Democracy Arsenal

« While Washington Slept | Main | Elections in Egypt: Time to Back Up Our Rhetoric with Action »

October 31, 2005

Security Council Unites Against Syria in Hariri Slaying
Posted by Suzanne Nossel

The UN registered another point of proof that the rumors of its demise are exaggerated:  the Security Council coalesced around a tough consensus resolution challenging Syria to cooperate fully with the continuing investigation into the death of Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri, or face consequences.  Algeria, China and Russia all went along along once the US, France and Britain agreed to strike language referencing sanctions if the Syrian obligations are not met, with the proviso that the resolution be adopted under Chapter Seven of the UN's Charter which specifically references enforcement mechanisms including sanctions and military force.

While this was not unexpected, nor should the accomplishment be dismissed.  The world is, at least for now, united in isolating a rogue state.  We have been unable to achieve similar with respect to Iraq, Iran, North Korea, Sudan and other outlaw regimes.   The real proof of the UN's mettle, of course, will come only if - -  as seems almost inevitable - - Bashar Assad's compliance with the investigation is incomplete and further measures are warranted.

But in the meantime let's touch briefly on a few reasons why, at least thus far, UN diplomacy is working better than usual in this case.   The cohesion and will to act derive in part from the specifics of the incident itself - a public assassination of a wildly popular former leader by the government of an occupying country.  But certain other aspects of what's unfolding transcend the Hariri case itself and have implications for US diplomacy at the UN:

1.   Generation of Objective Evidence - Innuendo, circumstantial evidence and even US intelligence weren't enough to rally the world against Syria.  But the findings of an independent, UN-appointed expert prosecutor were.   We dismissed the role of UN weapons inspectors in Iraq but had weapons been there, in retrospect it seems incontrovertible that the teams would eventually have found them and that, if they did, the UNSC would have been forced to act.  Rather than expecting the UN members to take our word for things, the extra time and effort to allow them to gather facts objectively will tend to pay off.

2.  Patience - The simple fact that the US is in no hurry for Syrian regime change and has been willing to allow the Mehlis investigation to run its course makes a big difference.  Behind the scenes of today's resolution was undoubtedly an agreement that if the Syrians indeed stonewall, sanctions will come later.  The UN moves painfully slowly, but allowing enough time to quiet all doubts and to "give a chance" to recalcitrant regimes is sometimes what it takes to build consensus.

3.   No (Public) Foregone Political Conclusions - That the US is too mired up in Iraq and other things to be able to handle Syrian disintegration helps a lot here.  If Algeria, China and Russia were convinced we wanted Assad out and quickly, they'd be far less likely to accede to the ratcheting up of  pressure on the regime.  By contrast, because the US made so nakedly clear that it would be satisfied with nothing less than Saddam Hussein's ouster, other countries resisted all forms of cooperation with us on Iraq for fear of abetting a US-led coup.  Even if Bush and Co. believe that nothing less than toppling Assad will do the trick, the decision not to flaunt their long-term designs is making it easier to sustain consensus.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c04d69e200d834626a5e69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Security Council Unites Against Syria in Hariri Slaying:

» Tough Resolution Against Syria Passed from Unpartisan.com Political News and Blog Aggregator
The U.N. Security Council unanimously adopted a resolution Monday demanding Syria's full cooperation [Read More]

Comments

Interesting, Ms. Nossel -- you expend hundreds of words in praise of the recent workings of the UNSC, with nary a mention of Ambassador Bolton? Are you incapable of offering praise for our new U.S. Ambassador?

Bolton deserves some credit for this, at least from what I can tell.

Yes, then do throw the poor guy a bone in your main post sometimes...

Figo asks the right question there. You seem remarkably reticent to admit that Bolton deserves credit where most people are looking.

北京网页设计
网页设计
网站建设
网站推广
法语
钟表
塔钟
钟表
塔钟
钟表
机票
飞机票
国际机票
打折机票
机票
飞机票
国际机票
打折机票
国际机票
打折机票
家用中央空调
格力中央空调
口腔溃疡
复发性口腔溃疡
白塞氏病
白塞氏综合症
扁平苔藓
口腔扁平苔藓
琥珀
三面翻
自动麻将桌
麻将
扑克
色子
牌技
透视麻将
透视扑克
乳腺增生
助听器
助听器
助听器
助听器
助听器
助听器
助听器
助听器
发电机
发电机组
柴油发电机
发电设备
发电机出租
康明斯
发电机
发电机组
柴油发电机
发电设备
发电机出租
康明斯
助听器
乳腺增生
充气床|充气用品|充气游泳池|野营用品|户外用品|充气船|气垫床
激光对中仪|激光几何测量仪|机械轴承故障检测仪|机械故障试验台
发电机|发电机组|柴油发电机|发电设备|发电机出租|康明斯
从化旅游|从化温泉|从化酒店|从化旅游网|从化|从化地图|从化碧水湾|碧水湾温泉|碧水湾温泉度假村
从化|从化旅游|从化仙沐园温泉|从化旅游局|从化森林公园
家用中央空调 格力中央空调
发电机|发电机组|柴油发电机|柴油发电机组
进口轴承|nsk轴承|SKF轴承|轴承
进口轴承|skf轴承|nsk轴承
轴承|进口轴承|skf轴承|fag轴承
从化旅游
从化五道菜
从化荔枝|从化荔枝节
从化湖光度假山庄
从化地图
从化碧水湾|碧水湾温泉度假村
google排名
火车票 火车票预定 火车票查询
google排名-机票,国际机票,助听器,整形,整容
视频会议
防雷
成人用品|性用品|性器具|性保健品|滋阴壮阳|文胸
男自慰器|减肥品|情趣内衣|催情|成人用品|调情露
避孕|避孕套|性玩具|成人保健|减肥|丰胸|催情水
google排名|Adwords帐户|网页优化|搜索引擎优化技术

The comments to this entry are closed.

Subscribe
Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Email: 
Powered by TypePad

Disclaimer

The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use