Democracy Arsenal

« Stolen Art and International Relations | Main | Three Cheers for Executive Authority »

March 02, 2009

About Those 50,000
Posted by Ilan Goldenberg

There has been some concern expressed in Congress about the size of the residual forces in Obama's Iraq plan.  I think it's important to put this in perspective.  First, as Gates emphasized yesterday on Meet the Press, the 35,000-50,000 is really a way station to zero by the end of 2011.  Second, it is very much in line with Obama's own promises during the campaign to remove combat forces and leave behind a residual or "transition" force to do training, counterterrorism and civilian protection. 

But there is a bigger question here.  It's healthy for Congress to disagree with the President, hold him accountable, and ask the tough questions.  But rather then simply stating that the number sounds high, I would have preferred to see a set of thoughtful questions about the plan and the residual forces.  A.  Does the military, and particularly the Joint Chiefs, believe that drawing down to that number balances our risks in Iraq with those in the rest of the world, and allow us to plan for other contingencies?  B.  Does it sufficiently reduce the strain on the force and allow us to reset?  C.  What does the new mission and force size mean in terms of American casualties and financial costs going forward? 

The concerns over the size of the residual force should be tied to troop tasking and strategic interests instead of offhanded comments that it "sounds too big."  Based the folks I've talked to, I feel pretty comfortable with the plan and the "transition force" sizing.  But there is nothing wrong with a healthy debate on this point.  Let's just make it a thoughtful debate


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference About Those 50,000:


The Rafik Hariri Assassination, Authorized by the United States and
Carried Out by Israeli Mossad, was a Provocation Aimed at Syria!
Yasser Arafat Was Also Assassinated by U.S/”Israel and France!
U.S./“Israel” Continues Its Failed Policy of Provocation by Assassination
By Sacrificing one of their Fascist Chistian Phalangists, Pierre Gemayal
In Vain to try to Prop Up Their Puppet Lebanese Government!

The U.S.-Israeli Mossad Axis literally bombed out (assassinated) Rafik Hariri with a gigantic bomb and blamed it on Syria, who had no motive for such a crime! The Syrians incidentally have no special history of assassination in the Mideast or anywhere, while the Israeli IDF uses assassination as one of its most frequent weapons of choice and is the most experienced in the entire Mideast in assassination! Since the Hariri “Blow-Up” the U.S. has authorized a veritable stream of assassinations in Lebanon carried out by the “Israeli” Mossad in order to inflame anti-Syrian opinion, which has no motive to assassinate anyone! Previously the United States’ authorized Israeli agents to also assassinate Arafat! Nothing happens in Israel policy wise without U.S. authorization, although isolated Zionist crimes do occur from time to time. The dog wags the tail—not the other way around, despite lies to the contrary which anti-Semitic (rarely anti-Zionist) conspiracy theorists try to push. Israeli is not actually a conventional state, it is an entity (the Zionist Entity), a U.S. puppet/proxy state because it is completely dependent militarily, economically, politically and diplomatically on the United States for its existence. It is the cat’s paw of U.S. imperialism in the Mideast! For example, in order to keep Israel out of the 1991 U.S. Invasion of Iraq the Bush Regime threatened to cut off $6 billion in credits to Israel to keep the fanatic Zionists in line. The U.S. authorized the Israelis, with the helpful assistance of its proxy agents of Fatah—Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) & Co., to initially administer Arafat poison in Ramallah, giving him an isolated case of thrombocytopenia (low platelets) with no other symptoms, symptoms which could only occur by poisoning, as his doctors in Ramallah, and individual doctors in Paris who had examined Arafat, so testified! (See New York Times!) The French provided timely assistance first by immediately sedating Arafat and apparently starving him to help weaken him so that when he arrived in Paris he could not speak or know what was happening to him. French “intelligence,” which has historically always worked closely with Israel and Mossad in many assassinations carried out by Mossad in Paris of PLO militants in the 1980’s, and, of course, with the United States (except in Iraq!), indubitably administered the final overdose of anti-coagulant or other poison in order to induce the stroke, which was the reported immediate cause of death. To cover up their dirty work the French also gave Arafat a platelet transfusion when he arrive in Paris, totally useless in the presence of another administration of poison. In order to muzzle those physicians in the French hospital who had stated that it looked like Arafat had been poisoned, when Arafat finally died on November 11, 2004, the French stated “there would be no details about the cause of death because of French privacy laws (!)” Arafat used to be their boy but was sacrificed primarily because he had largely lost the support of his militant constituency and the capitalists wanted to install new “leadership” personnel, which has turned out to be a total failure for them once again. The irony is that during the 1980’s several assassinations of highly militant PLO figures were carried out by Mossad in the close proximity of Arafat, sometimes in Arafat’s own house in Tunis, always leaving him untouched. This time the capitalists sacrificed him.

Yassar Arafat Did Not Die of AIDS!
Yassar ArafatWas Assassinated by the U.S.-Authorized
Proxy State of So-called “Israel” and France!

The idea to try to discredit Yassar Arafat as a homosexual originated with David Frum of the National Review, who first coined the Bush regime phrase “axis of evil.” In order to cover up the assassination of Arafat and to cloud the issue, spread confusion and falsely defame Arafat as “Gay,” Mahmoud Abbas, the U.S./”Israeli” proxy and actual assassin of Yassar Arafat, made the claim to Ahmad Jibril, founder of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine General Command in Damascus, an early friend who later became a long-time enemy of Arafat, that Arafat had died of AIDS. (!) There was however no mention of AIDS in Arafat’s final medical records although this was first alleged by the New York Times the day after Arafat died November 12, 2004! The New York Daily News, July 20, 2007, also confirmed that there had been no mention of AIDS in Arafat’s final medical records. But Ashraf al-Kurdi, Arafat’s personal physician in Ramallah before he was transferred to Paris stated in an Israeli newspaper that French doctors told him that Arafat had AIDS when he died! Ashraf al-Kurdi stated that Arafat had tested negative for AIDS only 3 months earlier and said that Arafat had been deliberately infected with the AIDS virus in order to hide the poison which had been used to kill him. Ashraf al-Kurdi got it completely right! That is the only explanation which fits the facts and is precisely what happened. (See Daily News Ibid.)

It is true that the Syrian leaders are completely opportunist and have worked closely with both the U.S. and Israel. The Syrians have and will continue to torture absolutely anybody the U.S. sends them through their so-called "Extraordinary Rendition” Torture Program, which incidentally is not extraordinary for the capitalists but routine and an everyday event. But Syria would have NO MOTIVE whatsoever to assassinate Hariri! Only the United States and Israeli, the puppet of U.S.-led world imperialism, and Mahmoud Abbas have the motive! The motive of the Hariri assassination was 1.) to generate the pretext to pressure Syria to withdraw from Lebanon—which was the almost immediate result and 2.) to supply the pretext to try to overthrow the Baath Socialist Party-led government of Syria! Syria has a socialist system, which provides full employment, no homelessness, free education to the highest level and free medical and dental just like Iraq used to have, all of which is unavailable in the United States! The capitalists want to get rid of it and institute so-called “freedom and democracy,” which under capitalism have become euphemisms for capitalist dictatorship, enslavement and the “freedom” to exploit and super-exploit. Just like they have done in Iraq and everywhere else possible, including the U.S.A.! But they are losing this battle in Latin America, which has begun electing some Communists. Long and convoluted articles based on CIA files, e.g. the November 3, 2005 article in the New York Times demonstrate how determined the capitalists are to try to undermine the Syrian Baath Socialist government and falsely implicate Bashir al-Assad, a former ophthalmologist as supposedly having given the order to assassinate Hariri! But Hariri had already resigned from the government when he was assassinated! If the Syrians hated him so much they would have assassinated him while he was in office! The reason that he was assassinated after he left office rather than when he was in office and presumably more of a “threat”, which he never really was, was that such a provocation simply did not occur to U.S. and Israel earlier. The truth is that Hariri never ever had a majority support for his anti-Syrian position! Not even close! Not even after he was assassinated! Not even now! Syria has supported Hezbollah, whose defensive attacks against the illegal Israeli invasion and occupation of Lebanon, forced Israel to finally pull out of Lebanon and all the Lebanese know it! The U.S.-directed “Israeli” Mossad is widely recognized and understood to be the assassin of Hariri and Arafat, etc. throughout the Mideast! It’s time to wake up here in the USA!

To assassinate Hariri the U.S. directed Israeli Mossad assassins used a huge truck bomb, which they drove through Syria, or assembled in Syria, and painstakingly filmed leaving Syria and driving all through Lebanon and Beirut before being blown up, where it was also filmed at the point of detonation! It is not credible that surveillance cameras would be so strategically placed to document this event so precisely unless it had been planned in advance. This is very similar to the video that was made of “the first AIDS ‘Typhoid Mary’” (so-called patient 0) where the capitalists deliberately infected a promiscuous male airline steward through his “doctor” with the AIDS virus then followed him, videotaping him going from one assignation to another unknowingly spreading AIDS. But what these Biowarfare enthusiasts, who could not have made the film for any other reason than to document their Biological Warfare handiwork, did not realize was that the film actually implicated those who made it. The questions immediately arose: 1.How did the video tapers know that person had AIDS? 2.) Why didn’t they stop him? The same thing applies with the film of the Hariri truck bomb.

Instead the United States has ordered its United Nations puppet leadership to begin a phony “investigation,” which has been authorized by the Security Council! The only problem is that the capitalists currently have only one “witness.” (Of course more can be manufactured if necessary!) The witness, Hossam Taher Hossam, who identified himself to the UN inquiry as a former Syrian intelligence officer, alleged in a 75-minute interview on November 27, 2005 that Hariri’s son, Saad Hariri, met him several months ago and offered him $1.3 million to testify against top Syrian officials. But the question of credible motive and who only benefits from such assassinations—the United States and its cat’s paw Israel—is never raised in this brazen provocation. The capitalists are running totally amok! Everything the capitalists attempt turns into a fiasco. On June 28, 2006 the U.S. ordered its Proxy Zionist Army of Israel to buzz the Syrian coast and the house of Syrian leader Bashir al-Assad while threatening to attack Syria on the pretext that the exiled supreme leader of Hamas, Khaled Mashaal, living in Syria ordered the kidnapping of an Israeli soldier! Right! This was carried out while the U.S. Zionist Proxy State of Israel was invading Gaza under the laughably fraudulent pretext of trying to “rescue the kidnapped (murderer) Israeli soldier,” for whom they do not give a damn, and relentlessly bombing and shelling Gaza population centers and torturing the population all night with sonic booms in order to deprive them of sleep just like they torture prisoners in Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo, all in direct violation of International Law, just exactly like its U.S. master which writes Torture Memorandums and gives virtually all the orders.

The U.S. and its Zionist Proxy State of Israel also wage economic war against Hamas by having Israel collect over $500 million in taxes from the Palestinians and then refusing to turn the money back over to the Palestinians to run their government because the capitalists do not really believe in democracy when the masses choose to elect Hamas. They actually thought that they might be able to impose the election of Fatah on the Palestinians after it was taken over by U.S./Israeli Puppet Mahmoud Abbas after he was nice enough to help poison Arafat! After the assassination of Arafat by the U.S./“Israel”/Abbas-Fatah Axis the majority of those Fatah leaders who had been loyal to Arafat were expelled from Fatah, which has now been taken over lock stock and barrel as a tool of the U.S. and its Zionist Proxy State. Fatah has been organized to attack Hamas and to create chaos in Gaza (New York Times, August 29, 2006), while Judeo-Nazi “Israel” simply arbitrarily arrests dozens of Hamas cabinet ministers and legislators. (Reuters, June 29, 2006) Prior to its air attack on Lebanon the U.S. “Israeli” Proxy State pledged to bomb the infrastructure of Lebanon back to the Stone Age, which they did, while they threatened Syria and Iran! All completely authorized by their master the USA! Bombing a country back to the Stone Age was precisely the policy of the U.S. in Vietnam! This is why in order for there to be a genuine solution in the Middle East there first must be a Socialist Revolution in the United States!

The U.S./ “Israeli” Mossad Assassinates Pierre Gemayal in a Vain
Attempt to Try to Prop Up Their Puppet Lebanese Government!

In any crime motive is primary: who benefits? Who has the real motive and the access and a long-standing prior history of assassination—the U.S./ “Israelis”! In order to try to prop up the U.S./“Israel”-backed Fuad Saniora puppet Lebanese government and create division within Lebanon, which is about to fall because of widespread popular support of Hezbollah among all of the 17 Lebanese sects, the U.S./“Israeli” Mossad, as a provocation in its typical style, assassinated Pierre Gemayal on November 21, 2006. Gemayal was a minister in that puppet government and was the Fascist grandson of Pierre Gemayal, who supported the NAZIs in WWI and the nephew of Bachir Gemayal, the leader of the Fascist Christian Phalangist Militia who carried out the 1982 Massacres of Palestinians in the Sabra and Shittila refugee camps, which was directly ordered by Ariel Sharon! The subsequent demonstrations on November 23, 2006 organized in support of their sacrificed Phalangist fell flat totally and were countered and completely overwhelmed by demonstrations beginning on December 10, 2006 in support of Hezbollah which numbered over 2 million people—over half the Lebanese population—demonstrating in the center of Beirut Lebanon peacefully calling for the U.S./ “Israeli”/French backed puppet government to step down!

The Assassination of Yitzhak Rabin Was a “Queen Sacrifice” Carried Out by
the Israeli Government, under Authorization From its United States Master, in Order to Increase Support Among Israelis for the Oslo Peace Accords in 1995
But Was Gratuitously Sabotaged by Likud-directed Shin Bet!

In 1995 support for the Oslo Peace Accords was substantial among Palestinians because it represented a better situation than they had, but Israel was split right down the middle with supporters versus opponents. Because the Mideast and the Oslo Accords were so important to the United States, Israel and the entire capitalist world, both politically and economically, potentially opening up an area which had been shunned by big investors because of the Intifada and constant threat of suicide bombings, the capitalists decided to carry out what is known in politics and chess as a Queen Sacrifice in order to increase support for the Oslo accords among the Israelis. At a rally in support of the Oslo Accords on November 4, 1995, members of the Israeli security forces deliberately allowed a Zionist fanatic, Yigal Amir, to breach security around Rabin as the rally ended and Rabin was on his way to his car. (In this respect the Rabin assassination was very similar to the 9/11 Trade Center Attack, which was also a government-facilitated provocation, where the Bush Regime deliberately opened the door to the Islamic Fundamentalists to permit them to obtain flight training for jumbo jets in the face of local FBI protests [see above] and kept the Air Force jet interceptors grounded for over an hour in order to permit the 9/11 Attack to be successfully carried out.) After the Rabin assassination support for the Oslo Accords among Israelis increased to over 71%!

The assassination of Rabin appeared to be a “success!” But shortly thereafter on January 5, 1996, the head of Shin Bet, Avi Dichter, known up to that time only as “Kaf,” under pressure from the fanatical Zionist Likud Party and acting against the objectives of the United States and its puppet Israeli government, gratuitously assassinated the chief Hamas suicide bomb maker, Yehiya Ayash, in the Gaza Strip by planting a radio-controlled bomb in his cell phone. But Yehiya Ayash had had no business for years! Ayash was no longer a viable threat because nobody wanted to volunteer for suicide bombing against Israel and in fact there had not been any suicide bombing in Israel for several years after the signing of the 1993 Oslo Accords, which stood to improve the situation for Palestinians living in Occupied Palestine. Support for the Oslo Accord was also at an all time high among Israelis after the “successful” Queen Sacrifice of Rabin. Avi Dichter was a literal example of a loose cannon and his motive was clear as crystal! The Israeli government and the United States were furious! The Shin Bet Chief “Kaf’s” offer of resignation was accepted several days after he ordered the assassination of Ayash. Previously “Kaf’s” pro forma offers of resignation after the carefully planned Rabin assassination were turned down by Peres, who was also part of the Rabin assassination, which briefly advanced Israeli interests! In order to expose “Kaf” for acting against Israeli and U.S. interests, the new Shin Bet Chief, Ami Ayalon, former Rear Admiral in the Israeli Navy agreed to openly accept the position as the new Shin Bet Chief one week after the Shin Bet assassination of Ayash, allowing his name to be known for the first time as the new Shin Bet Chief in order to permit the Israeli government to be able to then reveal the name of his trouble-maker predecessor, “Kaf,” who was Avi Dichter, who would no longer enjoy the government security he had while head of Shin Bet!

It was a completely new precedent in Israeli politics to announce the name of the head of Shin Bet, and was designed to jeopardize the security of those Zionist fanatics who would act independently against Israeli interests and U.S. interests. (Yigal Amir, the Zionist fanatic who assassinated Rabin was manipulated to advance U.S. and Israeli interests.) The assassination of Yehiya Ayash of Hamas was a deliberately calculated provocation by Likud to sabotage support for the the Oslo Accords among Israelis by providing the pretext for retaliatory suicide bombing by Hamas and other Islamic Fundamentalist groups, which began immediately after the assassination and has continued ever since right up to the present moment. On September 28, 2000 Ariel Sharon went onto the Temple Mount, Al Haram ash-Sharif in Arabic (Noble Sanctuary), as a deliberate provocation, after the Camp David negotiations broke up earlier on July 5th, in order to deliberately incite the Palestinians and start up a Second Intifada and resulting “Israeli retaliation,” which was used as the pretext to further crush and oppress the Palestinians and to try to force them into total submission. But that will never happen!

United States/“Israeli” Apartheid Prison Wall

This situation has continued up until the present despite the fact that before his stroke Likud Chief Sharon agreed to U.S. demands to withdraw from Gaza and tried to give the appearance of supporting a “Two State Solution” with the Palestinians, but where the Palestinians would in practice remain under the jackboot of the Israeli Fascists behind the U.S./Israeli Apartheid Wall, which is actually a prison in violation of the Fourth Geneva Convention and United Nations Resolution 242. That Apartheid Wall—euphemistically termed “segregation barrier,” as even James Earl Carter refers to it in his book (see below) which admirably uses the word Apartheid in the title but then adopts the euphemistic Orwellian U.S./“Israeli” capitalist media terminology in the text as a “separation barrier” or “fence” while describing the Wall’s deliberate effects to separate the Palestinians themselves and destroy their lives and economy, is over five (5.1046 actually) times as long and over twice as high as the Berlin Wall. (The Berlin Wall was 13.12 feet high and 96 miles long.) The Apartheid Wall is designed to incorporate large tracts of valuable Palestinian land and resources into so-called “Israel” in huge West Bank settlements, while leaving the Palestinians with a few nonviable disconnected Bantustans (not Cantons!) as in South Africa—not Switzerland, which the US and Israel ridiculously try to call “a future state for the Palestinians!” The Israeli Apartheid Wall is 28 ft. high (30 feet high according to “Palestine Peace Not Apartheid” by James Earl Carter). It is presently 490 miles long as of December 28, 2008 and counting, with 95-315 ft. of buffer zone with electric fence, trenches, cameras and security patrols, which according to the new acting Prime Minister, Ehud Olmert, of the new so-called “centrist” Kadima Party, will form the basis of the permanent boundary between “Israel” and a proposed Palestinian State (Prison)! The Israeli Apartheid Prison Wall is built entirely within Palestinian territory and is projected to be at least three and a half times as long as “Israel’s” presently recognized border (!) and includes 375,000 Palestinians (and counting) on the “Israeli” side of the wall, 175,000 of whom are outside Jerusalem. (See above-mentioned book.) According to Carter the most comprehensive description of the Apartheid Wall is the film The Iron Wall by the Palestinian Agricultural Relief Committees costing $10.00 at, which however does not specify the wall’s actual present length. The reality is that “Israel’s” agreement to support a “Two State Solution” is clearly fraudulent and only represented a bargaining chip to try to manipulate Hamas into recognizing Israel, which Hamas has steadfastly and admirably refused to do. That refusal forced the U.S./ “Israel” to direct their proxy and Arafat assassin, Mahmoud Abbas, to illegally call for new elections, which the U.S./ “Israeli” proxy Fatah thinks it can rig to produce a Fatah victory. In the Mid-East the so-called Quartet’s “Road Map” is understood by the majority to be a total fraud and just going through the motions for sake of appearances and as a smoke screen to obscure and hide the reality of the ever increasing oppression of the Palestinians. The Israeli Apartheid Wall represents the hardening dictatorship of U.S. capitalism-imperialism in the Mid-East. Be under no illusion, there is no real possibility of formation of a Secular State of Palestine (see below) and dismantlement of the Apartheid Wall without a Socialist Revolution first occurring in the United States.

The Only Solution for the Middle East is One Secular
State Of Palestine which has as its Pre-Condition:
Socialist Revolution in the United States!

The only solution which could ever succeed on a long term basis is a One Secular State Solution which is neither a Zionist state nor an Islamic state. This can only come about after a Socialist Revolution here in the United States and will automatically be one of the immediate outcomes of that Socialist Revolution. This fact should be made widely known to all Jews and all Moslems. There can be no oppression of Palestinians and there can be no oppression of Jews. Zionism—Jewish nationalism—has no place in a peaceful future of the Mideast and neither does Islamic Fundamentalism, both of which represent reaction not progress. The Jewish people have always had a progressive history up until World War II and the Holocaust. Two-thirds of the leadership of the Russian Revolution was Jewish! In Europe Jews followed Communists and Social Democrats—NOT Zionists. In Germany the Zionists only got about 5% of the Jewish vote, while in Poland it was higher, up to 35%, due to the capitalists’ barrage of anti-Soviet anti-Communist propaganda because of its proximity to the Soviet Union. The Jewish people had its Communist and progressive leadership beheaded in the Holocaust along with the 6 million Jews murdered by Hitler, who also murdered 27 million Soviet citizens and millions of others including 500,000 Gypsies (Roma), a total of 57 million people died in WWII. After the Holocaust, reactionary and Fascist Zionists, some who had actually made agreements with Hitler, were insinuated into leadership positions among the Holocaust Survivors, whose first choice was to emigrate to the United States and Great Britain. Both countries turned down the Holocaust Survivors, prevented their entry and directed them to Palestine, where the capitalists helped them set up the Zionist entity “Israel” as a garrison proxy state to protect U.S. and British imperialist oil interests. Stalin, no Communist (see below), eager to ingratiate himself with the United States after WWII was the first to opportunistically recognize so-called “Israel” As mentioned, Israel is not formally even a state because it is economically, politically, diplomatically and militarily dependent on the United States. If this support were withdrawn Israel would collapse like a house of cards. Israel’s 200 plus nuclear weapons at Damona would be of no help to the Zionist criminals without oil. The Proxy State of so-called “Israel” does not represent the interests of the Jewish people. “Israel” is bad for Jews! Its existence has increased the threat to Jewish people everywhere! This is undeniable and can only be ended with a Socialist Revolution in the United States!

Obama Supports the U.S./Israel War on Gaza Just like Bush, which
Was Carried Out to try to Weaken Hamas and Enforce a Fraudulent
2-State Solution so-called “Peace Process” Where the Palestinians
Are Supposed to Live Behind the Apartheid/Prison Wall!

Obama said nothing except that he was supposedly “monitoring the situation” when the U.S. authorized and directed its Proxy Israel to begin the War Against Gaza starting with a relentless bombing campaign on December 27, 2008 which was followed by a ground invasion on January 3, 2009, which has killed almost 500 Palestinians and wounded nearly 3,000 Palestinians. The United States ordered its proxy state of so-called “Israel” to attack Gaza prior to Obama actually taking office in order to try to change the facts on the ground by weakening or eliminating Hamas which won the election in Gaza in 2006 by 72% of the vote! When Fatah, which supports Israel and the U.S., tried to take over militarily Hamas routed Fatah because they were traitors who were well know to work with “Israel” and the U.S. against Palestinian interests, and who also had helped murder Yassar Arafat, their own front man when he ran out of credibility. Fatah has virtually no popular support and was driven out of Gaza, and prior to the War on Gaza Hamas was on the verge of asserting its election victory on the West Bank, which the U.S./”Israeli”-backed Fatah, which controls the presently misnamed “Palestinian Authority despite the fact that Fatah had won only about 28% of the popular vote in the 2006 election! The capitalist dictatorship believes that it can enforce a ridiculous “2-state solution” on the Palestinian people! They think that the Palestinians will be more likely to agree to living behind the Apartheid/Prison Wall, which is more than 5 times as long and over twice as high as the Berlin Wall! To accept such a “peace” would be ridiculous! It would be like telling the inmates at Leavenworth Penitentiary that they are now citizens of the “free and independent state of Leavenworth...Penitentiary!” The answer is a secular state of Palestine! This implies the abolition of “Israel” and Zionist rule but does not permit any anti-Semitism or any anti-Islamism! This goal can ONLY be achieved by carrying out a Socialist Revolution in the United States as explained further below.

The Kibbutzim Are A Total Deception and a
Means of Neutralizing Potential Communists!

Jewish people worldwide and Israelis alike must organize themselves against Zionism and for a Socialist Revolution. Israel plays another little number on its citizens many of whom aspire to Socialism and would like to think of themselves as progressive. Israel runs a network of 270 Kibbutzim, which are communal settlements supposedly based on the principle of joint ownership of property, equality and cooperation of production, consumption and education; the fulfillment of the idea "from each according to his ability, to each according to his needs." But the reality is that they do not represent Socialism at all in any way and cannot because they exist within a capitalist dictatorship and function to help maintain that dictatorship. This is an example of the dialectical contradiction of form and essence. The Kibbutzim are a just a trick, a deception used to exhaust progressive-minded people and to isolate potential Communists away from main population centers and to exploit the labor of about 130,000 Israelis who supply and help maintain the Imperialist-cat’s paw of the United States—“Israel”—in its permanent war against the Palestinians and the other Mideast countries. At age 18 all members of the Kibbutzim all must serve in the Israel army, 3 years for men and 21 months for women, and for each year thereafter until age 51 men must serve 39 days each year in the army, while those who have seen combat are allowed to stop after age 45. Thus there are no “innocent Israeli citizens” unless they are in the process of organizing a mutiny in the Israeli puppet army. Unless the Israeli people carry out a mutiny the reality is that every child in Israel will grow up brainwashed and be organized to kill, torture and oppress Palestinians. Only a Socialist Revolution in the United States can bring this to an end. It’s pre-condition is mutiny in all the armed forces of the capitalist countries!

The position of all Communists, and all progressive people who are not yet Communists, is to support all those oppressed by capitalism-imperialism and its Zionist cat’s paw and that includes supporting the Hamas Palestinians and supporting Hezbollah against the U.S./“Israeli” Invasion of Lebanon and against the U.S./“Israeli” puppet government of Lebanon, which may now be overthrown by popular demand. Both the Lebanese Army and the “Israeli” army should be encouraged to mutiny, as should the entire population of Occupied Palestine—so-called “Israel!” That does not mean that Communists support Islamic Fundamentalism or Sharia any more than they do Zionism. Nor does supporting Hezbollah and Hamas against the U.S. and “Israel” mean in any way that Communists support the nuclear bombing of “Israel” by Iran! Not at all! By consistently opposing capitalism-imperialism in all of its death throe invasions and statecraft against the people of this planet capitalism is weakened overall and the Socialist Revolution brought closer and with it a Secular State of Palestine. The overthrow of Zionism in “Israel,” will occur in tandem with the Socialist Revolution in the United States. The elimination of the Zionist state will permanently eliminate the threat to the Jewish people. The Jewish people must no longer tolerate representation by Zionists and should begin immediately to deprogram themselves of the cancer of Zionism!

William H. Depperman, Coordinator
United Front Against Racism
And Capitalism-Imperialism
Union Square Park
New York, N.Y. 10003
March 2, 2009

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Guest Contributors
Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Powered by TypePad


The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use