, London and Paris are not far behind. Why would anyone in their right mind want to be a liberal infidel when you can be muslim? I mean liberals give you welfare, high taxes, crappy socialized medicine, self-loathung and of course lots of civil rights to criminals. But with Islam you get 72 virgins, you can grow your beard like ZZ Top and stone the devil! I vote Islam! It's way more fun than being a cry baby liberal.

Fiber Optic Splice ClosureSounds good except for the fact that you cant control what they put in the adverts and it sounds like they are very picky, so I suppose this one's not for me...

What a well-researched article — thanks for putting in the time to look into the back-stories of all these famous brands. I had no idea the Twitter bird came from iStockPhoto, of all places!

If you go a little bold,
Emu boots you can also choose from some bright hues like pink,Emu Boots lilac, baby blue and so forth. Visvim Some vibrant patterns like sunflower print,Moonboots colorful fireworks can be also found on these simply Emu Australia Boots classic tall boots!

this is a very good blog!~

The comments to this entry are closed.

Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Powered by TypePad


The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use