To Talk or Not to Talk Posted by Ilan Goldenberg

There has been a lot of debate recently about whether or not there can be any progress on the peace process without engagement with Hamas.  Thus far the debate has been primarily talk or don’t talk.  But the interesting conversation as far as I’m concerned is about how to talk. 

Ghaith al-Omari writing at Middle East Progress and Brian Katulis posting on the Wonk Room lay out the potential pitfalls of direct engagement with Hamas.  Omari writes:

In any engagement, Hamas—like any rational political actor—will seek to maximize its benefits and minimize its costs. It will use any international dialogue it can achieve to send one overriding message to its local, regional and global constituencies alike: namely, that it can maintain its positions regarding the peace process, Israel and the use of violence, while at the same time gaining international legitimacy. It will argue that it provides at least as many benefits as its secular opponents, without making any compromises. Engaging Hamas without the terms of engagement being clear and without it first paying the political price of admission to the international club—particularly by accepting the two-state solution and disarming—amounts to a political free lunch

I think this makes sense.  Direct engagement by either Israel or the U.S. on full comprehensive peace talks with Hamas completely undermines Fatah and Abbas and sends the signal that Hamas can gain the domestic political benefits of refusing to acknowledge Israel’s right to exist, while at the same time being considered a credible international political actor.  At the end, the result would be more an empowerment of Hamas then an opportunity to moderate it.

Still, there is the practical problem of the current violence, which undermines the peace process and causes many to suffer.  Omari argues that through the Egyptians or another Arab state acting as an intermediary a ceasefire with Hamas can be arranged that results in a reduction in violence and greater mobility for Palestinians in and out of Gaza.

He then recommends going ahead more aggressively with the Annapolis process.  This means Israel needs to get serious about a settlement freeze.  And Fatah needs to get serious about building credible and less corrupt long-term institutions that gain greater support from the Palestinian people.  Meanwhile, Israel and the United States also need to do everything they can to empower effective moderates inside the West Bank and Gaza, but not be seen as working too closely with them, which only serves to discredit these actors domestically.  Over time, progress on this front, and the Palestinian Authority’s ability to deliver would discredit Hamas’ hardline views, forcing it to either moderate its positions and come to the negotiating table or risk losing political support.

Instinctively, as progressives, we view talking directly to those we disagree with as a low-cost pragmatic approach to solving problems or at least looking for areas of possible agreement.  But in this case, as opposed to Iran for example, there is a real cost.  In the case of Iran, outside of the institutions of the Iranian state, there aren’t any credible powerbrokers.  So, the choice is either to engage in talks on common issues of concern or to just continue down the current path of antagonism.  But in the case of the Palestinians there are two alternatives and it’s important to take into account the internal political impact that directly engaging Hamas in long-term peace negotiations, without forcing it to first make the politically difficult compromise of recognizing Israel and renouncing violence, would have on Fatah.

Comments

[gregorbkny]

You go to the bargaining table with the opponents you have, not the ones you wish you have.

Also, isn't the reason there is your distinction between the Iran and Palestine situation that Israel has denied the possiblity of a Palestinian state, therefore they are all non-state actors on the Palestinian side.

[Dan Kervick]

This idiotic conflict in the itchy crotch of the world has been a giant waste of the world's time for decades. It's not going to end until Europe, the US and other members of the international community simply dictate the terms of the final settlement, and then suspend all trade and economic assistance with both sides until they both accept the deal. Otherwise, it's just going to be more fighting for decades, accompanied by empty blather about nonexistent "peace processes".

I really have little compassion, empathy, outrage or even intellectual curiosity left when it comes to the interminable Israeli-Palestinian farce. My fantasy preference would be to see all of the Palestinians relocate to other Arab countries, and all of the Israelis relocate to the United States, so they can both give that patch of dirt a rest. Otherwise, perhaps the rest of the world can find some way of divesting itself from all concern with those assholes, and of getting on with our business.

[cheap eve isk]

Here is the eve isk,
eve online isk is the regular site.
buy isk we supply the regular service.
I like to buy eve online isk here.

[cheap Final Fantasy XI Gold]

When you have FFXI Gil, you will become strong. With FFXI gold, you can upgrade and admire by others. You can use Final Fantasy XI gold to start the journey of the world. So, do not hesitate, let us move to buy FFXI Gil

[cheap Final Fantasy XI Gold]

Yesterday, my boyfriend gave me a lot of FFXI Giland he told me that the FFXI gold is useful for me to go into the net game. At the same time, the Final Fantasy XI gold is the gift for my birthday and I will buy FFXI Gil to thank him because it is not free for him.

[dd]

I hope i can get Sho Online Mun in low price,
Yesterday i bought Sho Mun for my friend.

[buy rupees]

so they often search where can buy rupees, I think our website maybe is your best choice. Many friends told me that in here can get rappelz money, and here you can also relax yourself.

[Fake Thomas Wylde Handbags]

so they often search where can buy rupees, I think our website maybe is your best choice.

[replica Gucci Bracelet]

so they often search where can buy rupees, I think our website maybe is your best choice.

[luxury watches]

I am so with you,rolex watch
luxury watch

[cheap coach handbags]

Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!

[sesli sohbet]

I really have little compassion, empathy, outrage or even intellectual curiosity left when it comes to the interminable Israeli-Palestinian farce. My fantasy preference would be to see all of the Palestinians relocate to other Arab countries, and all of the Israelis relocate to the United States, so they can both give that patch of dirt a rest. Otherwise, perhaps the rest of the world can find some way of divesting itself from all concern with those assholes, and of getting on with our business.
seslichat

[watches]

The sterile dial with its very legible hands and large numerals is fantastic to use, and a breeze to read in low light conditions. There is no chapter ring -- just a stainless steel space between the dial and domed sapphire crystal.The crystal features an internal anti-reflective coating that does successfully lessen the effects of glare. The domed shape of the crystal meets flush against the bezel and, while it is a small detail, the tight fit will prevent nicks in the edge of the crystal and lint or dust from taking up residence in the space. The Moray is powered by the excellent Miyota 8215 automatic movement seen in many Citizen automatics and it gives the Moray a 45 hour power reserve and handwind capability. On my wrist after a few weeks of wear, the Replica Pulsar Watches was running just about 5-7 seconds fast over a given day, spending its nights in a display case facing dial up. This is very close to COSC timing and is very similar to the Halios Holotype which uses the same movement. I wore the Moray exclusively for weeks and can attest that it is veryaccurate, sturdy, and fits easily under all of my sleeves (including Replica Locman Watches). The Moray does exhibit the same rotor noise found in almost allMiyota based Replica Haurex Watches (when you move your wrist fast enough, you willlikely hear the rotor spinning inside the case).The Benarus Moray is nearly sold out in all configurations; only the PVD with the British Racing Green (BRG) dial is Raymond Watches, and it is selling for $550 USD. It has been an big success for Benarus, and is well regarded on many collectors forums. The rare mix of vintage style, simplicity, 500m water resistance, and a great price point made the Moray a fast seller.The Moray has quickly become one of my favorite Replica Hugo Boss Watches. Benarus customer service has been great and subjectively the styling is nearly perfect for my taste in Replica Invicta Watches. After about a month of ownership, I have no complaints or warnings with the Benarus Moray; it is a Replica Rotary Watches, very robust, and beautifully built.By James Stacey » For updates on content, follow Watch Report on Twitter.Replica Officina Del Tempo and Replica Mauboussin Watches.

[k247br]

be tantchanelamount to grasp the numerous reproduced the contents of your site. In that case, she must be approved by the Changlaikanguccikan your station. The fastest yohermesu that she is from helouis vuittonre you get the fastest, so her customers can also receive up-to-date search results. So,designer note to Mars will not do. The result is you confuse the site in a large site on Mars, found the girl simpldesigner handbagsy can not tell to you

[led miner cap lamp]

Specialize in manufacture explosion proof light, including: explosion proof floodlight, led flashlight, spot lamp, led mining light, led searching light with rechargeable battery in China.