Democracy Arsenal

« Hard Is Not Hopeless | Main | Egyptians are Getting Angry »

August 02, 2010

The Failure of Perry-Hadley and the Growing Debate Over the Defense Budget
Posted by The Editors

This post is by Gordon Adams, Distinguished Fellow at the Stimson Center. 

The struggle to discipline the defense budget and reign in the Department of Defense has begun.  Growing concern about the deficit, combined with growing disenchantment over the situation in Afghanistan and concern about the endlessly expanding role of DOD in US foreign policy have combined to put this issue squarely on the table.

The latest round in this debate is the report of the Independent Review Panel on the DOD Quadrennial Defense Review.  This report, chaired by former Secretary of Defense William Perry and former National Security Adviser Steven Hadley, is longer than the Quadrennial Defense Review itself. It is also a great disappointment, as was the QDR.

It betrays the continuing "suspension of disbelief" already painfully evident in the QDR.  Instead of bringing realism and discipline to defense planning, the report simply "doubles down" on the QDR’s analysis, calling for even more forces and more spending. The report willfully avoids three pressing national security realities.

The first is our looming fiscal crisis, which JCS Chairman Mike Mullen has called "our biggest national security threat." The report simply waives this issue aside; DOD planning, it seems to argue, must be done outside this context, as if budgets and the need for restraint did not exist.

Second, the Perry-Hadley report, like the QDR, assumes that all military missions are a priority, all are urgent, and the forces must grow to perform all of them. From counter-insurgency/stabilization/occupation/nation-building on the one hand, to a massive expansion of the forces for conventional war/deterrence/allied reassurance on the other, the report calls for more mission expansion, and, by implication, for even more funding than the unprecedented level of defense spending we already have today.   There is, here, no realistic assessment of the likelihood of challenges, no prioritization of missions, and no discrimination about US choices and interests.

Third, the report, like too many of our national security documents, assumes that US strategy should be driven by a Manichean world view, where threats around the globe are ever more present, dangerous, and challenging. While it pleads for a "whole of government" approach to our security, the focus of that "whole of government" is intended to pull all the US civilian architecture into the dark hole of perceived growing global violence and threat, to support military planning and deployment, focusing our civilian institutions on the way DOD should see the world.

The report is wrong on all three counts.  The fiscal crisis is real, it poses serious, long-term threats to American well-being and our global position.  The only solution, as already experienced from 1985 to 1998 (when we hit a surplus) is for all parts of federal spending and revenues to be on the table, including defense.  Defense budgets are now as large as any of the means-tested entitlement programs, and more than 55% of discretionary spending.  DOD budget planning has been undisciplined for more than ten years, leading to massive growth in defense overhead, a uniformed work force nearly half of which has never been deployed, many of whom are doing commercial functions, as the recent Defense Business Board interim report made clear.  Hardware program costs are out of control, with most being well above or significantly above projections, according to the Government Accountability Office.

It is time for budgetary restraint and discipline. Even Secretary Gates recognizes this reality, though the very small savings he seeks through management, structural, and overhead reforms are too easy to achieve and unlikely to reform an undisciplined institution. Defense budget reductions would provide such discipline and focus to DOD that it badly needs. And outside realities - the deficit reduction focus and the withdrawals from Iraq and Afghanistan - are making such reductions necessary, even inevitable.

Second, the commission seemed swayed by headline writers but not by reality.  Conflict makes good headlines, but the reality is that the US has never been more secure or less vulnerable to existential threats.  Its military is second to none, vastly superior in capability and technology relative to any global power, including China. Global conflict, moreover, for all the battle reports from Iraq, is down, not up, as are terrorist attacks. Outside of insurgents fighting the US military in Afghanistan, the world simply does not seem full of the insurgencies COIN doctrine was invented to fight.

Oddly, the high level of US security has stopped neither the QDR nor Perry-Hadley from arguing that we simply must expand the military to be the cutting edge of US global engagement, deterring threats, fixing fragile states, fighting insurgents, countering terrorists, building states, restoring economies and all of this on a global basis.  There is no discrimination here; every threat seems equal, every challenge is an American problem.

Historically, only imperial statecraft has assumed that all threats and challenges are the same and that the most powerful state has responsibility for all of them.  But for the United States, clearly, not all terrorists are alike; not all insurgents matter to us, and not all weak states need an American intrusion to fix them.  A more normal, discriminating statecraft would make those distinctions and lay out some choices.  Neither the QDR nor the Perry-Hadley report is discriminating; neither of them make the choices that are clearly open to us. The end result is a set of missions and forces that constitute little less than an open raid on the Treasury and the taxpayer, for no sum of money would ever be enough to meet the open-ended needs they describe.

Third, the report, like the QDR, betrays, sadly, an all-to-common reality of US strategic planning.  It is all done from a military perspective, and has been since the Nitze containment analysis of the late 1940's.  The challenges we face are all described as military challenges, and the missions of the military now continually expand to meet new challenges - from nation-building to public diplomacy to foreign assistance to advice on how to govern to solving the energy crisis to climate change.  There seems to be no end of the mission list and no end to the role of the military.  This is what Adm. Mullen was worried about when he warned of "the militarization of US foreign policy."

The Perry-Hadley report continues this tradition. It certainly endorses a strengthened civilian national security architecture, but it calls for this, in the very first instance, in order to deploy civilians alongside the military.  This is the "Iraq-Afghanistan" fallacy, which now permeates US strategic planning - all future wars will look like Iraq and Afghanistan.

It is important to be clear: in Iraq and Afghanistan the US intentionally invaded another country, in one case with a very large force, with the intent of taking down a regime.  It then inherited the occupation of those countries, with minimal allied support, and found itself unready to be an occupying power.

Unless the plan is to reproduce such invasions, take down other regimes, and inherit an occupation, the "whole of government" approach advocated by Perry-Hadley makes little sense.  It is not clear where such invasions are likely, not clear any other country would welcome them (especially given the Iraq and Afghanistan experiences), and not clear the American people are prepared to support the continuation of such a policy.

Creating a civilian capability to execute such a policy, side-by-side with the US military, is a mistaken enterprise, both expensive and unnecessary.  Instead, the strengthening of our civilian institutions should be focused on the broader problems of development and governance, which are civilian issues demanding civilian-led solutions.  The military should only play a secondary, not a leading role, in such efforts, and only when needed, invited, and welcomed.

This issue is one that needs to be urgently addressed by State and USAID in the context of the forthcoming Quadrennial Diplomacy and Development Review.  It involves strengthening the civilian institutions, while disciplining the defense institution to focus on its core missions and only the supporting role it ought to be offering civilian statecraft.

Perry-Hadley does not move the agenda forward; it is a step back from budget realities, from the urgent need for defense discipline, and from the real need for a civilian strategy for US engagement.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c04d69e20133f2cc6bad970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Failure of Perry-Hadley and the Growing Debate Over the Defense Budget:

Comments



The reports released recently iphone case by U. Manage on , Enjoy the bestE66 Dual SIM S. Internet digital camera traffic monitoring agency comScore shows that Microsoft`s share on American intellectual mobile phone market fell again. It has already fallen by 4 percentage points since last December, the newest data is only 15%. Though the ipad case share of google is not inferior to microsoft, according to comScore, data shows that google Android market share increases 5.2% in the same period, furtherly lessen the gap with microsoft. According blackberry keyboard to the trend, google soon will overpass software and become the third smartphone plate after iPhone and RIM.Adornment of TV80

Maybe, it is the reason that why microsoft concerns iphone deals mobile phone industry in 2010 so much. It has already released the new mobile operation system Windows Phone 7 Seires. In any case, microsoft will compete with iPhone and try to win back the lost market share due to the Windows Mobile 6.The Top 5 Best touch screen tft lcd google android 1.6 tablet pc




thanks for your post , and ytell us about that

merhaba arkadaşlar yusuf güney dinle blogumuza hoş geldiniz bu blogda yusuf güney dinle ve her şey yusuf güney dinle hadi hadi

remapping "Avatar", pandora and may add a new segment in which the. In the interview, Cameron confirmed the news: "We are currently completing an pandora bracelets additional 6 minutes of that clip, it requires a lot of special effects work, as Pandora's rings really amazing friends, pandora sale all are for August in the theater Remapping "Avatar."

Are these things so that they are still going forward. pandora In the absence of cheapest pandora bracelets to accompany, they would sigh, this is their tired performance. We will not be around all the trouble was, when we want to be happy happy together. This is the pandora rings productsto you all, pandora bracelets although many times we would be happy, After some time, his face still appears innocent smile. This is the benefits of childhood, innocence, innocent, and no trouble living with. pandora uk There may be people to say their lives are like as long as pandora style beads.

The annual red spot design big prize (red dot design award) is a global swarovski famous design big prize, the will in the commendation decoration design aspect creativity swarovski crystals product. Having the honor to receive the red spot big prize to mean that is blooming in the swarovski beads design aspect. This year altogether has 27 renowned designers to be swarovski rings selected. The appraisal committee appreciates the clock and watch technology swarovski necklace which specially this model of wristwatch's vanguard swarovski earrings contour as well as the Swarovski wonderful world is made with all one's strength in recent years .

merhaba arkadaşlar bu yazımızda sizlere pegasus bilet fiyatları konusu hakkında bilgilendirme yapıcaz.pegasus bilet fiyatları sizinde bildiğiniz gibi çok aranıyor.bizde şimdi buradakisohbetimizi bitirip pegasus bilet fiyatları konusuna geçiyoruz.

At this point, Swarovski wholesale is succinct besides swarovski the low key, the black small foreign-style clothing and it is also swarovski crystals representing the mystical feeling, increases the enticement swarovski jewelry charm for the world's the female. Each dazzling masterpiece which is designs specially, will swarovski wholesale include in the manufacture, the style magnificent photography centralism, it will take this project international project the luxurious record.

This section unfolds the Bordeaux red dark red tone swarovski enchanting Swarovski UK, is on exquisitely the swarovski crystals brown cotton rope. This model of chain falls for the relaxed optional modeling ads swarovski beads contains the careful embellishment, it is one section startled colorful matches the decoration perfectly.



The reports released recently iphone case by U. Manage on , Enjoy the bestE66 Dual SIM S. Internet digital camera traffic monitoring agency comScore shows that Microsoft`s share on American intellectual mobile phone market fell again. It has already fallen by 4 percentage points since last December, the newest data is only 15%. Though the ipad case share of google is not inferior to microsoft, according to comScore, data shows that google Android market share increases 5.2% in the same period, furtherly lessen the gap with microsoft. According blackberry keyboard to the trend, google soon will overpass software and become the third smartphone plate after iPhone and RIM.Adornment of TV80

Maybe, it is the reason that why microsoft concerns iphone deals mobile phone industry in 2010 so much. It has already released the new mobile operation system Windows Phone 7 Seires. In any case, microsoft will compete with iPhone and try to win back the lost market share due to the Windows Mobile 6.The Top 5 Best touch screen tft lcd google android 1.6 tablet pc




uçak bileti satın almanın çeşitli püf noktaları vardır. Bu püf noktaları uçak bileti sitemizden çok rahatlıkla öğrenebilirsiniz.

Creating a civilian capability to execute such a policy, side-by-side with the US military, is a mistaken enterprise, both expensive and unnecessary. Instead, the strengthening of our civilian institutions should be focused on the broader problems of development and governance, which are civilian issues demanding civilian-led solutions. The military should only play a secondary, not a leading role, in such efforts, and only when needed, invited, and welcomed.
sesli sohbet seslichat sesli sohbet seslichat

We know the good, we apprehend it clearly, but we can't bring it to achievement. To persevere, trusting in what hopes he has, is courage in a man.

Are you fighting in Final Fantasy XIV for FFXIV Gil or Final Fantasy XIV Gil?
Can you suffer yourself being called newbie in FFXIV Gil game?
Are you seeking unofficial Buy FFXIV Gil cheats or Final Fantasy XIV guides in order to make Final Fantasy XIV Gil faster?
Can you get millions of Cheap FFXIV Gil in one day?
Even if you know how to farm Buy Final Fantasy XIV Gil you have to prepare enough Final Fantasy XIV Power Leveling first to buy height class Final Fantasy XIV Items, to upgrade your Final Fantasy XIV characters.
Buy aika gold
Then why not Buy FFXIV Gil from us?
In Final Fantasy XIV it's the fastest way FF14 Gil,for you to get rich. We are online 24 hours a day ready and 7 days one week to power up your FFXIV Gil accounts with FFXIV Gil. Here is the best place for the Final Fantasy XIV Online players to buy your Final Fantasy XIV Gil.
We are the professional website in FFXIV GIL sale.FFXIV GIL here,We are professional FFXIV Power Leveling online. We update price every single day to make sure we are the lowest in the market.(we don't compare price with scam sites which uses unbelievable low price to deceive.)
Our slogan:Cheapest price, Fastest delivery, Best service!

Cheap aika gold
In the 2 years we are in this field , AIKA Goldbuilt many business with tens of thousands of customers. They are very satisfied with our service.So if you want to get a log of Cheap FFXIV Gil ,no doubt ,come to our website to buy. Our customer service is ready for you on line now!(GM MMO)

Christian Louboutin children of their parents' friends, next-door neighbors. Any playmate is better than no playmate Christian Louboutin Boots That's what Homewood, AL, mom Wendy Price Murch learned when her Christian Louboutin Pumps but you've always loved going to the play place Christian Louboutin Sandals Simple Strategies to Help Your Child Make FriendsChristian Louboutin Shoes Sale

Well.I like it, Its a really nice article I've saw :) , now, please allow me introduce a site made by my friend. you can click the link to view his site and find yours favourite

www.replicas-relojes.net



REPLICAS RELOJES

REPLICAS DE RELOJES ROLEX

IMITACIONES DE RELOJES SUIZOS LUJO


why the teas in my eyes,becuse i love it so deeply.

you did a very good point

Good starting point for a genuine discussion

Okay, this post is very interesting and I particularly agree with your opinion.

Thank you for this tip. You will become a true expert in this area

Glad I could make my contribution to the building

Thank you for having added the other fields of the form:)

I must say greatest tips and guidelines! Glad you are posting again!cheap nfl jerseys

Very good blog, I got a lot of things! If you need to watch, please click on my name, visit our website, where you need to be able to find watch and look forward to your visit! Thank you!

Moncler outlet Body

I'm terribly sorry laptop batteries The best way to make sure that we will feel and look fine is to develop healthy eating habits. Body Dont forget to buy me some ketchup on your way back. Whenever I have free time, I go to the laptop battery store I'm tired of working all day Okey. Thank you. Would you like anything else I always have a big wash to do on Saturdays. Moncler jackets Its near here. Is that so John is tied up at the present time.John Do you have any suggestions Jerseys I just couldn't help it. Wisdom appears in contradiction to itself, which is a trick life plays on philosophy of life. How about yourself However,most of the time people from the two countries do not have any difficulty in understanding each other. laptop batteries really heavy. I'd like a refund on this ticket. A good book is a good friend.

thanks for your post , and ytell us about that

It ugg boots clearance may be good news for the Democrats that many people didn’t seem to get the word about this big event, or even exactly which party is in charge. According to a Pew Research Center poll released last week ugg boots clearance, “Fewer than half (46%) know that the Republicans will have a majority only in the House of Representatives when the new Congress convenes in January, while 38% can identify John Boehner as the incoming House speaker.” Nancy Pelosi should just keep showing up every day as if nothing has changed, like Milton Waddams in Office Space ugg boots clearance. She can go cubicle to cubicle asking if anyone has her red stapler, and see how long it takes to get tossed out on her ear ugg boots clearance.

Then again ugg boots clearance, you can be sure that a lot of the fired-up Tea Partiers know exactly what they accomplished this election cycle. So some of the 54 percent who don’t understand must be Democrats who aren’t paying close attention ugg boots clearance, which is one of the reasons the party finds itself in this electoral mess. The paying-attention wing of the party is left to ponder what—to it—are seemingly contradictory thoughts among the voting public. According to a Rasmussen poll last week, slightly more than half of Americans (51 percent) say it is possible to achieve a balanced federal budget without raising taxes ugg boots outlet. But many Democrats believe raising taxes is an absolute necessity to balance the budget and dig out of the $1.4 trillion annual hole we’re in. An increasing number of Americans just don’t trust them to do it right, and with good reason. Most people think the government wastes money ugg boots outlet.

Al's Protection Racket operated out of Manhattan, Kansas. Despite the name, it was a small, insurance-oriented police service with about twenty thousand customers, all within one hundred kilometers of the main shop. But apparently "Al" was some kind of humorist: His ads had a gangster motif with his cops dressed like twentieth century hoodlums. Wil Brierson guessed that it was all part of the nostalgia thing. Even the Michigan State Police - Wil's outfit - capitalized on the public's feeling of trust for old names, old traditions.
Even so, there's something more dignified about a company with louis vuitton outlet a name like "Michigan State Police," thought Brierson as he brought his flier down on the pad next to Al's HQ. He stepped out of the cockpit into an eerie morning silence: It was close to sunrise, yet the sky remained dark, the air humid. Thunderheads march around half the horizon. A constant flicker of lightning chased back and forth within those clouds, yet there was not the faintest sound of thunder. He had seen a tornado killer on his way in, a lone eagle in the far sky. The weather was almost as ominous as the plea East Lansing HQ had received from Al's just four hours earlier.
A spindly figure came bouncing out of the shadows. "Am I glad to see you! The name's Alvin Swensen. I'm the proprietor." He shook Wil's hand enthusiastically. "I was afraid you might wait till the front passed though." Swensen was dressed ugg boots clearancein baggy pants and a padded jacket that would have made Frank Nitti proud. The local police chief urged the other officer up the steps. No one else was outside; the place seemed just as deserted as one might expect a rural police station early on a weekday morning. Where was the emergency?

Madame," quoth the myry mon, "Mary yow 3elde,
For I haf founden, in god fayth, yowre fraunchis nobele,
And other ful much of other folk fongen bi hor dede3,
Bot the daynte that thay delen, for my disert nys euen,
Hit is the worchyp of yourself, that no3t bot wel conne3."
"Bi Mary," quoth the menskful, "me thynk hit an other;
For were I worth al the wone of wymmen alyue,
And al the wele of the worlde were in my honde,
And I schulde chepen and chose to cheue me a lorde,
For the costes that I haf knowen vpon the, kny3t, here,
Of bewte and debonertщ ugg boots outlet

"I U S E D to like dogs," May said. "In fact, I had one once."
"Lincoln Tunnel coming up," Murch called to them.
"That's not all that's coming up," May said.
They'd been in this UGG Boots Clearance truck for nearly two hours, except for three pauses at rest stops along route 80, when they would all get out and do a lot of breathing. Dortmunder, whose stiffness wasn't being helped by sitting on a cage floor and leaning his back against a cage wall, would simply stand behind the truck during the rest stops, hanging there like an elm tree struck by the blight, but the others would all walk around, inhaling and limbering up.
"It'll be over soon," Kelp said, but not with his usual sparkle. He'd cut out the sparkle about an UGG Boots Clearance hour ago, when after one optimistic remark he'd made Dortmunder had given him a flat look and had started thumping his right fist into his left palm. Now, Kelp too seemed beaten by events, even if only temporarily.
Lincoln Tunnel. Murch paid Ugg boots clearance the toll, and they drove through, following a slow-moving, belching tractor-trailer bringing-if the back doors could be believed-pork fat to an anxious city.
Out the other side, Murch scooted the van around the tractor-trailer and headed up Dyer Avenue to Forty-second Street, where a red light stopped him. "Where to?" he called back.
"Out," Dortmunder said.
Kelp said, "Don't we have to let the kid off first?"
"That's right," Dortmunder said.
May called to Murch, "Stop at Eighth Avenue. He can take the subway there, up to Central Park West."
"Right."
Jimmy had been half dozing, sitting Ugg boots clearance on his Air France bag and leaning back against May's side. Now she jostled his shoulder, saying, "Here we are, Jimmy. New York."
"Mm?" The boy sat up, blinking. When he stretched, his bones cracked like tree limbs. "Boy, what a trip," he said.
Murch drove to Eighth Avenue and stopped. May gave the boy a token, and Kelp opened the rear door for him. Carrying his bag, he climbed awkwardly out onto the street. (In some places this might have caused comment, but at Eighth Avenue and Forty-second Street in New York City a twelve-year-old boy with Ugg boots clearance an Air France bag climbing out of the back of a veterinarian's truck at eight-thirty on a Friday morning was the closest thing to normality that had happened there in six years.)
"So long, Jimmy," May called, and waved to him.
"So long, everybody," Jimmy said, waving to them all through the open door of the truck. "Don't feel bad," he said, and turned away.
Kelp pulled the door shut, and Murch drove them on. "How much farther?" he asked.
"Turn down Seventh," Dortmunder said, "and park as soon as you can."
Kelp was frowning. He said, "Don't feel bad'? What did he mean, 'Don't feel bad'?"
May said, "I suppose because we're all separating now. We kind of got close there, after all, and he did warn us about the police."
Kelp continued to frown. "It doesn't feel right," he said.
Dortmunder looked at him. "What's up?"
"The kid said, 'Don't feel bad.' Why would he-?"
Kelp blinked. Dortmunder looked at him. The two of them swiveled their heads and looked at the suitcase May was sitting on. May said, "What's the mat-?" Then she too looked down at the suitcase. "Oh, no," she said.

The Perry-Hadley report continues this tradition. It certainly endorses a strengthened civilian national security architecture, but it calls for this, in the very first instance, in order to deploy civilians alongside the military. This is the "Iraq-Afghanistan" fallacy, which now permeates US strategic planning - all future wars will look like Iraq and Afghanistan.

It is important to be clear: in Iraq and Afghanistan the US intentionally invaded another country, in one case with a very large force, with the intent of taking down a regime. It then inherited the occupation of those countries, with minimal allied support, and found itself unready to be an occupying power
sohbet chat seslisohbet seslichat seslisohbet siteleri seslichat siteleri xat

Thanks for sharing your article. I really enjoyed it. I put a link to my site to here so other people can read it. My readers have about the same interets

Je lisais quelque chose d'autre à ce sujet sur un autre blog. Intéressant. Votre position sur elle est diamétralement contredit ce que j'ai lu plus t?t. Je suis encore contempler sur les points de vue opposés, mais je suis à bout fortement vers le v?tre. Et peu importe, c'est ce qui est si grande sur la démocratie moderne et le marché de la pensée en ligne.

Thanks for sharing your article. I really enjoyed it. I put a link to my site to here so other people can read it. My readers have about the same interets.

J'espère que vous garderez mettre à jour votre contenu sans cesse que vous avez un lecteur dédié ici.

Salut, où avez-vous obtenu cette information peut vous s'il vous pla?t appuyer ce avec une certaine preuve ou vous pouvez dire quelques bonnes références que moi et d'autres apprécieront vraiment. Cette information est vraiment bon et je vais dire sera toujours utile si nous essayer sans risques. Donc, si vous pouvez le sauvegarder. Cela nous aidera vraiment à tous. Et cela pourrait apporter un peu de bonne réputation pour vous.

Thanks for the post. This keeps me informed about the topic. By the way, if you have time, please give me a few seconds by visiting my website at.

I absolutely love your blog and find almost all of your post's to be just what I'm looking for. Do you offer guest writers to write content available for you?I wouldn't mind producing a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects you write in relation to here. Again, awesome website!

Thanks on your marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading it, you could be a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and will eventually come back in the future. I want to encourage continue your great writing, have a nice day!

Thanks for sharing your article. I really enjoyed it. I put a link to my site to here so other people can read it. My readers have about the same interets

your article is very useful.

I like very you article, it is so right....haha

Perhaps this is one of the most interesting blogs that I have ever seen. Interesting article, Funny comment. Keep it up!

The material and shape and fashion classic Gucci coat of metal badges in sharp contrast.

we can provide you with high quality Ugg Boots ,just take action now do not miss it!

Very happy to see your article, I very much to like and agree with your point of view. Thank you for sharing. At the same time,i love best pram very much .Welcome to look at my website and blog articles.Hope we can become good friends, and exchange and to help each other! Thanks!!

I’ve been reading about this topic for one week now for my papers in school and thank God

I found it here in your blog. I had a great time reading this.

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In.

Guest Contributors
Founder
Subscribe
Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Email: 
Powered by TypePad

Disclaimer

The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use