2004 all over again? Petraeus abandons strategy to keep casulaties down Posted by Max Bergmann

Fred Kaplan in his war stories column connects the dots...

So, what accounts for the decline in American deaths since the summer? It's hard to say for sure, but one little-reported cause is almost certainly a shift in U.S. tactics from fighting on the ground to bombing from the air.

An illustration of this shift occurred on Sunday, when U.S. soldiers were searching for a leader of a kidnapping ring in Baghdad's Sadr City. The soldiers came under fire from a building. Rather than engage in dangerous door-to-door conflict, they called in air support. American planes flew overhead and simply bombed the building, killing several of the fighters but also at least six innocent civilians. (The bad guy got away.)

In other words, though the shift means greater safety for our ground troops, it also generates more local hostility.

As I wrote yesterday, the quadrupling of airstrikes, along with the continued use of overly aggressive security contractors, totally undermines a counter-insurgency approach that emphasizes "protecting Iraqis." It seems that Petraeus has quietly abandoned his strategy in favor of the 2004 focus on force protection that got us nowhere.

So what exactly is Petraeus doing? Is this just another example of a sycophant General so concerned with public opinion that he is abandoning his stated strategy? At the very least he should explain why airstrikes have quadrupled.

Comments

[Zathras]

The most likely explanation is also the simplest: lack of manpower.

The increase in American combat personnel provided by the surge earlier this year allowed Petraeus to disperse more troops to neighborhoods in Baghdad in which Sunni Arabs lived in close proximity to Shiites, as well as to Anbar to support the tribes resistance to the al Qaeda groups, and to Diyala. There are still not nearly enough troops to hold the massive Sadr City slum, which unhappily is the base for JAM and other terrorist groups bent as much on killing Sunni Arabs as on fighting Americans. Airpower is not a good substitute, but it's the only one available.

Incidentally, the superiority of infantry assaults to precision air strikes in built-up areas like Sadr City as far as avoiding civilian casualties is not as evident as it may appear from reading the counterinsurgency manual. I know it is the manual that Goldenberg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air.

[Mike M.]

I have a great force protection idea. Deploy our troops stateside.

[Zathras]

Bergmann, not Goldenberg. My mistake.

[Chris]

Headline Typo: casu[al]ties. Not just a hardcore punk band.

[Metin2 gold]

Welcome to our game world, my friend asks me to buy some Metin2 yang . I do not know how to use the Cheap metin2 yang ; my friend tells me how to use. I will thank for my friends bringing me in this world. I am not regret to buy Cheap metin2 gold . We all love game, if you want to play it, please Buy metin2 gold and join us. Please do not hesitate to have game.

[Arua ROSE zuly]

It is the Rose zuly which make me very happy these days,
my brother says rose zulie is his favorite games gold he likes,
he usually buy some rose online zuly to start his game

[ghost gold]

It is necessary that ghost goldfor the game. You can earn your ghost moneyeasily if you have strong sense, quick and careful.

[cheap aoc gold]

Try your best and then you can get it. I buy cheap aoc gold, just because I like it. So simple the aoc money is.

[sadas]

The summer is coming,tiffany jewelry is your best choice.So you can choose a popular style tiffany jewelry for yourself.You will be more beautiful.

You may like 646-204 and 642-845,also you want to pass them.We can help you.

[ugg boots sale]

UGG Boots is your best ugg boots sale online Outlet where you can buy the cheapest
Ugg Boots.

[zhouhailei]

Authentic Products uggsline.co.uk provides all kinds of UGG Boots in high quality but lowest prices possible from UK. We frequently update the styles of uggsline Boots so please check back to choose your favourite Boots.
UGG boots sale

[cheap coach handbags]

Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!

[Orange County Appraiser]

I think There are still not nearly enough troops to hold the massive Sadr City slum.

[Find Senior Housing]

though the shift means greater safety for our ground troops, it also generates more local hostility.

[Homesure Services]

I think it is the manual that Goldenberg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air....

[Bathroom Vanities]

Rather than engage in dangerous door-to-door conflict, they called in air support.American planes flew overhead and simply bombed the building, killing several of the fighters but also at least six innocent civilians.

[San Diego Tax]

It seems that Petraeus has quietly abandoned his strategy in favour of the 2004 focus on force protection that got us nowhere.

[Mike Blouin]

I just read the article this you posted, well i gotta say it definitely makes you wonder thats for sure, but if its true which would be awesome, that is just a cool thing to know, Any info can be good info.

[LocalPosition.com]

American planes flew overhead and simply bombed the building, killing several of the fighters but also at least six innocent civilians.

[Danny DeMichele Photos]

The superiority of infantry assaults to precision air strikes in built-up areas like Sadr City as far as avoiding civilian casualties is not as evident as it may appear from reading the counterinsurgency manual.

[Mykalai Kontilai]

I know it is the manual that Golden-berg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air.

[Nightly Business Report]

I know it is the manual that Goldenberg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air. Thnaks

[InternetSlander.com]

It seems that Petraeus has quietly abandoned his strategy in favor of the 2004 focus on force protection that got us nowhere.

[Copywriting]

There are still not nearly enough troops to hold the massive Sadr City slum, which unhappily is the base for JAM and other terrorist groups bent as much on killing Sunni Arabs as on fighting Americans. Airpower is not a good substitute.

[GK Scott]

We frequently update the styles of uggsline Boots so please check back to choose your favourite Boots.

[William Cassarly]

Nice post,In other words, though the shift means greater safety for our ground troops, it also generates more local hostility..thanks for shared this with us.

[James Cassel]

President Petraeus? In the US, not a friggin’ chance you delusional braun-knase war monger.

[Eco Village]

I know it is the manual that Goldenberg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air.

[NewForeclosureOnline.com]

I know it is the manual that Goldenberg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air.

[Trade Key]

I know it is the manual that Goldenberg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air.

[Home Sure Services]

I gotta say it definitely makes you wonder thats for sure, but if its true which would be awesome, that is just a cool thing to know, Any info can be good info.

[Internet Slander Lawsuits]

Today I got a interesting information from y our blog and its very useful for me,thanks to share this grate stuff...

[Gatehouse Academy Reviews]

My question is that, "Why airstrikes have quadrupled?"

[Pet Care Rx Reviews]

American planes flew overhead and simply bombed the building, killing several of the fighters but also at least six innocent civilians.

[Buy Toyota Parts]

American planes flew overhead and simply bombed the building, killing several of the fighters but also at least six innocent civilians.

[Amy Laurent]

I think they haven't enough troops to hold the massive Sadr City slum, which unhappily is the base for JAM and other terrorist groups bent as much on killing Sunni Arabs as on fighting Americans. Airpower is not a good substitute, but it's the only one available.

[San Diego Oceanfront rentals]

Your article says that Petraeus has quietly abandoned his strategy in favor of the 2004 focus on force protection that got us nowhere.

[Bathroom Wholesale]

I gotta say it definitely makes you wonder thats for sure,but if its true which would be awesome,that is just a cool thing to know,Any info can be good info.

[Internet Marketing Consultants]

There are still not nearly enough troops to hold the massive Sadr City slum, which unhappily is the base for JAM and other terrorist groups bent as much on killing Sunni Arabs as on fighting Americans. ..thanks for shared this with us.

[New Foreclosure Online]

I know it is the manual that Goldenberg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air.

[Baby Nursery Accessories]

Here I find a great stuff to read thanks to share,have you some more interesting stuff..

[2010 ford Crown victoria parts]

It seems that Petraeus has quietly abandoned his strategy in favor of the 2004 focus on force protection that got us nowhere.Thanks for the excellent information!

[Naples Tour]

American planes flew overhead and simply bombed the building, killing several of the fighters but also at least six innocent civilians.

[Freight Brokering]

It is the manual that Goldenberg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air.

[Danny Demichele]

American planes flew overhead and simply bombed the building,killing several of the fighters but also at least six innocent civilians.

[Trent Jordan]

It is the manual that Golden-berg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air.

[Honda Parts]

It seems that Petraeus has quietly abandoned his strategy in favor of the 2004 focus on force protection that got us nowhere.Thanks for the interesting info.

[sell cell phones for cash]

I think it is the manual that Goldenberg is familiar with, but human shields are used for a reason, and that reason doesn't change whether Americans attack from the ground or the air.