Podhoretz vs. Zakaria Posted by Ilan Goldenberg

In six minutes of News Hour footage you can boil down the entire argument over Iran between the crazies (Podhoretz) and the sane people (Zakaria). Notice especially, Podhoretz's repeated references to Hitler.  The "what would Hitler do" argument, which is often accompanied by the classic "You are worse than Chamberlin argument" is the oldest rhetorical trick in the book.  Fortunately, I just don't think that a country with a GDP the size of Florida's represents the same threat as the industrial behemoth that was Germany. 

I wonder why the Neocons never reference WWI?  You know.  The one where all sides wanted to avoid a war but accidently ended up escalating to a point where they lost control and war became inevitable.  The one where all sides underestimated the difficulty and costs of war and expected the battle to be over in months.  The war where millions died for absolutely nothing.  Surely there is something we can also learn from that episode in history.

Comments

[Zathras]

There is nothing crazy about Norman Podhoretz. He is simply thinking, and speaking, as a Jew for whom the Holocaust will always be recent history and will always be just around the corner.

The tone of violent alarm he now takes when discussing Iran is not that different from that he, and his magazine, took toward the Soviet Union during the late 1970s and early 1980s. He overestimated Soviet strength and the attractiveness of Communism then, and underestimated the capacity of America and its allies to cope with it -- but his calculation of strength was based less on a comparison of the Soviets on one hand and the Americans on the other than on a comparison of the Soviets on one hand and the Jews on the other. Official Soviet anti-Semitism and hostility to Israel (hostility, incidentally, that was absolutely profitless from the standpoint of Soviet interests) was reason enough to inspire Podhoretz's alarm and feeling of dread.

Iran is a far less formidable threat. But on the other hand Podhoretz is an old man now, perhaps more easily frightened. And here again what matters for him is not the threat Iran poses to the United States, but the threat it poses to the Jews -- granted, a threat mostly under worst-case assumptions. From Podhoretz's point of view, the worst case has already happened, making the thought that it or something like it could happen again the opposite of crazy.

The viewer of the Newshour clip will notice that Zakaria's repeated invocation of the success of deterrence with respect to Mao's revolutionary Chinese government -- actually a somewhat dubious debating point -- was something Podhoretz didn't appear even to hear. It's not hard to see why. China doesn't have anything to do with the Jews as a people, and never did. Zakaria is thinking of the Iranian problem in a global context; Podhoretz just isn't.

It is tempting for people of limited experience and imagination to ascribe arguments based on assumptions radically different from those with which one is familiar to insanity or some other form of mental defect. This temptation is yielded to often these days, perhaps more often than in the past because a key point of American reference -- the policy judgment of the incumbent administration -- is one in which Americans have at the moment dramatically reduced confidence. Of course it is also true that basic assumptions are less easily compromised than analysis.

This is why Podhoretz sounds so unreasonable. It isn't that his analysis is flawed or his style of argument is grating, but that his assumptions as to what is most important are radically different than those of most people in this country. I am actually sympathetic to those assumptions, at least insofar as I can understand what they are based on. My own distance from his position is based on my own assumptions -- chief among these being the absolute priority American national interests should have over all other considerations where foreign policy is concerned -- and on these I'm no more inclined to compromise than he is.

[Dan Q. Public]

Thank you, Zathras. There's a wide gulf between 'crazy' and 'operating on different goals.' But isn't it nice and easy to just elide whole arguments by waving the ad hominem wand instead of thinking about why someone might have a different world view?

[Guy in Jersey]

Nobody's actually arguing that Podhoretz is clinically "crazy". This term and other like it are used figuratively: They gloss an American citizen who so loudly and brazenly wants to put his own country and the lives of his fellow citizens at risk for the sake of another country. After Iran, it will be Syria, Lebanon, etc.

[Don Bacon]

Commenters are falling into the trap of referring to the Iran "threat" (Ilan and Zathras) and the Iran "problem" (Zathras). Iran is on good terms with all other countries in its region (except Israel) including especially the governments of Iraq and Afghanistan, as well as other countries in Asia and elsewhere. So the only "problem" is one that Israel has concocted, and there is no "threat". The simple facts are that (1) there can be no valid comparison of Iran with Nazi Germany and (2) there is no threat to be deterred, and to suggest otherwise plays into the hands of the warmongers.

Zakaria's comparison of Iran to an expansionist China which supported Vietnam against the US is simply crazy on many counts. China has never been expansionist, and China and Vietnam have always been enemies. And then for Zakaria to propose that the US contain Iran as it supposedly did China is amusing, since China and Iran are now best friends.

All of this indicates that foreign policy dialogue is reaching the heights of fantasy, and blood will flow as a result. But think of the money to be made.

[Zathras]

As I note upthread, basic assumptions are fairly important.

A significant number of Americans grounds its thinking on foreign policy on the assumption that their country is inherently virtuous, and must therefore be correct in whatever policy it is following at the moment. A considerably smaller number of Americans is sure that their country is inherently wicked, and is therefore prepared to wax enthusiastic toward any regime, movement or political figure willing to espouse hostility to the United States. This does not necessarily suggest their sympathy for Communism, say, or either the Sunni or Shiite variants of Islamist fanaticism. Neither would it have necessarily suggested their sympathy for Nazi ideology, though had they been around in the late 1930s they would certainly have denounced in righteousness the insanely corrupt and arrogant Roosevelt administration's undeniably hostile attitude toward the reasonable and inoffensive Mr. Hitler.

The United States is a very large, dynamic and constantly changing country. It is inevitable that such a country will produce in some of its citizens feelings of profound, personal and embittered alienation. These feelings will occasionally be reflected in public discussions of American foreign policy, but need not mislead or confuse us, any more than Norman Podhoretz's violent rhetoric, as long as we can recognize them for what they are.

[Kyle]

It's funny you should mention how everyone wanted to avoid WW1 and that the neocons never mention it. Have you ever heard of a neocon wanting to avoid a war? You get the boot from the club for that one, like Francis Fukuyama did. He's still pretty much with them but tried to advocate a less militaristic for of it and pretty much got ostracized for it.

[IM]

"It is inevitable that such a country will produce in some of its citizens feelings of profound, personal and embittered alienation"
Exactly! Just look at this alienated Podhoretz...
Is there any proof that Podhoretz cared at any time of this life about a) Israel b) Jews in general or c) the Holocaust? Podoretz is an mediocre man feeling always and by everybody snubbed. Negroes in his cildhood, later in sixties Norman Mailer and so on. His main literary output are books about himself, for Gods sake!
Murray effing Rothbard had his number decades ago and if even a libertarian can see through him I don't know there is the problem.

The guy is nattering about foreign policy because this gives him attention. He is choosing extremist positions and silly historical comparisons because this demands the least efort (even a lazy hack remenbers somewhat about Hitler).
No, P. doesn't thinks in terms like The Jews v. World but rather The World v. Norm P.

[IM]

By the way during the Iraq/Iran war, when Iran was still led by charismatic revolution leader Chomenei and not his tired heirs, Israel supported Iran.
Why is Iran supposed a bigger danger to Israel now?

[buy runescape]

then he let his friends all have some runescape money

[rf gold]

I hope i can get rf online gold in low price.
i buy rf money for you.

[WoKf gold]

Once I played kung fu, I did not know how to get strong, someone told me that you must have World of Kung fu Gold. That he gave me some WoKf gold.

[Entropia Universe Money]

It just like Entropia Universe Money. Buy Entropia Universe Gold is very easy.

[cheap shaiya gold]

you must borrow cheap shaiya gold from friends, or you could not continue this game without shaiya online gold.

[Replica Gucci handbags]

Once I played kung fu, I did not know how to get strong, someone told me that you must have World of Kung fu Gold. That he gave me some WoKf gold.

[Replica Gucci handbags]

you must borrow cheap shaiya gold from friends, or you could not continue this game without shaiya online gold.

[Bvlgari Jewelry]

you must borrow cheap shaiya gold from friends, or you could not continue this game without shaiya online gold.

[luxury watches]

I am so with you,rolex watch
luxury watch

[asdas]

The summer is coming,tiffany jewelry is your best choice.So you can choose a popular style tiffany jewelry for yourself.You will be more beautiful.

You may like 646-204 and 642-845,also you want to pass them.We can help you.

[ugg boots sale]

UGG Boots is your best ugg boots sale online Outlet where you can buy the cheapest
Ugg Boots.

[links of london]

Thanks for your comments!

[tiffany and co]

It was a very nice idea! Just wanna say thank you for the information you have shared. Just continue writing this kind of

post. I will be your loyal reader. Thanks again.

[24 Hour Locksmith]

Great Blog, author make some extreme valid points, keep up the good work.

locksmiths melbourne l locksmiths

-----------------------------
locksmiths melbourne

[Louis vuitton bags]

good

[cheap coach handbags]

Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!

[metin2 yang]

lili lilili

[chanel handbags]

Chanel Handbags are woman’s dream come true.

Chanel, a fashion name that has become synonymous with femininity since 100 years, is on the must-have list of every fashion-conscious woman.? And we bring these must-have Chanel Handbags at never before discounts, just for you.

It is only when you come across an Chanel New Arrivals, do you realize the power of her words.? Chanel handbags are crafted not just to be trendy, but trend-setting.? Hardly has lived a celebrity who has not been seen carrying a Chanel handbag under her arm; such has the influence of Chanel handbags as a fashion statement.

Chanel handbags have been so popular in the elite classes of the society, that their pricing is usually prohibitive for everyone else.? Discount Chanel handbags are really difficult to come across, but today should be your lucky day.? We bring you a superb unbeatable range of Chanel Flap bags, all at fantastic discounts.? With us, you have an incredible chance to buy your favorite Chanel handbags at rock bottom prices!

Chanel Handbags have always been at the forefront of luxury and style.? The Chanel classic quilted leather handbags and its reinventions have ruled fashion since forever.? Chanel handbags have remained extremely popular as they continue to merge evolving modern trends with the class and simplicity of its original avatar.

An Chanel 2008 Collection and Chanel 2009 Collection single handedly enhances the look you are carrying.? The reason you would buy a Chanel handbag is own a bag that mingles with your charm and intensifies it with its inherent simplicity.? If you have owned an authentic Chanel handbag before, you know what we are talking about.? If you are one of the unlucky people who haven’t yet gotten a chance to own an Chanel Cambon, now is your chance to shop for an authentic Chanel handbag and discover its ability to transform your look completely.

Buy Chanel handbags with us, and get fabulous discounts which you will never get at your favorite store.? We offer cheap authentic Chanel handbags and they are all up for grabs!

[caoch shoes]

Once you have

href="http://www.coachoutletusa.com/">coach wallet  ,

find out what day the store gets its
shipments in so that you can have your pick first of whichever C

title="" href="http://www.coachoutletusa.com/">coach

handbags  you want.All these are in the

href="http://www.coachoutletusa.com/">coach outlet

stores  web.

[jordan shoes]

day in depressed people wake up.

[Air Jordan 11]

Nice article.Always nice to read some tips concerning the appearance of our blogs.

[wholesale Acekard]

How to NOT Wear wholesale EZFlash 3-in-1 : Easy Tutorials The type of Adamo XPS of Dell wins the laurel of the thinnest laptop in the world with its definite advantage of the thickness, 9.99 mm. You See, OEM TF Memory Card Sweep over the Fashion Trend of Yaroslave

[R4]

this is really interesting! so amazing! http://www.r4fords.co.uk/

[China wholesale]

"Nike Skyforce Hi Nintendo Wii", founded in 1989, was donated to 5 million club members of Nintendo “Game World” first, and later was changed to monthly. Paris Woman Offer You How to Go With Screen Protector for iPhone Now it has become the best selling children reading in American, in 1990, it had readers of 6 millions. Nintendo's first created "counselor principle" counsels the customers via telephone line separately, to help the customers master the tips of the game to improve the skills and tastes, greatly improving customer’s loyalty.Choices of wholesale Dual SIM Cell Phone

[vikings jerseys]

Look here, Viking fans. Vikings is one of the best football team in NFL. Now he got the best QB RB and LB, will he do another greatest seaon in 2010? We are watching here. When you browse our website, you will find all newest and popular info. from it. All viking fans, if you are the real one. You will be watching on us. Got your best Vikings jerseys in our store.We have Purple,white,Blackshadow Minnesota vikings jersey in stock, and we also can make your own custom jerseys. Exclusive fans jerseys, hats in our website are waiting for you! Find your favorite Vikings authentic jerseys and get it shipped fast with 3-Day shipping on any size order for Free shipping.

[r4itt]

i have buy a game card for 6 days,but i havn't receive the card,do you bought game cards of the website named http://www.r4fords.co.uk?

[watches]

The sides are beautifully sculpted and the lugs extend from the bottom of the case in a way that compliments almost any strap,or the bracelet.The design is very fluid,and it sits perfectly on my wrist.Replica Kenneth Cole Watches is solid,smooth,and has a very vintage feel to it.The crown is a lovely size and features the Benarus three dolphin logo on its edge.The bezel is a Replica Jacques Lemans F1 120 click dive timer that fits the case perfectly with no play,wiggle or flex.Replica Immersion Watches of any case is in its details which is where the Moray excels.Its retro design seamlessly integrates with the solid end links of the bracelet.The dial is quite unique as well; Replica Jacques Lemans Watches is a very dark grey/black with a slightly tactile metallic tone -- not glossy or smooth.It's very hard to describe,and I have attempted to capture it in the photos.The markers and numbers on the dial are not inlaid but appear to be made of painted on C3 luminous paint.The lume is first rate; it charges quickly and lasted well into the night or through a movie.The hour and second hand have metallic edges while the minute hand has orange edges that cause it to stand out.This is my only issue with the Moray: I'm not a big fan of the continuity of the orange hand.It's not bad,but Replica Orient Watches really stands out.(The Ocean7 LM-2 has a similar orange minute hand,but it matches the orange accents on the reflector,second hand,and logo.)The dial is almost sterile,only indicating the brand,the automatic movement,and the water resistance.The date window is small and unobtrusive with white text on a black wheel located between the 4 and 5 markers.The dial design is very similar to that found on Panerai Replica Hamilton Watches,but the hands,date Replica Leonard Watches,and paint application has little in common with Panerai.

[r4i]

hello,Do you know this site named http://www.r4fords.co.uk? many people say the website is very good,there have many game cards such as

href="http://www.r4fords.co.uk/">r4 revolution sdhc,r4 sdhc upgrade revolution,

href="http://www.r4fords.co.uk/">r4 ultra sdhc, and so on.they have fun from the website named http://www.r4fords.co.uk. but i have no

idea.

[China wholesale]

Across the street were some clothes shops. He joyfully appreciated those shops one by one till the words “Ed Hardy Clothing” came to his eyes.VRS.But he couldn’t help taking look at the clothes inside the shop through its clean glass. He suddenly found a lot of “Ed Hardy” among the crowds. He imaged he had an Ed hardy clothing and smiled. He felt he was getting warm…Why Send Electronics Gadgets wholesale for BarbersMicro Sim Card Most First-Grade Picks Acknowledged in the World

[nhl jersey]

I would like an investigation into the people who force the banks to make loans to clients they would not otherwise approve. Just exactly why do you suppose banks make applicants go through such a difficult underwriting process? Is it so they can just discriminate or is it because they want to try and make good loans?

[seo-vancouver]

China doesn't have anything to do with Iran.I am disappointing.

[Egitim]

thanks for sharing Chat many people are pay more attention to one's wearing than before, especially a watch. Sohbet . Perhaps when you went to some place far away Chat you must borrow it from friends Sohbet you can get everything you want in this game
Chat money to invest in other industry which will return you good profit. Sohbet when you look at the surface of the watches Egitim from the city you live in and thought you knew nobody there Exsohbet . It sounds like you have a form of a disorder known as dermatillomania Chat excluded from activities and involvement in life; the dead are outside "the ring" of life. Sohbet