Democracy Arsenal

« Hamid Karzai . . . Our Diem | Main | A Conversation with US Ambassador to Iraq Christopher Hill, Cont. »

May 11, 2010

What's So Backward about 'Peace through Strength'
Posted by Patrick Barry

UncleSam Given that the modern GOP is totally bereft of ideas, it shouldn’t surprise anyone to see that the right has resorted to resuscitating old ones.  What is a touch surprising is that many of the old ideas being revived should be so terribly bad.  Take one of the latest recycled concepts gaining traction in conservative circles: Reagan’s foggy notion of an American foreign policy based on “peace through strength.” Frank Gaffney and Co. have an op-ed in the Washington Times ticking off their update to this Reagan-era principle. If you're like me, you'll probably find that it manages to be both repugnant and absurd. That said, the far right is far from alone in holding this perspective. Increasingly, it’s the mainstream of the conservative movement that is attempting to turn “peace through strength” into a credible foreign policy, as evidenced by Eric Cantor’s address at the Heritiage Foundation, where he mentioned the concept 5 times.

There are so many problems with this idea, it’s hard to know which to address.  While it’s obviously a recipe for unilateralism, and international isolation, for me, there are two, massive weaknesses, which rise above all the rest.  First is that it has no basis in reality.  The U.S. spends a huge amount of money on defense as it is.  Secretary Gates put this in stark terms over the weekend, when he spoke before an audience at the Eisenhower library:

For example, should we really be up in arms over a temporary projected shortfall of about 100 Navy and Marine strike fighters relative to the number of carrier wings, when America’s military possesses more than 3,200 tactical combat aircraft of all kinds? Does the number of warships we have and are building really put America at risk when the U.S. battle fleet is larger than the next 13 navies combined, 11 of which belong to allies and partners?  Is it a dire threat that by 2020 the United States will have only 20 times more advanced stealth fighters than China? (Emphasis added)

The U.S. advantage in defense so overwhelming that it’s hard to see the necessity behind expanding it in the fashion desired by conservatives.  Moreover, there’s a mounting consensus that all this spending hasn’t resulted in greater security at home, or ability to project influence abroad.  I’m curious to hear how the right would situate “peace through strength” in a context, which finds the U.S. military loudly arguing for shifting emphasis toward the diplomatic and development instruments of national power.

This brings me to my second point, which finds something much more troubling about the re-emergence of this “peace through strength” mentality: it misidentifies the origins of American power.  In his Heritage address, Cantor credits this so-called strategy for “usher[ing] in an unprecedented era of American prosperity.”  In Cantor’s estimation, America’s domestic prosperity owes itself to the expansion of military power.  This is wrong.  It’s also dangerous. 

It’s wrong because it identifies economic well-being as the result of military might, when most would agree that the causal link extends in the opposite direction.  While I think there’s definitely reciprocation between military, economic, and also political power, everybody from Secretary Gates to Fareed Zakaria, to President Eisenhower has recognized that our ability to counter threats abroad, rests heavily on an active and healthy economy and a political environment capable of sustaining that advantage and converting it to influence oversees.

But the right’s formulation isn’t just wrong.  It’s dangerous.  It’s dangerous because, military expansion, at the expense of a sound economic foundation, is a strategy not for the growth of power, but its erosion.  History has not been kind to countries that maintain a foreign policy of “peace through strength.”  By embracing this concept as a grand strategy, Cantor, Gaffney, and the rest risk fulfilling Eisenhower’s grim prophecy: “destroy[ing] from within what we are trying to defend from without.”

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c04d69e20133ed7a10cd970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What's So Backward about 'Peace through Strength':

Comments

When you have time for a laugh, take a break and CHECK THIS OUT!

www.baitandswitchtv.com
The games are hilarious... click on Federal Reserve Crap Shoot.. very funny stuff. Here are my favs:

“Dating a Bank,” “Shitty Shitty Bank Bank,” and “Superfrauds: The Injustice League”
http://www.baitandswitchtv.com/comedy2.html

“Stificil” erectile dysfunction commercial parody
http://www.baitandswitchtv.com/comedy1.html

“A Federal Reserve Crap$hoot” online game
http://www.baitandswitchtv.com/games1.html

Follow Bait and Switch TV:
www.twitter.com/baitandswitchtv
www.facebook.com (search “Bait and Switch TV”)

Work at Home, Work From Home, Here's The FASTEST, EASIEST And LAZIEST Way To Make Reliable Internet Income - With NO Experience, No Website And NO Product!"

No Matter What You've Heard...

You don't need ANY previous experience
You need almost ZERO money to start with
You don't need your own product
You don't need your own list
You don't even need a website!

http://www.work-at-home-career.org

Zhejiang Haoren Electric Vehicle Co., Ltd.is the top electirc Vehicle factory in China supply Electric motorcycle,Electric scooter,Electric bike with

http://www.electricscooterschina.com

Peace is a lie there is only passion. The average sailor spends anywhere from a few weeks to several months on the Reagan without setting foot on land. This one country, overwhelmed with unsolved domestic problems and corruption, oblivious to all of the death, destruction, and suffering it has caused, somehow believes that it and it alone knows what is best for every human being on the planet.

Compared with the similar products, PDF to XLS Converter with good reputation and personalized designe is more and more popular. With free PDF to XLS Converter, you can Convert PDF to XLS exactly. So you needn't to worry about the output quality.pdf to xls converter

It was a big week for LeBron James; he grabbed himself a second MVP trophy and the Cavs moved on to the next round of the Playoffs. We saw a bunch of LeBrons, like the MVP Air Max LeBron VII, an unreleased LeBron VII P.S., and another sneak peek at his eighth shoe. LeBron’s upcoming shoe wasn’t the only preview we got, as a sample of the Jordan Melo M7 made its way to the public. Speaking of being in public, even more notable celebrities like Justin Timberlake, Mick Jagger, C.C. Sabathia, and Nelly came out with some heat of their own, while the Sneaker Friends 2010 Event in the ATL really burned a hole in our eyes. We also received a ton of glimpses at upcoming releases, from more Air Attacks, 90’s Retros, and classic silhouettes for Fall 2010. We were also hit with a big-picture news story, as Nike took personal action against counterfeit sellers and later announced the plans for the company’s future during their 2015 Global ,welcome to http://www.wikishoes.com

M4V to WMV Converter is a three-in-one software which can be used as a video converter, audio converter, and DRM Remover. To pay for one software, you will get three functional tools.m4v to wmv converter
dv converter.blu ray to mkv.

Satellite TV For PC - Official Site, 9000 channels only $10. Award-winning software allows you to receive Satellite TV on

your PC


http://www.watchsatellitetvforpc.org

"Work at Home, Work From Home, Here's The FASTEST, EASIEST And LAZIEST Way To Make Reliable Internet Income - With NO

Experience, No Website And NO Product!"

No Matter What You've Heard...

You don't need ANY previous experience
You need almost ZERO money to start with
You don't need your own product
You don't need your own list
You don't even need a website!


http://www.work-at-home-career.org

Very informative and trustworthy blog. Please keep updating with great posts like this one. I have booked marked your site and am about to email it to a few friends of mine that I know would enjoy reading

The comments to this entry are closed.

Emeritus Contributors
Subscribe
Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Email: 
Powered by TypePad

Disclaimer

The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use