McChrystal is NOT Shinseki Posted by Michael Cohen

I have a great deal of respect for Bill Galston, but I'm a bit befuddled by his comments yesterday in the New Republic about General Stanley McChrystal's recent public announcements on Afghanistan policy. Even in the face of public rebukes from National Security Advisor Jim Jones and Secretary of Defense Bill Gates, Galston seems to think that progressives are acting hypocritically here:

Jones suggested that military advice should "come up through the chain of command," while Gates chastised that it is "imperative" that military and civilian leaders "provide our best advice to the president candidly but privately." How quickly we forget: That was the rationale used to muzzle General Eric Shinseki during the run up to the Iraq war.

This is just a deeply misleading analogy. Let's review the history for a second. General McChrystal not only had his strategic review leaked to the Washington Post, but he has appeared on 60 Minutes in recent days and even went to London to plead the case for population centric counter-insurgency in Afghanistan. In other words, McChrystal voiced his candid views in public instead of in private up the chain of command. Eric Shinseki did nothing of the sort. In 2003, he was Army Chief of Staff and when he publicly contradicted the Bush Administration's rosy view of the post-war occupation of Iraq he wasn't being interviewed on television - he was testifying under oath to Congress. As Shinseki's spokesperson correctly pointed out at the time, "He was asked a question and he responded with his best military judgment." We should expect nothing less. It's simply incorrect for Galston to say that the arguments being used to hush up General McChrystal today are the same ones that were used to muzzle Shinseki in 2003.

But Galston makes an even more dubious argument:

Wouldn’t we have been better off to have had a no-holds-barred debate involving senior military officials prior to the invasion about the number of troops it would take to stabilize Iraq after the invasion? Wouldn’t we have had the kind of public discussion that the American people deserved but did not get?

No it wouldn't. What would have been better is if the country had that no-holds barred debate in Congress (you know, the branch of government charged in the Constitution with declaring war). Certainly that debate should have been informed by the views not only of the military but also of civilian policy-makers. Clearly that didn't happen in the run-up to the Iraq war. But does Bill Galston really want members of a deeply hierarchical organization like the US military having a no-holds barred public debate on matters of war and peace? This is a recipe for civil-military disaster and I can't believe that Galston doesn't see the downside of such a public usurpation of authority by an institution that is supposed to be subservient to the executive and legislative branches.

Yet Galston doubles down on this argument:

Does McChrystal’s speech put pressure on the president, as some have charged? Sure, and what’s wrong with that? The general is saying that the mission the president articulated back in March after a thorough policy review requires more troops than are now on the ground in Afghanistan. If he’s right about that, the president owes the country one of two things: send the troops or redefine the mission. McChrystal’s intervention makes it more difficult to fudge the decision. In my book, that’s a good thing.

Why can't the general make that case to the President in private - and if Obama decides to redefine the mission or send more troops shouldn't the pressure to explain that decision come not from a general, but from Congress? I'm sort of baffled by this entire argument. Galston wants a public debate about troop levels in Afghanistan. No disagreement there. But the notion that it should be instigated by the military as opposed to elected, accountable officials that serve in a co-equal branch of government just seems bizarre. And frankly I'm less bothered than many on the left about the idea of General McChrystal testifying before Congress. My gut tells me this should wait until after the President has made his strategic assessment, but if Congress wants to hear from the country's military commander in Afghanistan it doesn't strike me as unreasonable.

Finally, Galston's argument seems to ignore the political environment in which decisions about troop levels are being made. Surely Galston is a smart enough observer of American politics to understand that McChrystal's "pressure" does not occur in a political vacuum. Instead it can and will be used by the Republican party to put political pressure on Obama.

Let's look again at the comments last week by Karl Rove, ""Refusing to provide all the troops and strategic support that his commanders are requesting will be to concede defeat."  This is precisely the problem with having generals express their views in the midst of a strategic review by the White House - particularly when you have an opposition party in which people like Karl Rove are held in high esteem. It unnecessarily politicizes the debate. Now General McChrystal may not be overly concerned about the impact of his words on the country's political discussions, but the rest of us should be - and it's a good reason why Bill Galston is just plain wrong on this one.

Comments

[Bernard Finel]

Plus, look Shinseki was talking about resourcing, not strategy. He didn't say invading Iraq was a bad idea. He didn't claim we could live with a contained Saddam. He merely answered a question about how to resource the strategy.

It is just apples and oranges to compare the two.

Fact is, most of McChrystal's defenders are demonstrating an embarrassing lack of knowledge of facts and norms of civil-military relations.

[Constant Gina]

Damn, at least he is not adding troops

[replica watches]

most of McChrystal's defenders are demonstrating an embarrassing lack of knowledge of facts and norms of civil-military relations.

[rolex oyster perpetual]

If you are looking for a watch to buy,rolex perpetual come to solve the problem of the not-so-rich category of people. A rolex oyster perpetual can be purchased by many of us, due to the accessible price it can have. A rolex oyster perpetual date will always cost only a few hundred dollars.

[muhtar]

Thank you for your sharing.! seslichat seslisohbet

[cheap coach handbags]

Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!

[cheap coach bags]

Great comments! You are so nice, man! You never know how much i like'em!

[cheap coach purses]

Yes, that's cool. The device is amazing! Waiting for your next one!

[cheap r4i software]

Hi,
Moreover, Fox News personalities repeatedly criticized President Obama for having not yet acted on McChrystal's advice but almost entirely avoided criticizing the Bush administration for not heeding Shinseki's 2003 recommendation.

[dfdg]

Support of the Lou Zhu, Lou Zhu worked hard
Signature--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nothing is impossible for a willing heart.
funny games

[rado watches]

If you have PANERAI Watches , I still have my idea to achieve.

[ghd]

We guarantee we provide the cheapest ghd , ghd Hair Straighteners , ghd straighteners in the market and 100% Quality Guarantee.

[watches sale]

watches sale you luxury and fashion men watches and women watches with first-class quality. Enjoy shopping with watches ladies at competitive prices!

[iwc portuguese watch]

Welcome to our website,and you will enjoy the sunshine service. Let's abandon all the worry,and enjoy the happy shopping travel.All the iwc watches andiwc portuguese watch are most in fashion boutique this year.rolex replica and iwc watch and the iwc swiss watches show your chaming temperament. In addtin, the vintage iwc watches and the other iwc replica watches make you mold your unique glamour this winter.The swiss iwc portuguese watch have the high quality but low price. iwc watch and replica rolex have all the style and cheapest price iwc swiss watches. Enjoying the fun of net purchase! iwc replica watchesWe will supply you the perfect service and after sale support system. Our honest will bring you absolute satisfaction.

[k247br]

Known as replica chanel replica chanel
Los Angeles' "Ambassador of replica gucci replica gucci
Boogie Funk," Dãm-Funk represents the citizens of the Funkmosphere. Headquartered in replica hermes replica hermes
the Leimert Park section of L.A., Dãm (pronounced: dame) has been dedicated over the last few years to cultivating a musical renaissance replica louis vuitton replica louis vuitton
rooted in the early-'80s styles known discount handbags discount handbags
as Boogie, Modern designer handbags designer handbags
Soul and Electro-Funk. www.myspace.com/damfunk

[FFXIV Gil]

Are you fighting in Final Fantasy XIV for FFXIV Gil or Final Fantasy XIV Gil?
Can you suffer yourself being called newbie in FFXIV Gil game?
Are you seeking unofficial Buy FFXIV Gil cheats or Final Fantasy XIV guides in order to make Final Fantasy XIV Gil faster?
Can you get millions of Cheap FFXIV Gil in one day?
Even if you know how to farm Buy Final Fantasy XIV Gil you have to prepare enough Final Fantasy XIV Power Leveling first to buy height class Final Fantasy XIV Items, to upgrade your Final Fantasy XIV characters.
Buy aika gold
Then why not Buy FFXIV Gil from us?
In Final Fantasy XIV it's the fastest way FF14 Gil,for you to get rich. We are online 24 hours a day ready and 7 days one week to power up your FFXIV Gil accounts with FFXIV Gil. Here is the best place for the Final Fantasy XIV Online players to buy your Final Fantasy XIV Gil.
We are the professional website in FFXIV GIL sale.FFXIV GIL here,We are professional FFXIV Power Leveling online. We update price every single day to make sure we are the lowest in the market.(we don't compare price with scam sites which uses unbelievable low price to deceive.)
Our slogan:Cheapest price, Fastest delivery, Best service!

Cheap aika gold
In the 2 years we are in this field , AIKA Goldbuilt many business with tens of thousands of customers. They are very satisfied with our service.So if you want to get a log of Cheap FFXIV Gil ,no doubt ,come to our website to buy. Our customer service is ready for you on line now!(GM MMO)

[Supra Skytop II]

Each doughnut loop (a "handle") has a length and a circumference, resulting in a huge assortment of possible geometries for the small dimensions.

[glass tiles]

Basically there is no solution!

[seo-vancouver]

Clearly that didn't happen in the run-up to the Iraq war.He is not Shinseki .

[jogos da polly pocket]

thanks,..What U saying is completely true.

regards,
jogos da polly pocket

[jumpman23 sneakers]

Thanks for the introduction! I am always reading your blog and only today I have

spotted the post with introduction! I am one hundred percent sure that Jodi is cool

as other members are.

[ralph lauren shirt]

But this time does appear to be different as the Obama Administration is making clear that "they will consider the Afghan government's commitment to reform in deciding how many more troops to send to fight the resurgent Taliban." But this isn't really true since the US is on the verge of agreeing to send more troops to Afghanistan so in fact we're not really waiting for genuine progress.

discount ralph lauren clothing
Shouldn't the cart come before the horse here? Shouldn't we wait for the Afghan government to get serious about dealing with corruption as well as a host of other issues before agreeing to send a single additional soldier? I mean,
ralph lauren online shoppingit's not as if 60,000 US troops can't effectively hold off the Taliban in the meantime - and it's not as if the US will even have an additional 30-40,000 troops on the ground any time soon to make much of a difference in the counter-insurgency
lauren by ralph lauren fight.

[Ayna]

thanks for sharing ayna many people are pay more attention to one's wearing than before

[ayna]

thanks for sharing ayna many people are pay more attention to one's wearing than before

[ralph lauren polo shirts]

look Shinseki was talking about resourcing, not strategy. He didn't say invading Iraq was a bad idea. He didn't claim we could live with a contained Saddam. He merely answered a question about how to resource the strategy.

[nồi hơi]

This piece really did turn the light on for me as far as this specific issue goes. Nevertheless there is actually just one issue I am not too comfy with and while I make an effort to reconcile that with the actual main idea of your point, permit me see what the rest of your visitors have to say.Very well done.

[lacoste outlet]

But this isn't really true since the US is on the verge of agreeing to send more troops to Afghanistan

[gucci shoe sale]

We have several system in education that you can choose. You can get a formal education at school or you can get a home schooling. This is mean you dont have to go to school you just learn from your house and there will be a special teacher for you.

[china electronics]

several system in education that you can choose. You can get a formal education at school or you can get a home schooling. This is mean you dont have to go to school you just learn from your house and there will be a special teacher for you.

[knockoff handbags]

i am glad to study your opinion. m41414 Keepall 55, m41416 Keepall 50, m41522 Speedy 40, m41528 Speedy 25, birkin 35cm, m40249 artsy mm, m40259 artsy gm, M45257 Messenger Bag, M40156 Neverfull MM, m40144 Tivoli GM

[Global Online Shopping]

thanks for sharing

[Wholesale]

thanks your share!

[ladies John Galliano jewelry]

Very thank the authors share such a good article, hope the author continue to work hard, published more interesting to share with everyone

[Cheap Propecia]

Hello Great informative article! Thanks so much for sharing your wealth of information. I certainly appreciate the effort! keep up the good work!

[Generic Cialis]

Hola,Ha hecho un trabajo muy bueno. Hay muchas personas en busca de eso ahora van a encontrar suficientes fuentes por tus consejos.espera para obtener más consejos acerca de que

[yiwu tires]

I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often

[Free Shipping]

"Now tell me how to get out of here" I asked"Come on ,the answer Gaming Playersis in front of you." he replied"What? are you kidding me? it's just a wall, or Home Audio & Video Equipments you mean that we need to scramble over it." I asked with a little anger"Yes, that 's it." he grined at me"it's impossible, i've never Media

[wedding dress]

You will fall in love with the black and white cocktail dress.

Nothing is quite as classy than black and white cocktail dress.

[Jordans for Cheap]

I really do not truly have much to say in response, I only wanted to comment to reply great work.

[ザイロリック]

Great tips, I would like to join your blog anyway,

[live cricket streaming]

Shouldn't the cart come before the horse here? Shouldn't we wait for the Afghan government to get serious about dealing with corruption as well as a host of other issues before agreeing to send a single additional soldier? I mean,

[magic bullet]

Moreover, Fox News personalities repeatedly criticized President Obama for having not yet acted on McChrystal's advice but almost entirely avoided criticizing the Bush administration for not heeding Shinseki's 2003 recommendation.

[Buy clomid online]

After reading the article, learned a lot of new and interesting. I advise everyone reading.

[cheap Gucci shoes]

The cheap tory burch shoescheap, known for its timeless design and perfect fit, comes in fine material. They look so luxurious and beautiful. Tory Burch is always a footwear brand that made for the ultra-feminine fashionista. Many Hollywood stars are fans of tory burch. If you want to keep the trend, you should not miss the cheap Tory Burchdiscount tory burch.

[replica jewelry]

Nice hosting! It’s my first time to read like this article.

[belstaff]

Nice hosting! It’s my first time to read like this article.

[olympic london accommodations]

Amazing article. Seems that you have experience in this sphere and your writing quality is on high-level. I am pleased to continue reading your blog posts. Keep up the good work.

[Polo Ralph Lauren]

The general words very reasonable, the President also should consider the general idea.

[Kaftan]

Off course, i am very glad to have your post here. Which is very awesome information and i want to say that its worth, thanks for kaftan sharing......