Democracy Arsenal

« Obama on jus in bello and jus ad bellum | Main | Why Afghan Women Matter »

December 10, 2009

It’s Time for Mitchell 2.0 and the American Plan
Posted by Joel Rubin

With much fanfare, Israeli Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu has unilaterally declared that Israel will temporarily freeze Israeli settlement construction in the West Bank, but notably, not in East Jerusalem, for 10 months.  This gesture reminds me of the temporary truces that groups like Hamas make when they unilaterally declare that they’ll do the right thing, such as enacting a truce, but only for a limited time.

Netanyahu’s gesture was probably the final Israeli response this year to American efforts, led by Special Envoy George Mitchell, to bring about a true settlement freeze in order to advance President Obama’s goal of restarting peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians.  Let’s call this Mitchell version 1.0.  Unfortunately, this effort has run its course without achieving the goal of restarting peace talks, let alone achieving peace.

So where do President Obama, Secretary Clinton, and Mitchell go from here?

This is a moment of deep reflection for advocates of the peace process.  The Obama administration has pressed Netanyahu hard.  He has bent slightly.  The Obama administration has pressed the Palestinians and the Arab states as well.  They have tamped down on violence and incitement and uttered nice words, but have not taken the plunge that Obama has asked for.

So now it’s time for the Mitchell team to get creative.  Interestingly, one attempt to test the creative waters may have recently been offered by Secretary Clinton.  On November 25th, included within her otherwise unremarkable response to Netanyahu’s settlements announcement, Clinton said that she supported “… an independent and viable (Palestinian) state based on the 1967 lines, with agreed swaps..."

This subtle, yet public American pronouncement that there should be land swaps in order to create a two state solution was a new twist and should not be overlooked.

More interestingly, the response to this Clinton trial balloon – silence by the parties – should raise eyebrows.  Clinton had gone further publicly than any other American official has gone in defining what a solution should begin to look like, and there was no significant negative fallout.

This should give the administration the confidence to turn it up a notch.  It’s now time for Mitchell version 2.0.

Mitchell 2.0 should be based upon the premise that, as Israeli and Palestinian leaders have often proclaimed, it is in both Israel’s interest to see a peaceful end to the conflict that leads to internationally recognized and secure borders for the Jewish state, and in the Palestinians’ interest to have their own internationally-recognized state.  Mitchell 2.0 should also be grounded in the idea that it is in America’s national security interest to improve our relationship with both the Arab and Muslim worlds.

Mitchell 2.0 must therefore be built upon the successes of Mitchell 1.0, which effectively demonstrated to all the parties that the United States is serious about ending the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and that it will engage in this process in a sustained manner.

At its core, Mitchell 2.0 should be about changing American tactics in order to create new movement in the peace process.

What Mitchell 1.0 made clear was that despite the fact that all of the parties talk about ending the conflict, they need a different American approach to effectively negotiate a deal.  While Mitchell 1.0 was effective at changing the political dynamics regarding the conflict, it needs to go further.

Mitchell 2.0 should therefore be about putting an American peace plan on the table in order to resolve the conflict. 

This is where Clinton’s trial balloon about “land swaps” comes in.  Her language was taken from the “Clinton Parameters” that developed during the late 2000 negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians under American auspices.  These parameters called for a two state solution that, amongst multiple issues, called for land swaps between Israel and Palestine so that roughly 95% of the equivalent territory of the West Bank (plus Gaza), including the swapped land, would become Palestine.

Revolutionary at the time, these parameters are now generally accepted both by experts and by multiple Israeli and Palestinian leaders as the way to achieve a two state solution to the conflict. 

It is now time for clarity about the endgame.  If this is where Clinton is heading, by putting an American plan on the table that lays out the parameters for a two state solution, then Mitchell will be empowered to advocate for what has largely been understood as the most realistic and practical solution for many years. 

Our country’s relationship with the Arab world needs to turn a new page, and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict stands out as unfinished business that must be resolved. 
It is therefore time to unleash Mitchell version 2.0 to achieve this goal.  It is time for the American plan.

This column was originally published in the Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle here.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference It’s Time for Mitchell 2.0 and the American Plan:


And if, in addition, Israel agrees that Palestinians have a "right of return," gives up all claims to Jerusalem, and renounces its status as a Jewish state, maybe some of the Palestinians and other Arab states will consider making "peace."

I would say There is no Mitchell 2.0. With Obama caving, and then using his Nobel speech to claim that the Israelis are exempt from International Law no Arab government should ever trust him again.The speech at Cairo was a lie used to lull the Arabs into a position of trust, which was then immediately broken....

Genial como siempre me gusto especialmente el ultimo punto, si tuviera tinta estaría probando ahora mismo...
Welcome to the discount ugg boots web site.--ugg boots uk

I really appreciate the kind of topics you post here. Thanks for sharing us a great information that is actually helpful. Good day!

Thanks u admins. good msj racking shelving cold store equipment

as a whole contractor for refrigeration equipment, design, manufacturing, installation.

professional racking & shelving manufacturer, pallet racking, drive in racking,
cantilever racking, longspan shelving, dexion racking,

Thank you for your article.
Looking For discount louis vuitton handbags?
The store online sells the louis vuitton bags.
Welcome to visit and buy lv handbags.

Thank you for your sharing.! seslichat seslisohbet

Manufacture Hydraulic Tools, offer from hydraulic crimping tool, cable cutter, pipe bender, gear puller, hole digger and hand pumps.

Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!

The comments to this entry are closed.

Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Powered by TypePad


The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use