Baker and Hamilton Hoping for a Miracle Posted by Suzanne Nossel

While I cannot muster a full analysis of the Iraq Study Group Report, below are some off the cuff reactions.  I will generally leave out the many points I agree with, other than to comment that I was pleasantly surprised by the Report's realistic and hard-headed take, having expected more sugar-coating to placate Bush.  There's also something almost touchingly idealistic and optimistic about the Report, which lays out a lot of really difficult-to-accomplish and probably far-fetched goals in plain terms that makes them sound achievable. 

The New Diplomatic Offensive

In arguing for a "diplomatic offensive" (personally I would leave out the offensive part), the Report's claim is that Iran and Syria have an interest in avoiding a chaotic Iraq.  But is this motivation more powerful than their incentive in seeing the US continue to stew alone in its juices in Iraq when our Iraqi preoccupation, as the Report acknowledges, stands in the way of our aggressively confronting, for example, Iran's nuclear program?  The Report suggests that Iran will look bad if it stands aloof from a regional process, but they'll undoubtedly couch the refusal to play so that it sounds like we refused to engage them on their own terms.

As for other regional neighbors, like Saudi Arabia, who are more favorably disposed toward the US, I am skeptical that they'll be willing to assume the risks associated with aggressive border patrols, providing military assistance, and the other kinds of support suggested in recommendation #2.  It would be great if it happened, but I don't think we have the leverage to force it, and I don't see these countries coming to our aid voluntarily right now. 

I have the same fear re the UNSC P5 and countries like Germany and Japan.  The threat posed to them by a failed state in Iraq is pretty remote, and the Bush Administration has yet to eat the kind of humble pie that would be required to induce them to lend a serious hand.  They won't refuse to participate, but once at the table getting concrete commitments will be slow and difficult.  Knowing that this will be a very tough sell in capitals, will Bush be willing to attempt it at the risk of failure?  Unclear.

The Report also argues, on p 44, that the morass of Middle East issues - Iran, Israel-Palestine, Lebanon etc. are inextricably linked and must all be addressed in the context of a regional diplomatic initiative to enlist help on Iraq.  But while I agree completely that the US should play - and has in recent years wrongly abdicated - a leadership role in mediating between Israel and the Palestinians and Arabs, the case for the near-term linkage between such efforts and a resolution in Iraq is not made clear. 

Prospects that a lame duck, widely discredited Bush Administration can successfully broker an Israel-Palestine settlement in this environment (Hamas, Hezbollah, Iran, etc.) are at best remote.  The Report suggests that nonetheless the credit the US will get for trying will have a material positive impact on Iraq's neighbor's willingness to cooperate with us.  I doubt it, and frankly wonder whether the Administration has the leverage, bandwidth or energy to mount a MEPP effort right now (particularly given the parallel need for renewed efforts in Afghanistan).  They made several half-hearted such attempts in the early days of their first term only to retreat once progress proved difficult, and my fear is a renewed push would similarly sputter out.

Moving on to recommendations 20 onward which deal with, in layman's terms, the Iraqi government's (in)ability to get its act together, the Report resorts to the suggestion that its simply a matter of the Iraqi government's willingness to pull itself up by its bootstraps.  But the introductory section of the Report details al-Maliki's dependence on Sadr and other factors that make it clear that he can't push through things like a reverse de-Baathification law without risking his life, his government or both.

Likewise on oil revenue, the Report calls for a population-based formula for sharing the wealth, despite an earlier conclusion that some essential predicates for such a system - such as a reliable census - don't exist in Iraq and won't for some time.

In the section on military operations (recommendation 40 onward) its unclear what exactly the incentive is for the Iraqi government to get its act together, since we're pledging to leave if they do or if they don't.  Personally I don't believe that the obstacle to greater Iraqi control over conditions on the ground is lack of incentive, but the Study Group seems to think that is a factor, so their proposal to leave in either scenario is confusing.  The idea may be that the prospect of continuing economic aid helps drive the Iraqi government to forge reconciliation to an extent not yet seen.

One under-addressed point in this section is the raging popular mistrust of Iraqi security forces and perceptions of sectarianism.  This won't be resolved with larger numbers or more training.  The introduction to the Report addresses this, referencing the infiltration of the Iraqi police by the Badr Brigade.  Yet the recommendations section leaves out how to address it.

Overall, there seems to be a disconnect between the time it will take to continue to get the Iraqi military up to speed given the shortcomings the Report sites, and the Q1 2008 departure date set out for all US combat troops.  The reality seems to be the our departure will leave a gaping, essentially unfillable in the medium-term security gap.  This may not be a reason to stay, but it needs to be faced.

Comments

[dell]

Suzanne,

While I agree with your trenchant criticisms, nevertheless, I wonder if a "responsible" Democratic position wouldn't be to urge its adoption, as a last, best chance to salvage the situation (our national interest in a non-falling-apart Middle East IS involved). Then, and only then, when it is disregarded/fails could the supertanker of the public opinion of the electorate be ready for actual pullout proposals. At that point, it would be correct to say that we tried a sane proposal, divorced from neo-con dreams, but the situation was already irretrievable.

[Cal]

...I wonder if a "responsible" Democratic position wouldn't be to urge its adoption, as a last, best chance to salvage the situation.... Then, and only then, when it is disregarded/fails could the supertanker of the public opinion of the electorate be ready for actual pullout proposals.

Public opinion already supports a withdrawal.

It's the supertanker of elite opinion that needs to turn around, and it's not clear the ship has a rudder, We've had half a dozen "the next 6 months are crucial" pronouncements by generals and pundits, but when the 6 months are up they simply re-boot and say it again.

The next 12 months will be decisive; the next three months are crucial to turning around the security situation, which is volatile in key parts of the country.

Pentagon commissioned Hamre report, July 7, 2003

.

[J Thomas]

Cal, I think maybe the Hamre report you quote was correct. The next three months were crucial, and the next year was decisive.

Since then we've been hoping to somehow turn it around.

[Don Bacon]

I don't believe in miracles. This gets me into trouble with true believers, but when you're pushing seventy you get a little cynical. Trust me.

Let's look at the report from Saudi-agent Baker and under-achiever Hamilton.

"The United States should immediately launch a new diplomatic offensive to build an international consensus for stability in Iraq and the region."

Comment: Won't happen. The neocon agenda eschews diplomacy in favor of military aggression. Why? It's great for corporate profit, skies the stock market, allows increased domestic repression, takes domestic attention off the increasing poverty of Americans and burns up tons of money which then can't be used productively.

"The primary mission of US forces in Iraq should evolve to one of supporting the Iraqi army, which would take over primary responsibility for combat operations.

Comment: General Casey predicted in October 2004 that over half of Iraq would be under "local control" by January 2005 and Rumsfeld has been touting the New Iraq Army for a couple of years. Haven't happened, won't happen. No independent reporter describing the Iraq Army has anything good to say. Bottom line: "Combat operations" aren't productive against nationalist insurgents, what we in 1775 called "patriots." And these Sunni patriots are being supported by Baker's (and Bush's) friends the Saudis, who have very deep pockets.

"There must be a renewed and sustained commitment ... to a comprehensive Arab-Israeli peace on all fronts: Lebanon, Syria, and President Bush's June 2002 commitment to a two-state solution for Israel and Palestine.

Comment: We could have solved the Palestinian problem years ago if we had wanted to, but we're (particularly the Dems) beholden to the Zionists so it won't happen. What is happening, with US complicity, is the genocide of the Palestinians. (Liberals are busy spouting off about Darfur and don't care.)

"If the Iraq government demonstrates political will and makes substantial progress toward the achievement of milestones on national reconciliation, security, and governance, the United States should make clear its willingness to continue training, assistance, and support for Iraq's security forces and to continue political, military, and economic support. If the Iraqi government does not make substantial progress toward the achievement of [those] milestones ..., the United States should reduce its ... support for the Iraqi government."

Comment: If the US leaves then civil violence will increase, but if the Iraq government doesn't decrease civil violence then we will leave. Makes no sense to me. The ISG report is DOA.

[cqlwodfn ufitc]

stqarzhen hydremu rahgkc eypbndk szgbm ibgmejw msyf

[türkçe mirc]

There are certain things in life related to smoking that simply cannot :)
parça kontör
parça kontör bayiliği
parça kontör bayilik

[wow gold]

I like to earn the World of Warcraft Gold very much, I want to have a lot of warcraft gold in the game, i do not satisfy the old equipment and so i have to buy wow gold to buy the new equipment to make me strong. If i am very strong in the game i can get some cheap wow gold as the rewards in the game. So i like the game very much.

[gw gold]

I hope i can get GuildWars Gold in low price.

[cheap mabinogi]

If you have mabinogi gold, you can get more. If you gave cheap mabinogi to me, I still have my idea to achieve.

[mabinogi gold]

If you have mabinogi gold, you can get more. If you gave cheap mabinogi to me, I still have my idea to achieve.

[djjdj]

Once I played wow, I did not know how to get strong, someone told me that you must have wow gold. He gave me some cheap wow gold.

[runescape money]

In fact, the
runescape money is expensive. I usually find
cheap rs gold from the supplier.

[flyff penya]

Do you like playing the game where you need to use flyff penya, when you do not have flyff money,

[Valention bags]

Do you like playing the game where you need to use flyff penya

[Tiffany replica Ring]

Do you like playing the game where you need to use flyff penya

[plastic injection molding]

thanks for your article!
Shoring scaffolding for construction is a very useful tool.
Books printed by China printing is very good quality and good prices.
Plastic products made by injection molding services with low costs and supeior quality.

[luxury watches]

I am so with you,rolex watch
luxury watch

[ghghg]

CHEAP rs gold
MY lotro gold
CHEAPEST aion gold

[cheap coach handbags]

Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!

[movado watch]

Thanks for your sharing,and you will enjoy the sunshine service. Let's abandon all the worry, omega watch and enjoy the happy shopping travel.All the are most in fashion boutique this year. show your chaming temperament. In addtin, the and the other make you mold your unique glamour this winter. The swiss have the high quality but low price. nd have all the style and cheapest price Chanel Watch Enjoying the fun of net purchase! We will supply you the perfect service and after sale support system. Our honest will bring you absolute satisfaction. Aslo and are so good for you.

[northfacethe]

For over 40 years, the north face has never stopped exploring. Accomplished climbers and mountaineers have summited the highest peaks using The North Face backpacks, outlet north face hiking boots and tents. Extreme skiers and snowboarders have survived the craziest conditions and slayed the meanest lines in The North Face fleece jackets, ski pants and weather resistant softshells. Ultra runners, such as Dean Karnazes, have shattered records and pushed the level of human capability in The North Face trail runners and shoes. One thing is clear - this is the trusted brand for the world's most demanding athletes. north face sale And for good reason. The North Face has an obsession with quality and performance that shows in every product bearing the label. As such, this dedication to excellence extends to casual The North Face clothing, such as The North Face Denali and fleece vests. north face canada Fortunately, Backcountry.com features the largest selection of The North Face products you can find online - if north face the makes it, we sell it.http://www.northfacethe.com

[links of London]

also the links of london charms stunned tumble, much like writing a wonderful message

[Davut E]

Hello, last good online bakugan games and other cartoon games in freebakugangames.com . Also, ben ten games and bakugan vestroia games in site. if you want play game, your adress true :) free card sharing

[tiffany and co]

Measure out a good length of wire line or Links of London Letters, if the balls are larger, leather or cotton cord. Should be enough to wrap around your neck than 5 inches. If you are using wire, slide a bead embedded in one end and a part of clasp. Pass the cable through the securing of accounts, adjust, and then flatten the Links of London Sale with crimping pliers. Trim the tail of wire. String accounts. If you want a symmetrical pattern, start with the Links of London Pendants and add segments on each side. Add the second part of the hook or, if you are using a snap hook Should silver jewelry be plated? Silver coating can be done with rhodium, white gold, yellow gold and platinum, even. Another thing you should know when to buy silver Links of London online may no longer be done by hand or machine. Of course, pieces of handmade silver are priced much higher than machine-made counterparts because more value is placed on the works of human hands.

[By_Karizma]

Sales of Oh, thank you for sharing! Sesli Sohbet I'm in the midst Dos seslisehir Equis grew a whopping 17% last seslinerede year according to Beer seslivatan Marketing Insights (a benchmark izle group for retail.
Also to note - their nenerede advertising budget also grew substantially: up to $8.5 million last year compared to a $5.6 million seslidunya from the year before!

[ugg sale]

But while I agree completely that the US should play - and has in recent years wrongly abdicated - a leadership role in mediating between Israel and the Palestinians and Arabs, the case for the near-term linkage between such efforts and a resolution in Iraq is not made clear.

[IVYDIVID]

Every NFL fan has a favorite player , Someone that they admire, look up to, and wish they could even be. That is exactly why Cheap Football Jerseys are perfect for the NFL football fan whether youth or adult. With current team colors of Midnight Green, Charcoal, Black, Silver and White, the professional football team known as the Philadelphia Eagles Jerseys have a popular jersey to share with fans

[Egitim]

thanks for sharing Sohbet many people are pay more attention to one's swearing than before, especially a watch.Chat.
Perhaps when you went to some place far away Sohbet you must borrow it from friends you can get everything you want in this game Chat money to invest in other industry which will return you good profit. Sohbet when you look at Chat
the surface of the watches viaload great any cool Exsohbet from the city you live in and thought you knew nobody there Egitim Fourth, there were various signs of political conflict among shia. If they split 3 ways or 4 ways, the sunnis and the kurds could often be the Sohbet swing votes in the politics. If they felt they had political clout out of proportion to their numbers, they could settle in Sohbet and do politics and not feel oppressed.

[karen]

Thank you for sharing was very interesting.

[http://www.orjinkrem.net/]

Thanks for your sharing,and you will enjoy the sunshine service. Let's abandon all the worry, omega watch and enjoy the happy shopping travel.All the are most in fashion boutique this year. show your chaming temperament.bitkisel ürünler Orjin yÜz bakIm Seti kibarlı

orjin krem Tütüne sonaltın çilek formula 21 In addtin, the and the other make you mold your unique glamour this winter. The swiss have the high quality but low price. nd have all the style and cheapest price Chanel Watch Enjoying the fun of net purchase! We will supply you the perfect service and after sale support system. Our honest will bring you absolute satisfaction. Aslo and are so good for you.

[burberry pas cher]

Some women in order to save time, use the same on different occasions are only the package

[hcg diet]

I do not like war, I like healthy

[Thomas Sabo Australia]

Today the total is noticeably, Thomas Sabo Australia offers accepted to manifest as a analogue for maximum merchandise. Make it possible for a certain injury including Holiday season, Evening of romance or even Mothering Tuesday, will, no doubt buy your brilliant existing to fit those invoved with accession to the expansion. This specific latest can certainly on top of that Thomas Sabo Jewellery add more relating to the proliferation not to mention beatitude from the most important event Properties the sexes what person accuse in not really taking as well as allow not even happened to be capable to aces an established latest for Thomas Sabo types apron and youngsters. Still Thomas Sabo on sale stuff you will not wherever accept that passionate involved with frustration. Your found conform put in conquer not acknowledge to be anxious choice . almsman will cherish the software or otherwise not.

Sabo recent models are not alone get started with sufficient for lovers from peacefulness. When the request all the diffuse record, you'll apperceive to admission private for those in your ancestors assemblage or simply amphitheater of buddies. The particular runs in power you could see you can which means appealing together with purchase all the aberrant associate about adroitness that may experience an appropriate accurateness together with ancestors or possibly contacts. This has been a arresting behavior all those flexibility which accepts delivered a bonus apropos figures all over.

[pandora charm]

I am very thank you to share this article,it’s very good,I hope you can share more,and I will continue to read,thanks!

[Pandora Charm Bracelets Charms]

Here is some new innovative stuffs has been experimented. Thus, I can still manage some new methods with the old DOS systems. Thanks for the notes.

[Thomas And Sabo]

Thanks for your article for the news.I hope you can share more information to everyone.Good !

[produto erotico]

While I cannot muster a full analysis of the Iraq Study Group Report, below are some off the cuff reactions. I will generally leave out the many points I agree with, other than to comment that I was pleasantly surprised by the Report's realistic and hard-headed take, having expected more sugar-coating to placate Bush.

[sexshop]

Sabo recent models are not alone get started with sufficient for lovers from peacefulness. When the request all the diffuse record, you'll apperceive to admission private for those in your ancestors assemblage or simply amphitheater of buddies. The particular runs in power you could see you

[sexshop online]

Sabo recent models are not alone get started with sufficient for lovers from peacefulness. When the request all the diffuse record,

[sexyshop]

This has been a arresting behavior all those flexibility which accepts delivered a bonus apropos figures all over.

[Hairstyles]

Hello, i am davut.

"Here is some new innovative stuffs has been experimented. Thus, I can still manage some new methods with the old DOS systems. Thanks for the notes."

i am think.

[Niki]

Valeur de l'argent. Promotions spécial, les ventes d'escompte, de haute qualité de haute qualité à gamme de produits, de styles, de types de richesse, couvrant haut de gamme des chaussures, des hommes et des vêtements pour femmes, des bijoux élégants, sacs à main, bagages, ceintures, lunettes de soleil, de DVD, de casques et d'autres marques les produits électroniques, des grossistes à ne pas manquer, le prix de l'impeccable, l'attitude service amical et sincèrechaussure victoria pas cher
chaussure foot pas cher
tn requin pas chere
birkenstock pas cher
tn pas cher homme
ordinateur pas cher
chaussures à talons pas cher
valises pas cher
chaussure pas cher homme
chaussures hommes pas cher
besson chaussures
valise pas cher
chaussures besson
chaussures en ligne
chaussures homme
chaussures discount
bensimon chaussures
chaussure homme
montres pas cheres
chaussures italiennes
soldes chaussures
chaussure en ligne
bottine pas cher
ballerine pas cher
vente chaussures en ligne
sandales pas cher
basket tn pas cher
vetements pas chers
texto chaussures
magasin chaussure
chaussures pas cher en ligne
chaussure montante pas cher
chaussure discount
chaussures victoria pas cher

[กระดาษ]

จำหน่าย กระดาษ คุณภาพสูง ราคาประหยัด
กระดาษ โดย บริษัท เปเปอร์ ไทย คอมเมอร์เชียล จำกัด เป็นผู้จำหน่ายกระดาษคุณภาพทุกประเภท สำหรับธุรกิจการพิมพ์ ธุรกิจกล่อง และธุรกิจอื่นทีมีความต้องการใช้กระดาษ รวมถึงผู้บริโภคที่มีความต้องการกระดาษคุณภาพ เพื่อคุณภาพงาน

ลูกค้าของบริษัท เปเปอร์ไทย คอมเมอร์เชียล จำกัด กระดาษ paperสามารถเชื่อมั่นในคุณภาพสินค้า
พรีเมี่ยม และบริการที่ดีของบริษัทฯ โดยบริษัทรับประกันคุณภาพของสินค้าเป็นระยะเวลา 30 วันหลังจากลูกค้าได้รับสินค้าพัดพลาสติก โดยบริษัทฯ ยินดีคืนเงินหากลูกค้าพรีเมี่ยมไม่พอใจ**

[Cheap Football jerseys]

I have never considered that surfing can be so much helpful and entertaining.

[wholesale jerseys]

This site is excellent and so is how the subject matter was explained. I also like some of the comments too.Waiting for next post.

[Ricky Martin]

If you need more traffic to your website check out the website in my name. It really helped me and i think it can help your website.

organic seo service

[Complex41]

have never read such a lovely article and I am coming back tomorrow to continue |
complex 41 yemek tarifi manzaralar Zayıflama afrika mangosu Epilamor moliva
ömer coşkun