The Contradictions of Marjah - UPDATED Posted by Michael Cohen

So have you heard about this big Marine offensive in Marjah? Of course you have, because the US military and ISAF practically can't stop talking about it! 

Why you might ask is the military taking away any element of surprise in attacking a major Taliban stronghold; because we want to spare the lives of Afghan civilians.  In fact, according to smooth-talking Stanley McChrystal the element of surprise really isn't as important "as letting Marjah's estimated 80,000 residents know that an Afghan government is on its way to replace Taliban overlords and drug traffickers."

Of course, for this to work one needs an Afghan government to actually come in and replace the Taliban. But is seems worth remembering the last big Helmand offensive - a mere six months ago - and the words of the Afghan governor there:

“I don’t get any support from the government,” said the governor, Massoud Ahmad Rassouli Balouch. Governor Massoud has no body of advisers to help run the area, no doctors to provide health care, no teachers, no professionals to do much of anything. About all he says he does have are police officers who steal and a small group of Afghan soldiers who say they are here for “vacation.”

And here's what General McCrystal had to say less than six months ago in his 'secret' review:

The Afghan government has been unable to provide sufficient security, justice, and basic services to the people. Although the capacity and integrity of some Afghan institutions have improved and the number of competent officials has grown, this progress has been insufficient to counter the issues that undermine legitimacy.

. . . There is little connection between the central government and the local populations, particularly in rural areas. The top-down approach to developing government capacity has failed to provide services that reach local communities. GIRoA has not developed the means to collect revenue and distribute resources. Sub-national officials vary in competency and capability and most provincial and district governments are seriously undermanned and under-resourced.

What has changed in the past six months to make anyone believe that these issues won't be serious problems in Marjah and that the Afghan Army and government is able to support the "build" and "hold" elements of a counter-insurgency effort in Helmand Province?  This is contradiction #1. (Perhaps instead of wasting time with breathless reports of how the US military is doing in clearing Marjah reporters might want to come back in 6 months or a year or 18 months and see how the "hold" and "build" part is going.) 

Over at the Danger Room, Noah Schachtman isolates contradiction # 2. After weeks of telling residents to leave Marjah, the message from NATO headquarters is now "Please, please, pretty please don't leave the warzone." Hmm. I would note a further contradiction (#3); we're telling the residents of Marjah that the US has come to bring security and stability at the same time that we are telling them to get the hell out of Dodge. I wonder if the Afghan citizens of Marjah are perhaps getting a mixed message. As Josh Foust notes, "it doesn't seem the Coalition cares much about how its activities hurt and terrify the Afghans. Only the Taliban's intimidation matters. That doesn't strike me as a very sustainable way of designing operations." Clearly Josh is confused here; when America intimidates it's for the greater good.

But for all the talk about civilian casualties; what about the Taliban? Here we have contradiction #4. The Taliban appear to have adopted a military strategy that - wisely - avoids, at all costs, direct combat operations with American troops and focuses instead on ambushes, IED attacks etc. Yet here we have a military operation that plays directly into the Taliban's hands; gives them fair warning to avoid engaging with US troops and provides them ample opportunity to lay tons of IEDS and set ambushes against US troops.

Of course, overarching this entire offensive is contradiction #5; waging a major military offensive without sufficient support from the Afghan government in a densely populated province directly contradicts the President's guidance that no troops should be sent into places that cannot potentially be handed over to the Afghan security services by June 2011.

UPDATE: Over at the Af/Pak Channel, Norine MacDonald makes another smart point about the strategic incoherence of the Marjah operation

Although the political decision to provide advance warning of Operation Moshtarak has allowed civilians to leave the conflict zone, steps to resettle these people temporarily are nonexistent. Thousands of Afghans are fleeing to Lashkar Gah and the ungoverned refugee camp outside it. This camp does not have sufficient food, medical supplies, or accommodations for the families who have already fled there -- a shocking state of affairs which has persisted since March 2006 -- and is already far beyond any original holding capacity, full of unemployed and angry men unable to provide for their families. Creating a situation which will lead to thousands more to take refuge at this camp is not only disastrous from a humanitarian point of view; it is a very poorly conceived plan from a counter-insurgency viewpoint.

How a mission oriented around convincing Afghans that ISAF and their government will guarantee security  - and has pushed Afghans to leave Marjah before escalation - could ignore the issue of temporary refugee resettlement is truly beyond me. 

Comments

[r4 sdhc]

Hi,
Success in Marjah, however, will not be judged on who wins the battle. Late in the day, military commanders have accepted that the solution to the eight-year war will be political, not military....

[pallet racking]

shelving
pallet racking
refrigeration equipment

[rado watches]

If you have PANERAI Watches , I still have my idea to achieve.

[bvlgari watches]

I am so with you FRANCK MULLER Watch

[sesli sohbet]

Thank You Editors..sesli sohbet sesli chat

[ray ban 2010 sunglasses]

Yellow lens of Ray ban wayfarer can 100% filter UV, allowing infrared and 83% visible light through the lens.

Its greatest feature is that you can filter the sun's most dazzling blue.

Sunlight through the atmosphere, the most performance is the blue light, which is why you see the sky is blue. Yellow lens filters blue light, the natural scenery can be seen more clearly. So driving with a yellow lens Ray ban 2010 sunglasses, you can more clearly see from the vehicle.

Ray ban sunglasses sale

ray ban 2010 sunglasses sale

ray ban sunglasses sale

ray ban wayfarer message from http://www.eyewear-rayban.com

[stianless steel rings]

We don't take the luxury route, just playing crazy exaggeration and assertive personality. In addition we break the traditional and innovative stainless steel bracelet, stainless steel rings and so on. Our stainless steel jewelry has great stage effects. The color, texture and design are very fashion. The breakthrough in molding achieves the strong sense of art stainless steel jewelry. It experiences a foreign land and customs, tracking the trend of the international fashion accessories. Our company welcomes the large stainless steel jewelry wholesalers to e-mail consultation.
E-mail: sus360@hotmail.com
website: http://www.sus360.com

[huo638671]

In a woman’s dress, the jewelry is unique; there is only one role— let a woman be more elegant, attractive and beautiful. But, one thing I can make a sure: An elegant woman, even if links of londonshe loved jewelry, but also must not be too obsessed with this, so that confused his whole body from top links of london sale to bottom are hanging ornaments, like a Christmas tree.

[sesli sohbet]

Very informative and trustworthy blog. Please keep updating with great posts like this one. I have booked marked your site and am about to email it to a few friends of mine that I know would enjoy reading

[Kralseks]

Normal activities are not enough. I can run 1/2 of a short block, slowly. I am 55 now and bike everywhere.

[TENGA]

It became reference very much though I was researching the situation of Afghanistan. Thank you. 赤帽 名古屋

[TıkLa-SohbeT]

seslisohbet siteleri arasında ekol bir adres sestonum hemen sohbette başlamak icin sestonum 'tıklayınız..! seslisohbet ve seslichat adreslerinin gözdesi hemen tıklayarak seslisohbet yapmaya başlaya bilirsiniz..!

sestonum
seslichat
seslisohbet

[ホームページ作成]

It became reference very much though I was researching the situation of Afghanistan. プライバシーマーク

[QodesQoM]

Türkiyenin ilk Hiphop Sitesi için tıkla -> Hiphop <-
Gekko G Fan Sitesi için tıkla -> Gekko G <-
Mask Animasyon sitesi için tıkla -> Mask animasyon <-

[เครื่องสำอาง]

Thank you guys !!!!! just a quick suggestion, Please enhance the speed of your web pages. Thanks! リサイクルトナー

[焼酎 日本酒の通販]

thanks! nice comments バックリンク

[焼酎 日本酒の通販]

They can learn to give more freedom to express opinions next time. Then people will be happier to participate.リサイクルトナー ＆ リサイクルトナー通販

[FFXIV GIL]

Are you fighting in Final Fantasy XIV for FFXIV Gil or Final Fantasy XIV Gil?
Can you suffer yourself being called newbie in FFXIV Gil game?
Are you seeking unofficial Buy FFXIV Gil cheats or Final Fantasy XIV guides in order to make Final Fantasy XIV Gil faster?
Can you get millions of Cheap FFXIV Gil in one day?
Even if you know how to farm Buy Final Fantasy XIV Gil you have to prepare enough Final Fantasy XIV Power Leveling first to buy height class Final Fantasy XIV Items, to upgrade your Final Fantasy XIV characters.
Buy aika gold
Then why not Buy FFXIV Gil from us?
In Final Fantasy XIV it's the fastest way FF14 Gil,for you to get rich. We are online 24 hours a day ready and 7 days one week to power up your FFXIV Gil accounts with FFXIV Gil. Here is the best place for the Final Fantasy XIV Online players to buy your Final Fantasy XIV Gil.
We are the professional website in FFXIV GIL sale.FFXIV GIL here,We are professional FFXIV Power Leveling online. We update price every single day to make sure we are the lowest in the market.(we don't compare price with scam sites which uses unbelievable low price to deceive.)
Our slogan:Cheapest price, Fastest delivery, Best service!

Cheap aika gold
In the 2 years we are in this field , AIKA Goldbuilt many business with tens of thousands of customers. They are very satisfied with our service.So if you want to get a log of Cheap FFXIV Gil ,no doubt ,come to our website to buy. Our customer service is ready for you on line now!(GM MMO)

[video seyret]

indir
Grafiker
Mimar
Alışveris SitesiThey can learn to give more freedom to express opinions next time. Then people will be happier to participate.リ
video izle
tv izle
video ara

[designer handbags on sale]

. Then people will be happier to participate

[designer handbags]

Just want to say what a great blog you got here!I've been around for quite a lot of time, but finally decided to show my appreciation of your work!

[white iphone 4]

Come and make a change for your lovely iphone 4 white!

[Sohbet Arkadaslik]

the nice contradixtion post..

[Cure a Hemorrhoid]

i have been surfing about your website and it looks fairly superb.

[ผลบอล]

Me and my friend were arguing about an issue similar to this! Now I know that I was right. lol! Thanks for the information you post. ผลบอล ผลบอล ผลบอล

[ibcbet]

Thanks for this looks like a great article. I like your blog. ibcbet sbobet แทงบอล

[lion]

It became study very much. Thank you. Everything is very open and very clear explanation of issues. การทำ seo seo thailand seo

[radyosec]

Hi,
First of all I can say LOVE that site. Your site's content is informative and I like the image can be sure that you're gone. I think many people have access to this site easily. If I give an example of myself, Google radyosec and canlı radyo dinle When you write you can easily access. Wish you continued success. Thank you.

[essay writing service]

Cool! Author the best! Thank you!

[冷夜]

e luxury route, just playing crazy exaggeration and assertive perso

[knockoff handbags]

i am glad to study your opinion. m41414 Keepall 55, m41416 Keepall 50, m41522 Speedy 40, m41528 Speedy 25, 219704, m40249 artsy mm, m40259 artsy gm, M45257 Messenger Bag, M40156 Neverfull MM, m40144 Tivoli GM

[Lynn Patik]

I'm just impressed from the way you discussed this subject. It is not regularly I

[seks shop]

Now I know that I was right. lol! Thanks for the information you post.

[Oakley Sunglasses]

These are wonderful! Thank you for sharing

[SBOBET]

These are wonderful! Thank you for sharing.

SBOBET

[Rory Faye]

Simply, there may possibly be no analysis of torture and anyone's part inside it aside from looking in to the phony apple of 2002 using the boost toward war

[Cheap Football jerseys]

Hope you like my quick comment though. I am looking forward to see your upcoming post. Keep it up!

[Rodrick Mcmickell]

But when the briefing is simply a come up with a difference of sitting easily and hearing having a brief lecture with out a Q&A followup...

[Milford Trentinella]

We just couldnt leave your website prior to saying that we genuinely enjoyed the useful data you provide to your visitors Are going to be back soon to check up on new stuff you post!

[new era hats]

Good work! Thanks for these kinds of interesting article as I have been able to find here. I agree with most of whats written right here.

[โหลดเกม PSP]

Thank you for good article , information I think great blog and good content I'll follow this site you everyday. 7M Livescore โหลดเกม PSP แจกเกมส์ PSP เกมส์ PSP โหลด Hope to see more article. Please write more and more about this. ผลบอล