What's wrong with this Hurricane? Posted by Moira Whelan

I just noticed that the daily brief customarily done in advance of a hurricane is happening because Gustov is bearing down on the Gulf Coast…but a big shift here: the briefing is being given by NORTHCOM. So what does this tell us and why does it matter? It tells us that things are as broken as they were before Katrina.

The military, like EPA, Commerce, or anyone else, is only involved in emergency management to the point that they are requested to do so by the governor or the FEMA director (who acts on behalf of the President).

When it comes to disasters, the governor is always in charge. At any point, he or she can call in their state’s National Guard, and/or ask other governors for their help in augmenting response efforts with their national guard or other resources. If a governor is worried things are getting out of control, they ask the President to provide help through FEMA at any point before or after the incident. FEMA is then in charge of coordinating the resources of the federal government to support the governor and the state. In a sense, when FEMA is working properly—as it did under Clinton—when the FEMA director tells another Federal agency to do something, it’s as if the President is calling. The government agency is expected to deliver and cut through red tape to make things happen and happen fast. 

There is no allowance or legal authority for the Department of Defense to take any sort of control or command in this scenario. In a hurricane, DoD, like Human Services, Transportation, etc, all work for FEMA and the governor of the impacted state.

This is done for a very specific and important reason: here in America, we believe that governors should have control over their own states. The federal government needs to be there to help, but they absolutely do not move in and take over. We also do not believe that the military should ever forcibly operate inside the United States unless they are under civilian control.

With NORTHCOM taking the lead on briefing the public, it’s clear the Bush Administration wants to send the message that everything is under control. Instead, to those that do this for a living, the message is clear that everything is absolutely and completely broken.

Perhaps the state governments need help. Perhaps FEMA is not up to the job. Perhaps the Bush Administration simply wants a uniform on camera, and this way of doing things is preferable to things happening the way that they should (a process, by the way, that WORKED before Bush screwed it up).

NORTHCOM taking the lead in public relations is a clear indication that nothing has been fixed in DHS and FEMA since Katrina. As a result, there is no confidence in FEMA’s ability to respond to this hurricane. With NORTHCOM at the helm, the Bush Administration either doesn’t care if, or doesn’t want, the systems to work. This Administration has issued a lot of reports since Katrina (none of which suggest the military should take control, incidentially), but no one has been held accountable and the lessons have not been learned. The priority is still on preventing embarrassment, not keeping people safe.

The other thing to remember here is that this is not a mission the military wants. Sure, they can ride in on a white horse and do what they can, but their job is to fight wars, not deal with disasters. Governors need their national guards to make this a priority (but most are in Iraq) but DoD needs to worry about the rest of the world. By dumping this on them, the Bush Administration is reinforcing the idea that the military is the only government agency that people can trust and continues to burden them with missions for which they are not trained.

The bottom line is that things will not work the way they should with NORTHCOM in charge.  Governors don’t take orders from Generals. No one else in government takes orders from DoD. No one in emergency management even knows what NORTHCOM does, except come in and issue “orders” to a bunch of civilians who don't work for them.

I hope for the sake of the people on the Gulf Coast that the hundreds of civilians who want to do right by them prevail over the system that the Bush Administration has failed to fix.

H/T to Jason McNamara for this one.

What'

Comments

[Peace]

It suprises me that the admministration's negelect in giving FEMA the necessary funds to repond to emergencies has not been a campaign topic especially after Katrina. The Republicans talk so much about national security, but yet they cut funding for agencies such as FEMA, who are must reponsible for the protection of the American people in case of a natural emergency or terrorist attack.

[Howl]

It is all well and good to state that FEMA worked so much better under Clinton, but that is rather disingenuous as Clinton's FEMA never had to deal with a Katrina-sized disaster. Praising an athlete in practice is one thing, but it's irrelevant if she's never played in a game.

[Bag O'Hammers]

@Howl: You gotta be kidding me. FEMA worked fine for several administrations, not just Clinton's. Is that the only argument conservatives have -- noun, verb, Bill Clinton?

You must remember that FEMA's approach to everything changed radically with the reorg after 9/11.

FEMA "played" in many "games" -- Hurricane Andrew, etc -- without the kind of major incidents seen in Katrina post-reorg.

[Can't say]

I think there's a little bit more here worth considering. First, unless things have changed dramatically in the last year, it's not the head of FEMA that's in charge of domestic response, it's the Secretary of Homeland Security. (See HSPD 5, "The Secretary of Homeland Security is the principal Federal official for domestic incident management.") Chertoff can, and does, delegate that role to a Principal Federal Official during such incidents but he does not always delegate it to the head of FEMA. He did for Katrina, which is why Brown(ie) was so roundly criticized -- his agency failed to prepare for the storm, and *HE* failed as the incident manager.

Finally, DHS and NORTHCOM have a fairly close relationship, and I'm not sure it's fair to say that "nobody in emergency management even knows what NORTHCOM does." Part of the reason they were established was to coordinate civil support missions that involve the military, including the National Guard. And given the Secretary's responsibilities in a domestic incident ("...coordinating Federal operations within the United States to prepare for, respond to, and recover from terrorist attacks, major disasters, and other emergencies"), they could be playing this role as a part of the coordinated Federal response.

Finally, HSPD 5 specifically does NOT require State or local governments to request help before the Secretary takes on this coordinating role among Federal agencies.

Let me be crystal clear -- I'm not defending the DHS/FEMA response to Katrina, the preparations for Gustav, or the current SOP for Federal coordination to domestic incidents. I'm just saying there's a veritable maze of authorities, roles, and responsibilities at play here. (Caveat: My knowledge on this is somewhat dated, and new authorities may be in play!)

[Don Bacon]

It's also a subtle, but clear, indication that we're coming under military rule, a sort of martial-law lite.

[Can't say]

I just realized there are two "finally"s in my post above. Woops!

[Pierce Wetter]

Seargents worry about tactics. Coronels worry about strategy. Generals worry about logistics. I find most of you article woefully ignorant about what the military actually does.

In the wake of a natural disaster, you want a hot meal, a cot, a blanket, and a tent. There is no one on earth better equipped to deliver those things then the US military, because winning wars is about exactly those same things.

Meanwhile, FEMA is mostly about the financial aspects of a disaster.

In other words, get off your civilian high horse. Getting the military involved early to deal with what could be a cat 5 hurricane could be exactly the right thing to do. The military has more knowledge about transportation, health care, food, and transportation than any civilian agency.

In short the guys at FEMA are bankers, the guys in the military are truck drivers. In a natural disaster, you need truck drivers, not bankers.

[Pierce Wetter]

Another way to put it. The Army has to deliver a hot meal, a cot, etc. while people are shooting at them. So what's a little wind and rain. :-)

[Tom]

What a stupid article! 1) Bush doesn't want a 9/11 commission, but Dems insist & we get one with a report & recommendations. 2) Bush says he will implement some recs. but not the dumb ones like subordinating FEMA to DHS. (He says this will ruin FEMA; remember?!) Dems scream that all recs. MUST be implemented, & Bush stupidly relents. Now that FEMA is ruined, it's clearly ALL Bush's fault.

[Yves]

Northcom isn't supposed to have authority in this case, even if requested by State. The so-called "insurrection act" amendment to the Posse Comitatus of 1807 was repealed in 08 by H.R. 4986.
Curently the law reads:
Under 18 U.S.C. § 831, the Attorney General may request that the Secretary of Defense provide emergency assistance if civilian law enforcement is inadequate to address certain types of threat involving the release of nuclear materials, such as potential use of a nuclear or radiological weapon. Such assistance may be by any personnel under the authority of the Department of Defense, provided such assistance does not adversely affect U.S. military preparedness.
I don't see Hurricanes anywhere I look.
Maybe I'm not looking in the rught places.
Fishy....

[TaiwanThinker]

Well Golly Gee Great!

Now we have a disaster response system similar to what the People's Republic of China has! Their primary response method is the People's Liberation Army, as seen this year with the devastating Sichuan Earthquake in May 2008.

The Republican Wrecking Crew now forces us to use a MAJCOM of the US military structured for *wartime missions* to now handle a job that FEMA was supposed to be in charge of.

That tells quite a lot doesn't it?

How is the Army going to be delivering meals, cots and tents when the National Guard units are on {insert tour number here} _________ tour of Iraq/Afghanistan?

Republicans are great at campaigning for government office.
And have fabulously demonstrated how able they are for wrecking government once they attain it.

Have we had enough yet?

[viperson]

Department of Defense, provided such assistance does not adversely affect U.S. military preparedness.
I don't see Hurricanes anywhere I look. discount tramadol Bush says he will implement some recs. but not the dumb ones like subordinating FEMA to DHS. purchase tramadol Well Golly Gee Great!

[viperson]

This is done for a very specific and important reason: here in America, we believe that governors should have control over their own states. buy cheap tramadol The federal government needs to be there to help, but they absolutely do not move in and take over. We also do not believe that the military should ever forcibly operate inside the United States unless they are under civilian control.tramadol online Such assistance may be by any personnel under the authority of the Department of Defense, provided such assistance does not adversely affect U.S. military preparedness. order tramadol Finally, HSPD 5 specifically does NOT require State or local governments to request help before the Secretary takes on this coordinating role among Federal agencies.

[viperson]

Finally, DHS and NORTHCOM have a fairly close relationshipbuy tramadol and I'm not sure it's fair to say that "nobody in emergency management even knows what NORTHCOM does. No administration would undertake such a thing lightly, and I'm not sure many administrations before this one would have left the Secretary of Defense to handle it by himself, with no White House comment at all.buy tramadol online This is noteworthy in an administration that has tended to keep its cabinet officials on very short leashes. Part of the reason they were established was to coordinate civil support missions that involve the military, including the National Guard. cheap tramadol And given the Secretary's responsibilities in a domestic incident ("...coordinating Federal operations within the United States to prepare for, respond to.

[viperson]

buy discount tramadol and recover from terrorist attacks, major disasters, and other emergencies"), Air Force chiefs have been able to run their own rogue operation for so long unchecked. tramadol cheap they could be playing this role as a part of the coordinated Federal response.

[twelve sky Gold]

Welcome to our game world, my friend asks me to buy some 12sky gold . I do not know how to use the twelvesky Gold ; my friend tells me how to use. I will thank for my friends bringing me in this world. I am not regret to buy 12Sky Silver Coins . We all love game, if you want to play it, please buy 12 sky gold and join us. Please do not hesitate to have game.

[buy AO credits]

When you have Anarchy credits, you will become strong. With Anarchy Online credits, you can upgrade and admire by others. You can use Anarchy gold to start the journey of the world. So, do not hesitate, let us move to buy AO credits

[requiem online gold]

Welcome to our requiem gold center. We can provide all what you want if you want. Our requiem lant are specialized, professional and reliable website

[dd]

I hope i can get FFXI Gil in low price,
Yesterday i bought FFXI gold for my friend.

[buy 9 Dragons gold]

I like to buy 9 Dragons gold. For me 9Dragons money is not just a simple thing.

[glammamix]

finc good site! odaback.1d cialis <a href=http://odaback.1d>cialis</a> wk822

[Discount Valention Handbag]

like to buy 9 Dragons gold. For me 9Dragons money is not just a simple thing

[luxury watches]

I am so with you,rolex watch
luxury watch

[cheap coach handbags]

Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!

[sohbet odaları]

This is a very good site..

sonra bedava chat
burasıda var bedava sohbet

[chanel handbags]

Chanel Handbags are woman’s dream come true.

Chanel, a fashion name that has become synonymous with femininity since 100 years, is on the must-have list of every fashion-conscious woman.? And we bring these must-have Chanel Handbags at never before discounts, just for you.

It is only when you come across an Chanel New Arrivals, do you realize the power of her words.? Chanel handbags are crafted not just to be trendy, but trend-setting.? Hardly has lived a celebrity who has not been seen carrying a Chanel handbag under her arm; such has the influence of Chanel handbags as a fashion statement.

Chanel handbags have been so popular in the elite classes of the society, that their pricing is usually prohibitive for everyone else.? Discount Chanel handbags are really difficult to come across, but today should be your lucky day.? We bring you a superb unbeatable range of Chanel Flap bags, all at fantastic discounts.? With us, you have an incredible chance to buy your favorite Chanel handbags at rock bottom prices!

Chanel Handbags have always been at the forefront of luxury and style.? The Chanel classic quilted leather handbags and its reinventions have ruled fashion since forever.? Chanel handbags have remained extremely popular as they continue to merge evolving modern trends with the class and simplicity of its original avatar.

An Chanel 2008 Collection and Chanel 2009 Collection single handedly enhances the look you are carrying.? The reason you would buy a Chanel handbag is own a bag that mingles with your charm and intensifies it with its inherent simplicity.? If you have owned an authentic Chanel handbag before, you know what we are talking about.? If you are one of the unlucky people who haven’t yet gotten a chance to own an Chanel Cambon, now is your chance to shop for an authentic Chanel handbag and discover its ability to transform your look completely.

Buy Chanel handbags with us, and get fabulous discounts which you will never get at your favorite store.? We offer cheap authentic Chanel handbags and they are all up for grabs!

[k247br]

e biodegradablechanel bags when you "stoop and scoop."
Dispose of animal waste according to the campground rules or bury it off-road.
Observe fire coguccinditions and always keep a full jug of water nearby.
Remove flammable brush near fire pits and keep campfires small.
Don't burn plastics and metalshermes.
Use non-toxic, phosphate-free, biodegradable cleaning supplies and sanitary additives.
Reduce the need louis vuitton for air-conditioning by parking in natural shade, opening windows, using awnings or portable sun shelters.
Wash air-conditionidesignerng filters when dirty, instead of buying new ones each time.
Reduce the need to turn on heat designer handbagsby parking in a sheltered spot, out of the north and west winds.

[Supra Skytop II]

I own all my triumphs and successes.

[Nike Shox]

Doing income on the web isn't an in a single day encounter like many may feel, but producing funds online is absolutely a foreseeable probability. As well, increasing reputation on the net just isn't an in a single day expertise, but through time, dedication, and persistence you will be rewarded with all of the royalties of blogging.

[nike shox]

In the wake of a natural disaster, you want a hot meal, a cot, a blanket, and a tent. There is no one on earth better equipped to deliver those things then the US military, because winning wars is about exactly those same things.

[led miner cap lamp]

Specialize in manufacture explosion proof light, including: explosion proof floodlight, led flashlight, spot lamp, led mining light, led searching light with rechargeable battery in China.

[Dog bark collars]

Thanks for the post. This keeps me informed about the topic. By the way, if you have time, please give me a few seconds by visiting my website at citronella bark collar citronella anti bark collar

[magic bullet]

throughout the report, the control-freakish language of "order" and and "ordering" comes up over and over. This language is, I know, very much favored by John Ikenberry, who I imagine is the report's chief author. Ikenberry is fixated on a Kantian vision of "liberal order".

[Cruz Phillipson]

We have been waiting for your launch of android for a long time, finally it came with Motorola cellphone & sprint package.

[Philomena Buhoveckey]

from the light youngsters didn't want their pool contaminated.